Shonfield v. State

• Decision Date: 16 October 1925
• Docket Number: 24,924
• Citation: Shonfield v. State, 196 Ind. 579, 149 N.E. 53 (Ind. 1925)
• Parties: Shonfield v. State of Indiana
• Court: Indiana Supreme Court

149 N.E. 53

196 Ind. 579

Shonfield v. State of Indiana

No. 24,924

Supreme Court of Indiana

October 16, 1925

INDICTMENT.---Affidavit charging commission of crime at future date insufficient and motion to quash should be sustained.---An affidavit charging that a crime was committed at a future date is insufficient and a motion to quash on that ground should be sustained.

From Delaware Circuit Court; Clarence W. Dearth, Judge.

Rudolph Shonfield was convicted of rape, and he appeals.

Reversed.

A. E Needham, for appellant.

Arthur L. Gilliom, Attorney-General and George M. Barnard, for the State.

OPINION

Gemmill, J.

The appellant was charged by affidavit with the crime of rape upon a female child under the age of consent.He was tried by jury and convicted of assault and battery.Judgment of fine and imprisonment was rendered on the verdict.He has appealed from said judgment.

One of the errors assigned is that the court erred in overruling the motion of appellant to quash the affidavit.The affidavit was filed on June 25, 1924, and it alleges that the crime therein charged was committed on or about October 1, 1924.The state by the attorney general, has filed a confession of error herein, part of which is as follows: "The court erred in overruling appellant's motion to quash the affidavit for it appears upon the face thereof that the date laid upon which the offense was alleged to have been committed was subsequent to the date of filing the affidavit."If a future date is given in an indictment or affidavit, same is insufficient.State v. Noland(1867), 29 Ind. 212;Hutchinson v. State(1878), 62 Ind. 556;Murphy v. State(1886), 106 Ind 96, 5 N.E. 767, 55 Am. Rep. 722;State v. Patterson(1887), 116 Ind. 45, 18 N.E. 270;Terrell v. State(1905), 165 Ind. 443, 75 N.E. 884, 2 L. R. A. (N. S.) 251, 112 Am. St. 244, 6 Ann. Cas. 851;Boos v. State(1914), 181 Ind. 562, 105 N.E....