Sims v. Sims

Decision Date30 January 1987
PartiesBilly SIMS, as Executor of the Estate of Fannie M. Sims, Deceased v. Albert T. SIMS, et al. 85-535.
CourtAlabama Supreme Court

Bill Kominos of Fuqua & Kominos, Ozark, for appellant.

William H. Filmore, Ozark, for appellees.

BEATTY, Justice.

Appeal by plaintiff, the executor of the estate of Fannie M. Sims, from summary judgment for the defendants, Albert T. Sims, et al., in plaintiff's suit to quiet title to certain land in Dale County. We affirm.

The real property in question consists of 160 acres, more or less, conveyed in 1911 by Mazzie Woolley and her husband, W.P. Woolley, to T.W. Sims, a/k/a Tell Sims, for a consideration of $1,000.

T.W. Sims was married twice. His first wife was Daisy Sims. T.W. and Daisy had three children: Albert, Herman, and Frankie. Herman is deceased; his survivors are his widow, Dee Fant Sims, and their two daughters, Becky Surrency and Mary Lee Pitts.

Following the demise of Daisy Sims, and after he had purchased the property in question, T.W. Sims married Fannie Sims in 1911. T.W. and Fannie had eight children. With the exception of a two-year period, T.W. and Fannie Sims lived on the land in question until 1945, the year T.W. died intestate.

During the time that T.W. and Fannie lived on the property, several transactions concerning it occurred. In 1915, T.W. and Fannie Sims executed a mortgage on the property in favor of L.B. Sims, to secure an indebtedness of $290.30. This mortgage was satisfied in January 1924. During the pendency of this mortgage, T.W. and Fannie gave a warranty deed on October 23, 1923, to certain timber on this real property to the Ozark Lumber Company for a consideration of $500.

On April 5, 1926, T.W. and Fannie executed a mortgage on this property in favor of Mrs. S.L. Moncill to secure an aggregate indebtedness of $1,000, as evidenced by ten installment notes to become due annually. The first five of these notes were for $200 each, and they were due on October 15 in successive years beginning in 1926 and ending in 1930. The other five notes represented differing amounts of interest at 8 percent and were, likewise, payable on October 15 in successive years from 1926 to 1930. These notes were as follows: One note for $36.95 due October 15, 1926; one note for $56.00 due October 15, 1927; one note for $42.00 due October 15, 1928; one note for $28.00 due October 15, 1929; and one note for $14.00 due October 15, 1930. This mortgage was satisfied in 1935.

On February 18, 1929, T.W. and Fannie conveyed the 160 acres by warranty deed to C.J. Sims, the brother of T.W., for a consideration of $243.75.

Thereafter, in October 1934, T.W. and Fannie, who were still occupying this 160 acres, granted to one P.C. Benedict an oil and gas lease to this property for a term of five years for a consideration of $1.00 and a one-eighth royalty on the gas produced.

In 1935, T.W. received a right-of-way deed from Mrs. J.H. Marley covering a road to this 160-acre tract, which the Simses continued to occupy. And, in 1938, T.W. mortgaged this property under the Emergency Farm Mortgage Act of 1933 to the Land Bank Commission to secure a loan indebtedness of $1,000. This was satisfied in 1944, and, in the next year, 1945, T.W. died intestate.

In 1972, the eight children of T.W. and Fannie Sims conveyed their interest in the property in question to their mother.

This suit was brought in 1983 by Fannie Sims to quiet title in her name to the 160-acre tract. The defendants, Albert Sims, Frankie Sims Wright (children of T.W. and Daisy Sims), and Rebecca Surrency and Mary Lee Pitts (children of Herman Sims, deceased, who was also a child of T.W. and Daisy Sims), answered by claiming a three-elevenths interest in the property and they sought a sale for division.

Plaintiff Fannie Sims moved for summary judgment, submitting the affidavits of Billy Sims, James R. Fuqua, and Fannie Sims. Defendants responded with a memorandum and the affidavit of Rebecca Ann Surrency. Discovery ensued, with depositions of Fannie Sims, Albert T. Sims, and Rebecca Sims Surrency being taken. Several additional affidavits were filed by the parties. Defendants also moved for summary judgment. Meanwhile, Fannie Sims died, and, subsequently, Billy Sims, as executor of the estate of Fannie Sims, was substituted as the plaintiff. Lenora Duato and Susie Longman, heirs of C.J. Sims, were also added as parties defendant.

In due course, a hearing was held on the summary judgment motions. The plaintiff's motion was denied. The defendants' motion was granted, with the trial court entering an order finding the following facts:

"On February 18, 1929, T.W. Sims and Fannie L. [M.] Sims purportedly conveyed the property in question to C.J. Sims. The Court finds from the undisputed evidence in the case, that C.J. Sims never took possession of the property and that T.W. Sims remained in possession of the property after the purported conveyance until the time of his death. The Court further finds that the heirs of C.J. Sims never considered that the purported instrument conveyed the land to C.J. Sims. The Court further finds from the undisputed evidence in the case that a mortgage to Mrs. S.L. Moncill was satisfied in 1935 and that the amount necessary to satisfy this mortgage was approximately the same amount as recited as consideration in the purported deed; that in 1934, Fannie Sims and T.W. Sims leased the oil and gas rights to P. [C.] Benedict on the property in question; that in 1938, Fannie Sims and T.W. Sims mortgaged the property in question to the Land Bank Commission and that in 1935, T.W. Sims received a right-of-way deed to the property in question. The Court further finds, from the deposition of the plaintiff, that it is evident that the plaintiff did not consider the land as being sold to C.J. Sims.

"The Court finds, from the undisputed evidence concerning the conduct of the parties after the purported conveyance was made and from the testimony of the plaintiff, that the property in question was not conveyed to C.J. Sims, that neither he nor his heirs have claimed ownership to the property and the instrument was executed as security for a debt and therefore T.W. Sims owned the property when he died in 1945."

On appeal, the plaintiff maintains that title to the land in question ripened in Fannie Sims by adverse possession...

To continue reading

Request your trial
6 cases
  • Justice v. Arab Lumber and Supply, Inc.
    • United States
    • Alabama Supreme Court
    • September 9, 1988
    ...judgment as to make it plainly erroneous, palpably incorrect, or manifestly unjust. Gaston v. Ames, 514 So.2d 877 (Ala.1987); Sims v. Sims, 502 So.2d 722 (Ala.1987); Goza v. Goza, 470 So.2d 1262 (Ala.Civ.App.1985). Where the evidence before the trial court is undisputed, however, the ore te......
  • Harris v. M & S Toyota, Inc.
    • United States
    • Alabama Supreme Court
    • January 11, 1991
    ...that determination is properly grounded in the law. Progressive Specialty Ins. Co. v. Hammonds, 551 So.2d 333 (Ala.1989), and Sims v. Sims, 502 So.2d 722 (Ala.1987). Accordingly, the trial court's order of a new trial is affirmed, and the cause is 89-404--APPLICATION GRANTED; ORIGINAL OPINI......
  • McCrary v. Butler
    • United States
    • Alabama Supreme Court
    • February 10, 1989
    ...King v. Travelers Insurance Co., 513 So.2d 1023, 1026 (Ala.1987); see also Moore v. Williams, 519 So.2d 1337 (Ala.1988); Sims v. Sims, 502 So.2d 722 (Ala.1987). There is no arbitrary test as to whether a partnership exists, but such a determination will be made upon all of the attendant cir......
  • Eldridge v. Loftis
    • United States
    • Alabama Supreme Court
    • April 10, 1998
    ...to his first four children, the holders of a remainder interest. A life tenant cannot possess adversely to a remainderman. Sims v. Sims, 502 So.2d 722 (Ala.1987). Alternatively, even if we viewed the evidence as supporting a finding of a parol gift in 1950, the probate of the will in 1958 c......
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT