Smith v. Wendy's of the South, Inc.
Decision Date | 20 February 1987 |
Citation | 503 So.2d 843 |
Parties | Milton Thomas SMITH v. WENDY'S OF THE SOUTH, INC., and Robert Harland Matthews. 85-990. |
Court | Alabama Supreme Court |
Dennis J. Knizley of Alexander and Knizley, Mobile, for appellant.
Leon G. Duke and Frank G. Taylor of Sintz, Campbell, Duke, Taylor & Cunningham, Mobile, for appellees.
At the close of plaintiff Smith's malicious prosecution case, the trial court granted a directed verdict for the defendants, Wendy's of the South, Inc., and Robert Harland Matthews. Smith appeals. We affirm.
Smith was indicted by the Grand Jury of Mobile County for a robbery in the first degree at a Wendy's restaurant. The criminal proceedings were nol-prossed by the district attorney.
A directed verdict in favor of a defendant is proper only when there is no evidence to support one or more elements of plaintiff's cause of action. Smith v. Norman, 495 So.2d 536 (Ala.1986).
As this Court stated in Rose v. Miller & Co., 432 So.2d 1237, 1239 (Ala.1983):
For the trial court to have erred in directing the verdict for the defendants in this case, there must be some direct evidence or circumstantial evidence from which the jury could reasonably infer each of the following elements, which comprise a cause of action for malicious prosecution: (1) that a judicial proceeding was initiated by the defendants against Smith; (2) that the judicial proceeding was instituted without probable cause; (3) that the proceedings were instituted by the defendants maliciously; (4) that the judicial proceeding has been terminated in favor of Smith; and (5) that Smith suffered damage as a proximate cause of the prosecution. Kitchens v. Winn-Dixie Montgomery, Inc., 456 So.2d 45 (Ala.1984). In this case there was some evidence of elements (1), (4), and (5).
There was no evidence to support the second element (want of probable cause).
In Alabama Power Co. v. Neighbors, 402 So.2d 958, 967 (Ala.1981), this Court held:
" 'In malicious prosecution the general rule is that the finding of an indictment by a grand jury against one charged with crime is prima facie evidence of the existence of probable cause, and that the acquittal of a defendant upon the trial does not tend to show a want of probable cause for believing him guilty of the offense charged when the arrest [was] made or prosecution initiated....' "
Quoting Union Indemnity Co. v. Webster, 218 Ala. 468, 118 So. 794 (1928) (emphasis added in Neighbors ).
This prima facie showing of the existence of probable cause created by an indictment by a grand jury can be overcome by a showing that the indictment was "induced by fraud, subornation, suppression of testimony,...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
McConico v. Patterson
...as a proximate cause of the judicial proceeding. Eidson v. Olin Corp., 527 So.2d 1283, 1284 (Ala.1988) (citing Smith v. Wendy's of the S., Inc., 503 So.2d 843, 844 (Ala.1987) ). In entering the judgment dismissing McConico's malicious-prosecution claim, the trial court properly noted that"s......
-
Benjamin v. Hooper Electronic Supply Co., Inc.
...reasonable men and women could not have arrived at a verdict for the non-movant. Guerdon, supra at 1205; accord Smith v. Wendy's of the South Inc., 503 So.2d 843, 844 (Ala.1987) (If, by any interpretation, the evidence can support a conclusion in favor of the non-moving party, this Court mu......
-
Montgomery v. City of Montgomery
...and (5) that [the present plaintiff] suffered damage as a proximate cause of the judicial proceeding. Smith v. Wendy's of the South, Inc., 503 So.2d 843, 844 (Ala.1987)." Eidson v. Olin Corp., 527 So.2d 1283, 1284 (Ala.1988). The Eidson court further "`Malicious prosecution is an action dis......
-
McConico v. Patterson
...as a proximate cause of the judicial proceeding. Eidson v. OlinCorp., 527 So. 2d 1283, 1284 (Ala. 1988) (citing Smith v. Wendy's of the S., Inc., 503 So. 2d 843, 844 (Ala. 1987)). In entering the judgment dismissing McConico's malicious-prosecution claim, the trial court properly noted that......