Smithfield Estates, LLC v. Hathaway, C.A. PC-2003-4157

Decision Date15 August 2011
Docket NumberC.A. PC-2003-4157
PartiesSMITHFIELD ESTATES, LLC v. THE HEIRS OF JOHN M. HATHAWAY; JOHN J. RILEY; ESTATE OF JOHN J. RILEY; EUGENE F. RILEY; ESTATE OF EUGENE F. RILEY; JUDSON DAVIS; GRACE BOARDMAN; LEWIS T. GARDNER; MARY A. WHITTAKER; ESTATE OF MARY A. WHITTAKER; MARY MACAULEY; ESTATE OF MARY MACAULEY; SARAH A. GARFIELD; ESTATE OF SARAH A. GARFIELD; CHARLES H. RUSSELL; FRANKLIN M. RUSSELL; CHARLES H. SHIPPEE; ESTATE OF CHARLES H. SHIPPEE; JAMES B. CANNING; ESTATE OF JAMES B. CANNING; MARY A. MCGIN a/k/a MARY A. MCGINN; ESTATE OF MARY A. MCGIN a/k/a MARY A. MCGINN; CATHERINE F. MCGIN; ESTATE OF CATHERINE F. MCGIN; FRED M. SWARTS; ESTATE OF FRED M. SWARTS; CATHERINE BRESLIN; ESTATE OF CATHERINE BRESLIN; THOMAS ADAMS; ESTATE OF THOMAS ADAMS; MABLE A. ADAMS; ESTATE OF MABLE A. ADAMS; WILLIAM BISHOP; ESTATE OF MILLIE BISHOP; EDITH H. RICHARDSON; THOMAS H. PHILLIPS; ESTATE OF THOMAS H. PHILLIPS; ROSE PHILLIPS; ESTATE OF ROSE PHILLIPS; DEBORAH NORTH; ESTATE OF DEBORAH NORTH; CHRISTINA HEAP; HAROLD HEAP; TOM HEAP; FRED P. HEAP; ADA HEWITT; THOMAS S. HEAP; EUGENE CORCORAN; ESTATE OF EUGENE CORCORAN; MARIA CORCORAN; ESTATE OF MARIA CORCORAN; EDWARD KANE; EDWARD P. KANE, JR.; MARGARET M. KANE; GEORGIA PENTA; EVELYN DEL DONNO; GEORGE A. MOORE; ESTATE OF GEORGE A. MOORE; GEORGE H. MOORE; ESTATE OF GEORGE H. MOORE; ESTER MOORE; ESTATE OF ESTER MOORE; MARGARETTE MARA; ESTATE OF MARGARETTE MARA; ALPHONSE MALO; ESTATE OF ALPHONSE MALO; MARTIN LYONS AND WIFE; ESTATE OF MARTIN LYONS AND WIFE; DANIEL HOOD; CHRISTINA LIVINGSTON; THOMAS HINDLE AND WIFE; GEORGE HINDLE; THOMAS HINDLE; FANNY W. HINDLE; FRANK ROBARGE; ESTATE OF FRANK ROBARGE; JAMES RILEY; ESTATE OF JAMES RILEY; CHARLES LOCKWOOD AND WIFE; DOMENIC D'AMBRA; MARJORIE V. LOCKWOOD; JULIA J. LOCKWOOD; MARY A. GILLAN; ESTATE OF MARY A. GILLAN; E. HAVERLY; ESTATE OF E. HAVERLY; ANNIE SMYTHE; ESTATE OF ANNIE SMYTHE; MARY COLEMAN; ESTATE OF MARY COLEMAN; EUGENE CORCORAN; ESTATE OF EUGENE CORCORAN; MARIA CORCORAN; ESTATE OF MARIA CORCORAN; EDWARD KANE; EDWARD P. KANE, JR.; MARGARET M. KANE; JOSEPH FONT; ESTATE OF JOSEPH FONT; PATRICK KELLY; CATHERINE KELLY; ANN AGNEW; ESTATE OF ANN AGNEW; W.F. GRAHAM; ESTATE OF W.F. GRAHAM; MARGARET J. BRINDLE; ESTATE OF MARGARET J. BRINDLE; MARY A. MCGOUGH; ESTATE OF MARY A. MCGOUGH; THOMAS S. LANE; MARGARET T. MCGOUGH; ROBERT E. FITZGERALD; ESTATE OF ROBERT E. FITZGERALD; WILLIAM H. ROSE; ESTATE OF WILLIAM H. ROSE; HENRY BASIALEWICK; ESTATE OF HENRY BASIALEWICK; JAMES RILEY; ESTATE OF JAMES RILEY; WILLIAM E. KILROY; MARY A. KILROY; ANNA E. CULLION; LETITIA A. LEACH; EUGENIA M. WATSON; EDWIN F. LEACH; LETITIA A. BEARS; EUGENIA M. WATSON; ESTATE OF EUGENIA M. WATSON; ANN CASH; SAMUEL L. CASH; FANNI L. QUINSBY; ALICE C. RHIND; JOHN B. ADAMS; ESTATE OF JOHN B. ADAMS; SARAH ADAMS; ESTATE OF SARAH ADAMS; ARTHUR B. MULLEN; ESTATE OF ARTHUR B. MULLEN; JOSEPHINE MULLEN; ESTATE OF JOSEPHINE MULLEN; CHARLES W. FRASER; ESTATE OF CHARLES W. FRASER; PHILIP B. BANSH; ESTATE OF PHILIP B. BANSH; ISABELLA LANCASTER; ESTATE OF ISABELLA LANCASTER; BRIDGET HEANEY; ESTATE OF BRIDGET HEANEY; ELLEN M. COLLINS; ESTATE OF ELLEN M. COLLINS; MARY L. LONGWILL; ESTATE OF MARY L. LONGWILL; ANNIE A. RIELLY; ESTATE OF ANNIE A. RIELLY a/k/a ANNIE A. O'RIELLY; PATRICK MCKENNA; ESTATE OF PATRICK MCKENNA; HENRY S. BRIGGS AND WIFE; WALTER E. BARKER; ANNA E. MARION; EMILY L. REINNAGEL; CORNELIUS FRIEL; ESTATE OF CORNELIUS FRIEL; ELIZABETH JOHNSON; ESTATE OF ELIZABETH JOHNSON; GEORGE PERL BUCKLIN AND WIFE; ESTATE OF WIFE OF GEORGE PERL BUCKLIN; DOMENIC D'AMBRA; MARY E. SHIPPEE; ESTATE OF MARY E. SHIPPEE; PATRICK MCGUINNESS; ESTATE OF PATRICK MCGUINNESS; CHARLES MARKOFF; CHARLOTTE MARKOFF; SAMUEL A. MARKOFF; RUTH MARKOFF; MICHAEL RODGERS AND WIFE, ANNIE; ESTATE OF ANNIE RODGERS; JOHN J. RODGERS; MARY T. O'NEIL; ESTATE OF MARY T. O'NEIL; MARY O'NEIL; PETER REILLY; ESTATE OF PETER REILLY; BRIDGET REILLY; ESTATE OF BRIDGET REILLY; MARY A. O'BRIAN; ESTATE OF MARY A. O'BRIAN; LILLIE CLANCY; ESTATE OF LILLY CLANCY; JULIUS HERMAN OTTO; EMMA ZEUNER; ANNA ASHCROFT; BERTHA OTTO; HERMAN OTTO; GEORGE OTTO; GERTRUDE OTTO; ANNIE HANLEY; ESTATE OF ANNIE HANLEY; ANNIE M. HANLEY; ANNIE A. HANLEY; SARAH A. RADICAN; ESTATE OF SARAH A. RADICAN; JAMES H. BROGAN; ESTATE OF JAMES H. BROGAN; DAVID CARTWRIGHT; ESTATE OF DAVID CARTWRIGHT; ANNIE SHAY; MADELINE V. GORMAN; CHARLES R. BOUTELLE; ESTATE OF CHARLES R. BOUTELLE; ISABELLA A. STEVENS; ESTATE OF ISABELLA A. STEVENS; JAMES EGLINTON AND WIFE; ESTATE OF WIFE OF JAMES EGLINTON; OLIVE H. EGLINTON; IRENE M. STANDISH; ESTATE OF IRENE M. STANDISH; MARY A. COLLINS; ESTATE OF MARY A. COLLINS; BENJAMIN S. TERRY; ESTATE OF BENJAMIN S. TERRY; JULIA MORADIAN; ESTATE OF JULIA MORADIAN; CATHERINE CRONIN; ESTATE OF CATHERINE CRONIN; MARIE A. O'CONNELL; ESTATE OF MARIE A. O'CONNELL; MARY J. BURKE; ESTATE OF MARY J. BURKE; ELLA A. BURKE; ESTATE OF ELLA A. BURKE; ANNA BEAGAN; ESTATE OF ANNA BEAGAN; MAY S. KEMP; ESTATE OF MAY S. KEMP a/k/a MARY S. KEMP; KATE HAROLD; ESTATE OF KATE HAROLD; ALBINE P. SONTAG; ESTATE OF ALBINE P. SONTAG; JOHN STEWART; ESTATE OF JOHN STEWART; JULIA M. SANDERS; ESTATE OF JULIA M. SANDERS; HENRY HARDY; ESTATE OF HENRY HARDY; THOMAS STONES; CHARLES STONES; ROSE HOBSON; SARAH ENGLEHART; JULIA RABBITT; ELIZABETH RUDDY; AGNES HEART; THOMAS RABBITT; EDWARD RABBITT; SARAH A. JACKSON; ESTATE OF SARAH A. JACKSON; KATE HAROLD; ESTATE OF KATE HAROLD; GEORGE A. KIMBARK; GENIE G. KIMBARK; S.A. GREENE; JOHN BOWEN; ESTATE OF JOHN BOWEN; MINNIE BISHOP; ESTATE OF MINNIE BISHOP; NAOMI HUGHES; ESTATE OF NAOMI HUGHES; MARY E. DOYLE; MARGARET T. DAILY; WILLIAM B. CRAM; ESTATE OF WILLIAM B. CRAM; MARY A. MELODY; CATHERINE MCELROY; ELLA TRACY; ESTATE OF ELLA TRACY; MARY CASSIDY; ESTATE OF MARY CASSIDY; ANNIE CALVERT; ESTATE OF ANNIE CALVERT; JOHN WINTHROP; ANNIE WINTHROP; CHARLOTTE M. MCCORMACK f/k/a CHARLOTTE WINTHROP; FRANK WINTHROP; ANNIE BISHOP; JOHN BISHOP; CATHERINE CRONIN; ESTATE OF CATHERINE CRONIN; ERNEST PURSHE; ESTATE OF ERNEST PURSHE; WILLIAM GLENNON; ESTATE OF WILLIAM GLENNON; ANTONIO MONCONE; ESTATE OF ANTONIO MONCONE; MARGARET CONNERTON; ESTATE OF MARGARET CONNERTON; ZYLPHA PHELPS; ESTATE OF ZYLPHA PHELPS; MARGARET CHENY; ESTATE OF MARGARET CHENY; ALBINE P. CONSTAG; ESTATE OF ALBINE P. CONSTAG; AXEL A. LAWS; ESTATE OF AXEL A. LAWS; WILLIAM G. GRUBE; ESTATE OF WILLIAM G. GRUBE; NELLIE B. COMER; ESTATE OF NELLIE B. COMER; NORA KURRAN; ESTATE OF NORA KURRAN; EDWARD T. MCSOLEY; ESTATE OF EDWARD T. MCSOLEY; THOMAS MCKENNA; MARION MCCAUGHEY; EVELYN PATTERSON; KATHLEEN REISS; JOHN J. MCKENNA; THOMAS F. MCKENNA; FRANK LOVE; ESTATE OF FRANK LOVE; FRANK ROONEY; ESTATE OF FRANK ROONEY; HELEN E. ANDREWS; ESTATE OF HELEN E. ANDREWS; ANNIE MCHUGH; MARY F. TALBY; MARGARET E. AYONS; HELEN I. ALDRICH; ANNA M. MCHUGH; PETER J. MCHUGH; ANNIE MCHUGH, ALIAS ANN MCHUGH; MARY F. TALBY; MARGARET E. AYONS; HELEN I. ALDRICH; ANNA M. MCHUGH; PETER J. MCHUGH; MARY B. HIGGINS; ESTATE OF MARY B. HIGGINS; MARGARET V. MURPHY; ESTATE OF MARGARET V. MURPHY; AMELIA BRINDLE; ESTATE OF AMELIA BRINDLE; MARY JUDGE; ESTATE OF ELLEN G. HENNESSY; ELLEN G. HENNESSY; JAMES WOLSTENHOLME; ESTATE OF JAMES WOLSTENHOLME; JAMES WOLSTENHOLME; JAMES CLAXTON WOLSTENHOLME; SARAH PETTINE; ESTATE OF SARAH PETTINE; PETER TRUMPLER; PATRICIA LETT; MARY M. SIMMONS; MARY M. GAYLORD; ELLA TRUMPLER; WILLIAM COURT; ESTATE OF WILLIAM COURT; THOMAS REYNOLDS; ESTATE OF THOMAS REYNOLDS; ALMIRA M. HALL; JOHN HOLMES; FRED L. BALCOM; ESTATE OF MARY ELIZABETH MCCARTHY; MARY MCCARTHY; PATRICK A. MORGAN; MARGARET M. MORGAN; JOSEPH F. CURRIER; ESTATE OF JOSEPH F. CURRIER; PATRICK D. LOUTH; THOMAS LOUTH; CHARLES H. BRIGGS; ESTATE OF CHARLES H. BRIGGS; WILLIAM JOHNSON; ESTATE OF WILLIAM JOHNSON; ELLEN T. SHANLEY; ESTATE OF ELLEN T. SHANLEY; MICHAEL J. SALMON AND WIFE; ESTATE OF MICHAEL J. SALMON; ESTATE OF WIFE OF MICHAEL J. SALMON; MARTIN MURTAUGH; ESTATE OF MARTIN MURTAUGH; MARY MURTAUGH; ESTATE OF MARY MURTAUGH; ALICE CRONIN; ESTATE OF ALICE CRONIN; MAURO DALARINO; ESTATE OF MAURO DALARINO; NATHAN BROWN; ESTATE OF NATHAN BROWN; MARY WATERMAN; ELISA ALDEN WATERMAN; EVELINA F. WATERMAN SMITH; JOSIAH HARRIS WATERMAN; FRANK ATWOOD WATERMAN; PHOBEY KNIGHT; HENRY KNIGHT; MARY KNIGHT BOWEN; C. E. SILVA; AMIL M. O'NEILL; FRANK O'NEILL; GEORGE KNIGHT; PATRICK HAYES; MARY HAYES; ESTATE OF MARY HAYES; ERNESTINE M. SCHWAB; AUGUSTA C. A. MEYER; ESTHER H. FINNERAN; MARY B. HIGGINS; ESTATE OF MARY B. HIGGINS; VICTORIA AVERY; ESTATE OF VICTORIA AVERY; THOMAS E. CARTER; ESTATE OF THOMAS E. CARTER; MARY A. LARKIN; ESTATE OF MARY A. LARKIN; JOHN J. RICH; SISTER MARY J. DOLORITA a/k/a JENNIE C. RICH; MARY T. RICH; AGNES C. RICH; ALMA M. RICH; CATHERINE G. RICH; IRENE M. STANDISH; ESTATE OF IRENE M. STANDISH; MARY JUDGE; ESTATE OF ELLEN G. HENNESSY; VICTORIA AVERY; ESTATE OF VICTORIA AVERY; JAMES H. MADDEN; ESTATE OF JAMES H. MADDEN; ANNIE CALVERT; ESTATE OF ANNIE CALVERT; CHARLES HOWE; FRANCES BERTHA HOWE; ARTHUR FREDERICK HOWE; JOSEPH PETTINE; ESTATE OF JOSEPH PETTINE; JOHN H. VALLETTE; ESTATE OF JOHN H. VALLETTE; ROBERT STEWART; ESTATE OF ROBERT STEWART; AGNES STEWART; ESTATE OF AGNES STEWART; AGNES GIFFEN STEWART; ALMIRA M. HALL; JOHN HOLMES; JOHN INDELKOT; ESTATE OF JOHN INDELKOT; THOMAS J. NORMAN; ESTATE OF THOMAS J. NORMAN; WILLIAM H. LE LACHEUR; CHARLES H. LE LACHEUR; PAUL LE LACHEUR; ESTATE OF HARRIET LE LACHEUR; PAUL A. LE LACHEUR; PAUL P. LE LACHEUR; JAMES P. LOFTUS; ESTATE OF JAMES P. LOFTUS; MARY E. LOFTUS; ESTATE OF MARY E. LOFTUS; MARY SHANNON; ESTATE OF MARY SHANNON; JOHN SHANNON; ESTATE OF JOHN SHANNON; JOHN A. SHANNON; MARY B. HIGGINS; ESTATE OF MARY B. HIGGINS; GIUSEPPE PAONE; ESTATE OF GIUSEPPE PAONE; CORA L. CANNON; ESTATE OF CORA L. CANNON; MARY A. CANNON; ROBERT S. ROBERTSON; SOPHIA ROBERTSON; KATHERINE MCCARTHY; ESTATE OF KATHERINE MCCARTHY; KATHERINE T. MCCARTHY; KATHERINE MARY MCCARTHY; C. G. CAMBIO; FRANK C. CAMBIO; WILLIAM A. CAMBIO; EDWARD P. CAMBIO; ADOLF A. CAMBIO; EVELYN OAKLEY, JR.; MARIA B. O'BRIEN, ESTATE OF MARIA B. O'BRIEN; WILLIAM FUERTH; HELEN FUERTH; CAROLINE FUERTH; DORA FUERTH; HELEN FUERTH HEDISON; ERNEST FUERTH; ELIZABETH KELLEY; ESTATE OF ELIZABETH KELLEY; THOMAS J. NORMAN; ESTATE OF THOMAS J. NORMAN; MARGUERITE BROWN; ESTATE OF MARGUERITE BROWN a/k/a MARGUERETE BROWN; DANIEL S. BUSHEE; ESTATE OF MARY L. BUSHEE; ERASTUS D. NILES; ESTATE OF ERASTUS D. NILES; JENNIE CRAMER; ESTATE OF JENNIE CRAMER; HENNIRETTA SIEGEL; ESTATE OF HENNRIETTA SIEGAL a/k/a HENNIRETTA SIEGEL; JOS. E. SCANLON; ESTATE OF JOS. E. SCANLON; TERASA SCANLON; ESTATE OF TERASA SCANLON; HANNAH E. BOLAN; ESTATE OF HANNAH E. BOLAN; RHEY T. SNODGRASS; ESTATE OF RHEY T. SNODGRASS; JOSEPH MANION; ESTATE OF JOSEPH MANION; JOHN CROFT; SARAH M. LUND; JOHN T. CROFT; CLARA I. CROFT; MILDRED R. CROFT; MARTIN F. FARRELL, JR.; ESTATE OF MARTIN F. FARRELL, JR.; DEBORAH L. GIFFORD; ESTATE OF LYSANDER C. GIFFORD; GEORGE A. SPINK; LUCIE A. SPINK; WILLIAM F. MCCARTNEY; ESTATE OF WILLIAM F. MCCARTNEY; WILLIAM MERRITT; ESTATE OF WILLIAM MERRITT; JOHN J. BURCH; WILLIAM W. BURCH; EMMA L. COOK; ESTHER A. MADDOX; ALBERT LINDGREN; ESTATE OF ALBERT LINDGREN; FANNIE E. WHITE; ESTATE OF FANNIE E. WHITE; MARY A. HOYE; ESTATE OF MARY A. HOYE; ROBERT R. RAWLINSON AND WIFE; ESTATE OF ROBERT R. RAWLINSON; ESTATE OF WIFE OF ROBERT R. RAWLINSON; HANNAH E. BOLAN; ESTATE OF HANNAH E. BOLAN; THOMAS A. DILLON; ESTATE OF THOMAS A. DILLON; SAMUEL H. TOBIN; ESTATE OF SAMUEL H. TOBIN; MYER COHEN; ESTATE OF MYER COHEN; ESTER COHEN; ESTATE OF ESTER COHEN; JOSEPH H. REYNOLDS; ESTATE OF JOSEPH H. REYNOLDS; JAMES DANIELS; ESTATE OF JOHN F. DANIELS; ESTATE OF CHRISTOPHER W. DANIELS; ESTATE OF EVELYN N. DANIELS; MARY E. DANIELS; WALTER E. DANIELS; CATHERINE DANIELS; JOHN W. MOORE; ESTATE OF JOHN W. MOORE; FERDINAND TANZER; ESTATE OF DORA FUERTH; CAROLINE FUERTH; ELEANOR P. CARTWRIGHT; ESTATE OF ELEANOR P. CARTWRIGHT; MAURICE GELUSHA; ESTATE OF MAURICE GELUSHA; MAX GELUSHA; ESTATE OF MAX GELUSHA; JOHN G. C. GAUTIEN; ESTATE OF JOHN G. C. GAUTIEN; LUCY A. BOWEN; ESTATE OF LUCY A. BOWEN; MARGARET T. BOWEN; ESTATE OF ELLEN BOWEN; ESTATE OF ELIZABETH BOWEN; ESTATE OF JOHN F. MULDOON; MARY BOWEN; ESTATE OF MARY BOWEN; MARY COMLIN; ESTATE OF MARY COMLIN; JANE OGDEN; ESTATE OF JANE OGDEN; THOMAS J. CRAMER; ESTATE OF THOMAS J. CRAMER; SARAH J. FRENCH; ESTATE OF SARAH J. FRENCH; HECTOR J. HECKETT; ESTATE OF HECTOR J. HECKETT; HANNAH E. BOLAN; ESTATE OF HANNAH E. BOLAN; MARY A. BYRNES; ESTATE OF MARY A. BYRNES; ADRIAN JACKSON; ESTATE OF ADRIAN JACKSON; ROSE ANN JACKSON; ESTATE OF ROSE ANN JACKSON; BENJAMIN BOUTELLE; ESTATE OF BENJAMIN BOUTELLE; THEODORE BIDET; THEODORE F. BIDET; JENNIE R. GIRARD; WILLIAM BIDET; MARY F. BIDET; ESTATE OF MARY F. BIDET; STEPHEN HANEY; ESTATE OF STEPHEN HANEY; ELIZABETH HANEY; ESTATE OF ELIZABETH HANEY; FANNIE CLARE; ESTATE OF FANNIE CLARE; CHARLES MCHUGH; EDWARD J. MCHUGH; GLADYS BROWN; SUSAN K. MCHUGH; AMELIA W. MARTIN; ESTATE OF AMELIA W. MARTIN; CATHERINE LEONARD; ESTATE OF CATHERINE LEONARD; JOHN J. RICH; SISTER MARY J. DOLORITA (JENNIE C. RICH); MARY T. RICH; AGNES C. RICH; ALMA M. RICH; CATHERINE G. RICH; MARY A. MARTIN; ESTATE OF MARY A. MARTIN; MARY A. BYRNES; ESTATE OF MARY A. BYRNES; JULIETTE DARLING; ESTATE OF JULIETTE DARLING; JAMES D. VANDERBEEK; ESTATE OF JAMES VANDERBEEK; BALDASSARE PARRILLO; MARY PARILLO; ESTELLE PARILLO; ANTONETTA PARRELLO; SOREN R. LIND; ANNIE R. LIND; ANNIE R. KAY; WILLIAM TRIMBLE; ELIZA TRIMBLE; MARY E. MCCANN; ESTATE OF MARY E. MCCANN; JOSEPH P. MCELROY; ESTATE OF JOSEPH P. MCELROY; ROBERT J. MARTIN; ESTATE OF ROBERT J. MARTIN; THEODORE E. THORPE; ESTATE OF THEODORE E. THORPE; KATE L. BRENNAN; ESTATE OF KATE L. BRENNAN; GIUSEPPE PAONE; ESTATE OF GIUSEPPE PAONE; FRANK RILEY; VIOLA M. DOYLE; CLARENCE J. RILEY; AUDREY E. RILEY; BRIDGET RILEY; WILLIAM KELLEY; WILLIAM H. KELLEY; JAMES H. MADDEN; ESTATE OF JAMES H. MADDEN; JANE HOLDEN; ESTATE OF JANE HOLDEN; ABE SELEZER; ESTATE OF ABE SELEZER; WILLIAM TRIMBLE; ELIZA TRIMBLE; NOBLE C. BROWN; ESTATE OF NOBLE C. BROWN; ANTONIO MARCHIONNE; ANNA MARCHIONNE; JAMES J. QUINN; THOMAS L. QUINN; PATRICK J. QUINN; ARTHUR NEILL; ESTATE OF ARTHUR NEILL; FILOMENO CAMBIO; ESTATE OF FILOMENO CAMBIO; ROSE SPERA; ESTATE OF ROSE SPERA; ESTELLA DOUGLASS; ESTATE OF ESTELLA DOUGLASS; MARTIN L. GRAY; ESTATE OF MARTIN L. GRAY; DOMESTIC LOAN AND INVESTMENT BANK f/k/a DOMESTIC SAFE DEPOSIT COMPANY; MAINE DEVELOPMENT, INC.; PAUL FILIPPI; [1] MARION FILIPPI a/k/a MARIAN FILIPPI;[2] DOMENIC D'AMBRA; BI REALTY, INC.; LEONARD W. HATHAWAY; ESTATE OF LEONARD W. HATHAWAY; WHEELOCK COLLEGE; DEAN JUNIOR COLLEGE ALUMNI ASSOCIATION; LIGHTHOUSE FOR THE BLIND; MIAMI SHORES COMMUNITY CHURCH; GREATER MIAMI LAY DIABETIC; LAWRENCE A. SIGNORE; COASTWAY CREDIT UNION; INDEPENDENT REALTY ASSOCIATES; PAUL T. SURABIAN; their heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns, known and unknown, and also all other persons unknown and unascertained, claiming, or who may claim, any right, title, estate, lien, or interest in the real estate involved, which is, or might become, adverse to the Plaintiff's right, title, or interest therein as alleged or which does or may constitute any cloud upon Plaintiff's title thereto, as set forth in the Amended Complaint
CourtRhode Island Superior Court

SMITHFIELD ESTATES, LLC
v.

THE HEIRS OF JOHN M. HATHAWAY; JOHN J. RILEY; ESTATE OF JOHN J. RILEY; EUGENE F. RILEY; ESTATE OF EUGENE F. RILEY; JUDSON DAVIS; GRACE BOARDMAN; LEWIS T. GARDNER; MARY A. WHITTAKER; ESTATE OF MARY A. WHITTAKER; MARY MACAULEY; ESTATE OF MARY MACAULEY; SARAH A. GARFIELD; ESTATE OF SARAH A. GARFIELD; CHARLES H. RUSSELL; FRANKLIN M. RUSSELL; CHARLES H. SHIPPEE; ESTATE OF CHARLES H. SHIPPEE; JAMES B. CANNING; ESTATE OF JAMES B. CANNING; MARY A. MCGIN a/k/a MARY A. MCGINN; ESTATE OF MARY A. MCGIN a/k/a MARY A. MCGINN; CATHERINE F. MCGIN; ESTATE OF CATHERINE F. MCGIN; FRED M. SWARTS; ESTATE OF FRED M. SWARTS; CATHERINE BRESLIN; ESTATE OF CATHERINE BRESLIN; THOMAS ADAMS; ESTATE OF THOMAS ADAMS; MABLE A. ADAMS; ESTATE OF MABLE A. ADAMS; WILLIAM BISHOP; ESTATE OF MILLIE BISHOP; EDITH H. RICHARDSON; THOMAS H. PHILLIPS; ESTATE OF THOMAS H. PHILLIPS; ROSE PHILLIPS; ESTATE OF ROSE PHILLIPS; DEBORAH NORTH; ESTATE OF DEBORAH NORTH; CHRISTINA HEAP; HAROLD HEAP; TOM HEAP; FRED P. HEAP; ADA HEWITT; THOMAS S. HEAP; EUGENE CORCORAN; ESTATE OF EUGENE CORCORAN; MARIA CORCORAN; ESTATE OF MARIA CORCORAN; EDWARD KANE; EDWARD P. KANE, JR.; MARGARET M. KANE; GEORGIA PENTA; EVELYN DEL DONNO; GEORGE A. MOORE; ESTATE OF GEORGE A. MOORE; GEORGE H. MOORE; ESTATE OF GEORGE H. MOORE; ESTER MOORE; ESTATE OF ESTER MOORE; MARGARETTE MARA; ESTATE OF MARGARETTE MARA; ALPHONSE MALO; ESTATE OF ALPHONSE MALO; MARTIN LYONS AND WIFE; ESTATE OF MARTIN LYONS AND WIFE; DANIEL HOOD; CHRISTINA LIVINGSTON; THOMAS HINDLE AND WIFE; GEORGE HINDLE; THOMAS HINDLE; FANNY W. HINDLE; FRANK ROBARGE; ESTATE OF FRANK ROBARGE; JAMES RILEY; ESTATE OF JAMES RILEY; CHARLES LOCKWOOD AND WIFE; DOMENIC D'AMBRA; MARJORIE V. LOCKWOOD; JULIA J. LOCKWOOD; MARY A. GILLAN; ESTATE OF MARY A. GILLAN; E. HAVERLY; ESTATE OF E. HAVERLY; ANNIE SMYTHE; ESTATE OF ANNIE SMYTHE; MARY COLEMAN; ESTATE OF MARY COLEMAN; EUGENE CORCORAN; ESTATE OF EUGENE CORCORAN; MARIA CORCORAN; ESTATE OF MARIA CORCORAN; EDWARD KANE; EDWARD P. KANE, JR.; MARGARET M. KANE; JOSEPH FONT; ESTATE OF JOSEPH FONT; PATRICK KELLY; CATHERINE KELLY; ANN AGNEW; ESTATE OF ANN AGNEW; W.F. GRAHAM; ESTATE OF W.F. GRAHAM; MARGARET J. BRINDLE; ESTATE OF MARGARET J. BRINDLE; MARY A. MCGOUGH; ESTATE OF MARY A. MCGOUGH; THOMAS S. LANE; MARGARET T. MCGOUGH; ROBERT E. FITZGERALD; ESTATE OF ROBERT E. FITZGERALD; WILLIAM H. ROSE; ESTATE OF WILLIAM H. ROSE; HENRY BASIALEWICK; ESTATE OF HENRY BASIALEWICK; JAMES RILEY; ESTATE OF JAMES RILEY; WILLIAM E. KILROY; MARY A. KILROY; ANNA E. CULLION; LETITIA A. LEACH; EUGENIA M. WATSON; EDWIN F. LEACH; LETITIA A. BEARS; EUGENIA M. WATSON; ESTATE OF EUGENIA M. WATSON; ANN CASH; SAMUEL L. CASH; FANNI L. QUINSBY; ALICE C. RHIND; JOHN B. ADAMS; ESTATE OF JOHN B. ADAMS; SARAH ADAMS; ESTATE OF SARAH ADAMS; ARTHUR B. MULLEN; ESTATE OF ARTHUR B. MULLEN; JOSEPHINE MULLEN; ESTATE OF JOSEPHINE MULLEN; CHARLES W. FRASER; ESTATE OF CHARLES W. FRASER; PHILIP B. BANSH; ESTATE OF PHILIP B. BANSH; ISABELLA LANCASTER; ESTATE OF ISABELLA LANCASTER; BRIDGET HEANEY; ESTATE OF BRIDGET HEANEY; ELLEN M. COLLINS; ESTATE OF ELLEN M. COLLINS; MARY L. LONGWILL; ESTATE OF MARY L. LONGWILL; ANNIE A. RIELLY; ESTATE OF ANNIE A. RIELLY a/k/a ANNIE A. O'RIELLY; PATRICK MCKENNA; ESTATE OF PATRICK MCKENNA; HENRY S. BRIGGS AND WIFE; WALTER E. BARKER; ANNA E. MARION; EMILY L. REINNAGEL; CORNELIUS FRIEL; ESTATE OF CORNELIUS FRIEL; ELIZABETH JOHNSON; ESTATE OF ELIZABETH JOHNSON; GEORGE PERL BUCKLIN AND WIFE; ESTATE OF WIFE OF GEORGE PERL BUCKLIN; DOMENIC D'AMBRA; MARY E. SHIPPEE; ESTATE OF MARY E. SHIPPEE; PATRICK MCGUINNESS; ESTATE OF PATRICK MCGUINNESS; CHARLES MARKOFF; CHARLOTTE MARKOFF; SAMUEL A. MARKOFF; RUTH MARKOFF; MICHAEL RODGERS AND WIFE, ANNIE; ESTATE OF ANNIE RODGERS; JOHN J. RODGERS; MARY T. O'NEIL; ESTATE OF MARY T. O'NEIL; MARY O'NEIL; PETER REILLY; ESTATE OF PETER REILLY; BRIDGET REILLY; ESTATE OF BRIDGET REILLY; MARY A. O'BRIAN; ESTATE OF MARY A. O'BRIAN; LILLIE CLANCY; ESTATE OF LILLY CLANCY; JULIUS HERMAN OTTO; EMMA ZEUNER; ANNA ASHCROFT; BERTHA OTTO; HERMAN OTTO; GEORGE OTTO; GERTRUDE OTTO; ANNIE HANLEY; ESTATE OF ANNIE HANLEY; ANNIE M. HANLEY; ANNIE A. HANLEY; SARAH A. RADICAN; ESTATE OF SARAH A. RADICAN; JAMES H. BROGAN; ESTATE OF JAMES H. BROGAN; DAVID CARTWRIGHT; ESTATE OF DAVID CARTWRIGHT; ANNIE SHAY; MADELINE V. GORMAN; CHARLES R. BOUTELLE; ESTATE OF CHARLES R. BOUTELLE; ISABELLA A. STEVENS; ESTATE OF ISABELLA A. STEVENS; JAMES EGLINTON AND WIFE; ESTATE OF WIFE OF JAMES EGLINTON; OLIVE H. EGLINTON; IRENE M. STANDISH; ESTATE OF IRENE M. STANDISH; MARY A. COLLINS; ESTATE OF MARY A. COLLINS; BENJAMIN S. TERRY; ESTATE OF BENJAMIN S. TERRY; JULIA MORADIAN; ESTATE OF JULIA MORADIAN; CATHERINE CRONIN; ESTATE OF CATHERINE CRONIN; MARIE A. O'CONNELL; ESTATE OF MARIE A. O'CONNELL; MARY J. BURKE; ESTATE OF MARY J. BURKE; ELLA A. BURKE; ESTATE OF ELLA A. BURKE; ANNA BEAGAN; ESTATE OF ANNA BEAGAN; MAY S. KEMP; ESTATE OF MAY S. KEMP a/k/a MARY S. KEMP; KATE HAROLD; ESTATE OF KATE HAROLD; ALBINE P. SONTAG; ESTATE OF ALBINE P. SONTAG; JOHN STEWART; ESTATE OF JOHN STEWART; JULIA M. SANDERS; ESTATE OF JULIA M. SANDERS; HENRY HARDY; ESTATE OF HENRY HARDY; THOMAS STONES; CHARLES STONES; ROSE HOBSON; SARAH ENGLEHART; JULIA RABBITT; ELIZABETH RUDDY; AGNES HEART; THOMAS RABBITT; EDWARD RABBITT; SARAH A. JACKSON; ESTATE OF SARAH A. JACKSON; KATE HAROLD; ESTATE OF KATE HAROLD; GEORGE A. KIMBARK; GENIE G. KIMBARK; S.A. GREENE; JOHN BOWEN; ESTATE OF JOHN BOWEN; MINNIE BISHOP; ESTATE OF MINNIE BISHOP; NAOMI HUGHES; ESTATE OF NAOMI HUGHES; MARY E. DOYLE; MARGARET T. DAILY; WILLIAM B. CRAM; ESTATE OF WILLIAM B. CRAM; MARY A. MELODY; CATHERINE MCELROY; ELLA TRACY; ESTATE OF ELLA TRACY; MARY CASSIDY; ESTATE OF MARY CASSIDY; ANNIE CALVERT; ESTATE OF ANNIE CALVERT; JOHN WINTHROP; ANNIE WINTHROP; CHARLOTTE M. MCCORMACK f/k/a CHARLOTTE WINTHROP; FRANK WINTHROP; ANNIE BISHOP; JOHN BISHOP; CATHERINE CRONIN; ESTATE OF CATHERINE CRONIN; ERNEST PURSHE; ESTATE OF ERNEST PURSHE; WILLIAM GLENNON; ESTATE OF WILLIAM GLENNON; ANTONIO MONCONE; ESTATE OF ANTONIO MONCONE; MARGARET CONNERTON; ESTATE OF MARGARET CONNERTON; ZYLPHA PHELPS; ESTATE OF ZYLPHA PHELPS; MARGARET CHENY; ESTATE OF MARGARET CHENY; ALBINE P. CONSTAG; ESTATE OF ALBINE P. CONSTAG; AXEL A. LAWS; ESTATE OF AXEL A. LAWS; WILLIAM G. GRUBE; ESTATE OF WILLIAM G. GRUBE; NELLIE B. COMER; ESTATE OF NELLIE B. COMER; NORA KURRAN; ESTATE OF NORA KURRAN; EDWARD T. MCSOLEY; ESTATE OF EDWARD T. MCSOLEY; THOMAS MCKENNA; MARION MCCAUGHEY; EVELYN PATTERSON; KATHLEEN REISS; JOHN J. MCKENNA; THOMAS F. MCKENNA; FRANK LOVE; ESTATE OF FRANK LOVE; FRANK ROONEY; ESTATE OF FRANK ROONEY; HELEN E. ANDREWS; ESTATE OF HELEN E. ANDREWS; ANNIE MCHUGH; MARY F. TALBY; MARGARET E. AYONS; HELEN I. ALDRICH; ANNA M. MCHUGH; PETER J. MCHUGH; ANNIE MCHUGH, ALIAS ANN MCHUGH; MARY F. TALBY; MARGARET E. AYONS; HELEN I. ALDRICH; ANNA M. MCHUGH; PETER J. MCHUGH; MARY B. HIGGINS; ESTATE OF MARY B. HIGGINS; MARGARET V. MURPHY; ESTATE OF MARGARET V. MURPHY; AMELIA BRINDLE; ESTATE OF AMELIA BRINDLE; MARY JUDGE; ESTATE OF ELLEN G. HENNESSY; ELLEN G. HENNESSY; JAMES WOLSTENHOLME; ESTATE OF JAMES WOLSTENHOLME; JAMES WOLSTENHOLME; JAMES CLAXTON WOLSTENHOLME; SARAH PETTINE; ESTATE OF SARAH PETTINE; PETER TRUMPLER; PATRICIA LETT; MARY M. SIMMONS; MARY M. GAYLORD; ELLA TRUMPLER; WILLIAM COURT; ESTATE OF WILLIAM COURT; THOMAS REYNOLDS; ESTATE OF THOMAS REYNOLDS; ALMIRA M. HALL; JOHN HOLMES; FRED L. BALCOM; ESTATE OF MARY ELIZABETH MCCARTHY; MARY MCCARTHY; PATRICK A. MORGAN; MARGARET M. MORGAN; JOSEPH F. CURRIER; ESTATE OF JOSEPH F. CURRIER; PATRICK D. LOUTH; THOMAS LOUTH; CHARLES H. BRIGGS; ESTATE OF CHARLES H. BRIGGS; WILLIAM JOHNSON; ESTATE OF WILLIAM JOHNSON; ELLEN T. SHANLEY; ESTATE OF ELLEN T. SHANLEY; MICHAEL J. SALMON AND WIFE; ESTATE OF MICHAEL J. SALMON; ESTATE OF WIFE OF MICHAEL J. SALMON; MARTIN MURTAUGH; ESTATE OF MARTIN MURTAUGH; MARY MURTAUGH; ESTATE OF MARY MURTAUGH; ALICE CRONIN; ESTATE OF ALICE CRONIN; MAURO DALARINO; ESTATE OF MAURO DALARINO; NATHAN BROWN; ESTATE OF NATHAN BROWN; MARY WATERMAN; ELISA ALDEN WATERMAN; EVELINA F. WATERMAN SMITH; JOSIAH HARRIS WATERMAN; FRANK ATWOOD WATERMAN; PHOBEY KNIGHT; HENRY KNIGHT; MARY KNIGHT BOWEN; C. E. SILVA; AMIL M. O'NEILL; FRANK O'NEILL; GEORGE KNIGHT; PATRICK HAYES; MARY HAYES; ESTATE OF MARY HAYES; ERNESTINE M. SCHWAB; AUGUSTA C. A. MEYER; ESTHER H. FINNERAN; MARY B. HIGGINS; ESTATE OF MARY B. HIGGINS; VICTORIA AVERY; ESTATE OF VICTORIA AVERY; THOMAS E. CARTER; ESTATE OF THOMAS E. CARTER; MARY A. LARKIN; ESTATE OF MARY A. LARKIN; JOHN J. RICH; SISTER MARY J. DOLORITA a/k/a JENNIE C. RICH; MARY T. RICH; AGNES C. RICH; ALMA M. RICH; CATHERINE G. RICH; IRENE M. STANDISH; ESTATE OF IRENE M. STANDISH; MARY JUDGE; ESTATE OF ELLEN G. HENNESSY; VICTORIA AVERY; ESTATE OF VICTORIA AVERY; JAMES H. MADDEN; ESTATE OF JAMES H. MADDEN; ANNIE CALVERT; ESTATE OF ANNIE CALVERT; CHARLES HOWE; FRANCES BERTHA HOWE; ARTHUR FREDERICK HOWE; JOSEPH PETTINE; ESTATE OF JOSEPH PETTINE; JOHN H. VALLETTE; ESTATE OF JOHN H. VALLETTE; ROBERT STEWART; ESTATE OF ROBERT STEWART; AGNES STEWART; ESTATE OF AGNES STEWART; AGNES GIFFEN STEWART; ALMIRA M. HALL; JOHN HOLMES; JOHN INDELKOT; ESTATE OF JOHN INDELKOT; THOMAS J. NORMAN; ESTATE OF THOMAS J. NORMAN; WILLIAM H. LE LACHEUR; CHARLES H. LE LACHEUR; PAUL LE LACHEUR; ESTATE OF HARRIET LE LACHEUR; PAUL A. LE LACHEUR; PAUL P. LE LACHEUR; JAMES P. LOFTUS; ESTATE OF JAMES P. LOFTUS; MARY E. LOFTUS; ESTATE OF MARY E. LOFTUS; MARY SHANNON; ESTATE OF MARY SHANNON; JOHN SHANNON; ESTATE OF JOHN SHANNON; JOHN A. SHANNON; MARY B. HIGGINS; ESTATE OF MARY B. HIGGINS; GIUSEPPE PAONE; ESTATE OF GIUSEPPE PAONE; CORA L. CANNON; ESTATE OF CORA L. CANNON; MARY A. CANNON; ROBERT S. ROBERTSON; SOPHIA ROBERTSON; KATHERINE MCCARTHY; ESTATE OF KATHERINE MCCARTHY; KATHERINE T. MCCARTHY; KATHERINE MARY MCCARTHY; C. G. CAMBIO; FRANK C. CAMBIO; WILLIAM A. CAMBIO; EDWARD P. CAMBIO; ADOLF A. CAMBIO; EVELYN OAKLEY, JR.; MARIA B. O'BRIEN, ESTATE OF MARIA B.
...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT