Society of European Stage Authors and Composers v. WCAU Broadcasting Co., 9997.
| Decision Date | 25 October 1940 |
| Docket Number | No. 9997.,9997. |
| Citation | 35 F. Supp. 460 |
| Parties | SOCIETY OF EUROPEAN STAGE AUTHORS AND COMPOSERS, Inc., et al. v. WCAU BROADCASTING CO. |
| Court | U.S. District Court — Western District of Pennsylvania |
Richard Benson, Harold Scott Baile, and Pepper, Bodine, Stokes & Schoch, all of Philadelphia, Pa., for plaintiffs.
Isaac D. Levy and Louis Levinson, both of Philadelphia, Pa., for defendant.
The plaintiffs have moved for separate trials of the claim and cross-claim. Under Rule 42(b) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, 28 U.S.C.A. following section 723c, the court "in furtherance of convenience or to avoid prejudice" may order a separate trial of any claim, cross-claim, counter-claim or third-party claim or of any separate issue or of any number of claims, cross-claims, counter-claims, third-party claims or issues. The plaintiffs base their motion upon the ground that separate trials will be in furtherance of convenience and avoidance of prejudice.
The complaint averred various copyright infringements which were either denied or defended by the defendant. Among the defenses raised by the answer is that the plaintiff, Society of European Stage Authors and Composers, Inc., is an unlawful combination of composers and publishers and so barred by reason of the fact that the anti-trust statutes are violated. The cross-claim reiterates this latter defense and asks for affirmative relief.
It is no defense to a suit for infringement of copyright on musical compositions that the plaintiff is a combination in restraint of trade. Abundant authority settles this. Buck et al. v. Newsreel, Inc., et al., D.C., 25 F.Supp. 787, and cases therein cited; Buck et al. v. Spanish Gables, Inc., et al., D.C., 26 F.Supp. 36. Therefore, the question of unlawful combination will not be concerned in the determination of the rights of the litigants as presented by the complaint and answer. That is a question to be considered solely under the cross-claim.
As to whether there shall be separate trials and separate judgments rests in the sound discretion of the trial judge, and the determining factors are the doing of justice, the avoidance of prejudice, and the furtherance of convenience. Seagram-Distillers Corporation v. Manos, D.C., 25 F.Supp. 233. There being nothing to compel a joint trial of the separate issues, I am constrained, by reason, to agree with the plaintiff that the convenience and fairness of separate trials warrant separation.
Furthermore, the complaint was filed May...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Zenith Radio Corp. v. Radio Corp. of America
...reaches the matter which was argued before and decided by Judge Maris. 9 See fn. 7, supra. 10 Compare Society of European Stage Authors v. WCAU Broadcasting Co., D. C., 35 F.Supp. 460; Hall Laboratories, Inc. v. National Aluminate Corp., D.C. Del., 95 F.Supp. 323; Stewart-Warner Corp. v. St......
-
United Artists Associated, Inc. v. NWL CORPORATION
...D.C.D.Mass.1938, 26 F.Supp. 36; Buck v. Newsreel, Inc., D.C.D.Mass.1938, 25 F.Supp. 787; Society of European Stage Authors and Composers, Inc. v. WCAU Broadcasting Co., D.C.E.D.Pa.1940, 35 F.Supp. 460; Buck v. Cecere, D.C.W.D.N.Y.1942, 45 F. Supp. 441; Harms, Inc. v. Sansom House Enterprise......
-
Utilities Natural Gas Corp. v. Hill
...are (1) the doing of justice, (2) the avoiding of prejudice, (3) the furtherance of convenience. Society of European Stage Authors and Composers v. WCAU Broadcasting Co., D. C., 35 F.Supp. 460; United States v. 340 Acres, etc., D. C., 64 F.Supp. 117. In the application of the rule, each cas......
-
Woburn Degreasing Co. v. Spencer Kellogg & Sons
...30 F.Supp. 671; Parker Rust-Proof Co. v. Western Union Tel. Co., 2 Cir., 105 F.2d 976; Society of European Stage Authors & Composers, Inc., et al. v. WCAU Broadcasting Co., D.C., 35 F.Supp. 460 (Dept. of Justice Bulletin No. 95) (copyright Within its sound discretion the court has a right t......