Spears v. BEAUREGARD PARISH SCHOOL BD.
Decision Date | 27 June 2003 |
Docket Number | No. 2002-CC-2870.,2002-CC-2870. |
Citation | 848 So.2d 540 |
Parties | L.D. SPEARS, Jr. v. BEAUREGARD PARISH SCHOOL BOARD. |
Court | Louisiana Supreme Court |
David W. Burton, District Attorney, Counsel for Applicant.
James I. Funderburk, Abbeville, Nancy Dunning, Counsel for Respondent.
Sanettria R. Glasper, Robert L. Hammonds, Baton Rouge, Counsel for Louisiana School Board Association.
At issue in the case is whether the school board or the teacher must pay the cost of preparation of the transcript of a teacher removal hearing held pursuant to La. R.S. 17:443, when the teacher seeks review of the action of the school board before the district court. After reviewing the record and the applicable law, we reverse the judgment of the court of appeal and hold that the teacher is responsible for these costs.
Plaintiff, L.D. Spears, Jr. ("Spears"), formerly served as principal of East Beauregard School, which is part of the Beauregard Parish school system. Spears was subject of a removal hearing before the Beauregard Parish School Board (the "School Board") from January 12, 1998, through January 18, 1998, conducted in accordance with La. R.S. 17:443. After reviewing documentary evidence and hearing the testimony of numerous witnesses, the School Board found that Spears had committed four acts of dishonesty and directed that Spears be removed as principal. The School Board also placed Spears on administrative leave, at full pay, through August 3, 1998, and instructed the Superintendent of the Beauregard Parish school system to offer Spears a teaching position at any school in Beauregard Parish, except East Beauregard School, at teacher's pay, beginning August 4, 1998. Spears is now teaching math at the high school level at South Beauregard School.
On February 23, 1998, Spears filed a suit for declaratory judgment and injunctive relief in the district court asking that the School Board be enjoined from filling his position as principal. The trial court rejected Spears' claim, the Third Circuit Court of Appeal affirmed that ruling, and this Court denied Spears' writ application. Spears v. Beauregard Parish School Board, 98-1604 (La.App. 3 Cir. 3/31/99), 732 So.2d 671, writ denied, 99-1270 (La.6/18/99), 745 So.2d 608. Thereafter, Spears filed a "Petition for Appeal from LSA R.S. 17:443 Removal Hearing" in the district court on October 1, 1998. As prayed for in the petition, the trial court signed an order directing the School Board to produce and file the transcript of the removal hearing with the trial court within thirty days. This was not done and no further pleadings were filed until Spears filed a "Motion and Order to Fix for Trial" on December 12, 2001, which the trial court denied on January 16, 2002 as follows:
Request for trial date denied. This is request for review of administrative hearing. Court review in such cases is based upon record of case and transcript of hearing. No trial date is necessary. Court will review matter when transcript is filed. Trial de novo not authorized.
On March 7, 2002, Spears filed a "Motion for School Board to Pay Transcript Costs," which was set for hearing on April 25, 2002. The Board filed a "Motion to Set Aside Ex Parte Order" directed at the order previously signed by the trial judge ordering the School Board to produce and file the transcript. At this point, the School Board had voluntarily provided and paid a certified court reporter to record Spears' removal hearing and had already paid the court reporter $3,140.00 for attending and transcribing the School Board's findings and decision. The estimated cost of transcribing the remaining portion of the hearing, including the testimony adduced at the hearing, is $10,000.00. At the April 25, 2002, hearing, the trial court denied Spears' motion and at the School Board's request, set a schedule for the perfection of Spears' appeal. The trial court adopted the provisions of La. C.C.P. art. 2126, requiring that Spears, as the appellant, post a deposit equal to the estimated costs, including the cost of the preparation of the transcript, with the clerk of court. Spears was ordered to post these costs within twenty days of the notification thereof or suffer dismissal of his suit.
On Spears' application, the court of appeal rendered a decision reversing the trial court's judgment and holding the School Board responsible for paying the advanced costs of the transcript to be filed in the trial court. Spears v. Beauregard Parish School Board, 02-515 (La.App. 3 Cir. 10/30/02), 829 So.2d 1156. The court of appeal, in reversing the trial court, reasoned as follows:
Although it is the disciplined teacher who must initiate trial court proceedings within the one year prescriptive period provided in the statute, it is the school board who must satisfy the trial court that the hearing was conducted in accordance with the authority and formalities of the statute; that there was substantial evidence presented to support the school board's findings of fact, and the action taken by the school board as a result of these factual findings was neither arbitrary nor an abuse of the school board's discretion. It would be extremely difficult, if not impossible, for the school board to establish for the trial court that it acted in accordance with the provisions of La. R.S. 17:443 unless the school board produces for the court the entire record of that proceeding, including the transcript. Thus, it becomes the school board's responsibility to pay for the transcription of the proceeding and the filing of the record into the trial court proceeding.
Id. at 1159. We granted the School Board's writ application to consider the correctness of that ruling. Spears v. Beauregard Parish School Board, 03-2870, 836 So.2d 82 (La.2/7/03).
"The Teacher Tenure Law ("TTL"), originally enacted by Act 100 of 1922 and amended and reenacted by Acts 58 and 79 of 1936, defines the status of Louisiana's public school teachers and outlines the procedures a school board must follow to discharge them." Wright v. Caldwell Parish School Bd., 98-1225 (La.3/2/99), 733 So.2d 1174, 1175 ( ). Under the TTL, permanent teachers are entitled to strict substantive and procedural protections before they can be removed from office, including specific enumerated grounds for discharge, a hearing by the school board prior to discharge, and judicial review of the school board action. Id. For purposes of the TTL, a "teacher" is an employee of the parish school board, including a principal, who holds a teacher's certificate and whose legal employment requires such certificate. Rousselle, supra.1 La. R.S. 17:443 provides the procedure for removal of a permanent or tenured teacher:
Thus, in accordance with La. R.S. 17:443(B), a permanent teacher who is found guilty by a school board after a removal hearing may petition a court of competent jurisdiction for a full hearing to review the action of the school board. However, while La. R.S. 17:443 specifies...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Oliver v. Orleans Parish Sch. Bd.
...Interests, 53 La. B.J. 445 (2006).13 Howell v. Winn Parish Sch. Bd., 332 So.2d 822, 827 (La.1976).14 Spears v. Beauregard Parish School Board, 02–2870 (La.6/27/03), 848 So.2d 540.15 U.S.C.A. Const. Amend. 14; La. Const. art. 1, § 2; La. R.S. ...
-
Powell v. Rapides Parish Sch. Bd.
...thirty days after Ms. Powell's brief was filed.Shortly thereafter, the supreme court issued its opinion in Spears v. Beauregard Parish Sch. Bd. , 02-2870 (La. 6/27/03), 848 So.2d 540, making it clear that Ms. Powell, as the terminated teacher and the appellant, was required to pay the cost ......
-
Nickerson v. Webster Parish Sch. Bd.
...public school teachers and outlines the procedures a school board must follow to discharge them. Spears v. Beauregard Parish Sch. Bd., 02–2870 (La.6/27/03), 848 So.2d 540, citing Wright v. Caldwell Parish Sch. Bd., 98–1225 (La.3/2/99), 733 So.2d 1174. A permanent or tenured teacher is one w......
-
Lee v. East Baton Rouge Parish School Bd.
...the recent cases of Wise v. Bossier Parish Sch. Bd., 02-1525 (La. 6/27/03), 851 So.2d 1090, 1098, and Spears v. Beauregard Parish Sch. Bd., 02-2870 (La.6/27/03), 848 So.2d 540, 544 n. 2. Therefore, contrary to the school board's argument, the district court is authorized to allow a teacher ......