Special Indem. Fund v. Mayo, 38515

Decision Date03 May 1960
Docket NumberNo. 38515,38515
Citation351 P.2d 1008
PartiesSPECIAL INDEMNITY FUND of the State of Oklahoma, administered by the State Insurance Fund, Wylie-Stewart Machinery Co., and Employers' Liability Assurance Corporation, Ltd., Petitioners, v. Lawson C. MAYO and the State Industrial Court, Respondents.
CourtOklahoma Supreme Court

Syllabus by the Court.

1. Under Workmen's Compensation Law, 85 O.S.1951, Section 22, Subd. 6, a disability cannot be ordinarily classified as total where the earning power of employee is not wholly destroyed and there remains some capacity to perform remunerative labor.

2. The contention of Special Indemnity Fund that the State Industrial Court was without power to enter an award against it because claimant was permanently totally disabled prior to the time he received his last accidental injury for which compensation against his employer and insurance carrier was sought and recovered, cannot be sustained under the record herein.

Original proceeding brought by Special Indemnity Fund of the State of Oklahoma, administered by the State Insurance Fund, to review an award entered by the State Industrial Court in favor of Lawson C. Mayo, claimant. Award sustained.

Mont R. Powell, Jack Baird, Fisher & O'Toole, Oklahoma City, for petitioners.

Spencer W. Lynn, Oklahoma City, Mac Q. Williamson, Atty. Gen., for respondents.

HALLEY, Justice.

Lawson C. Mayo, employee-claimant, admittedly sustained on May 26, 1958, an accidental personal injury while in the scope of his employment with Wylie-Stewart Machinery Company, hereinafter called company or employer. In his claim for compensation he alleged to be a physically imparied person by reason of pre-existing disabilities, and sought to recover against the employer and the Special Indemnity Fund. After a hearing participated in by all parties the trial judge found: (a) before receiving his injury on May 26, 1958, claimant was a physically impaired person due to disabilities previously adjudged and determined, and as a result of the combination of all the prior injuries he had 80 per centum permanent partial disability to the body as a whole; (b) claimant suffered additional 10 per centum permanent partial disability to the body as a whole on May 26, 1958, as a result of his last accidental injury, standing alone, for which he was entitled to statutory amount of compensation from the employer; (c) the pre-existing impairments in combination with the injury on May 26, 1958, rendered claimant permanently totally disabled; he was entitled to an award against the Special Indemnity Fund in the sum of $15,000 (for 500 weeks at the rate of $30 a week), less $1,785.83 (the total amount of temporary and permanent compensation allowed against the employer, Wylie-Stewart Machinery Company), or a total of $13,214.17.

The award of the trial judge based on the findings as outlined was affirmed on appeal by the State Industrial Court, en banc.

The Fund brings the cause before this Court to obtain a review of the award. The employer, Wylie-Stewart Machinery Company and Employers' Liability Assurance Corporation, Ltd., its insurance carrier, are made parties to the proceeding. No brief was filed on behalf of the Fund which adopted the contentions advanced by the employer. In a single proposition it is urged that the State Industrial Court was without authority to enter an award inasmuch as medical evidence disclosed claimant was permanently totally disabled prior to the last injury on May 26, 1958, Special Indemnity Fund v. Prewitt, 201 Okl. 308, 205 P.2d 306.

Undisputed proof in the record reveals a lengthy history of multiple pre-existing impairments: (a) claimant receives a pension from the Veterans Administration for 30 per centum service-connected disability due to a kidney infection; (b) on February 3, 1955, while employed by a transport company, he suffered an industrial injury to his head, neck and arm for which he obtained an award for 25 per centum permanent partial disability to the body as a whole; (c) on July 28, 1955, he sustained a severe accidental injury to the back consisting of a ruptured disc which required a laminectomy. A sizeable award for permanent partial disability was entered in his favor in New Mexico; (d) in 1956 he received another industrial injury to the upper portion of his back which also aggravated the previous condition and resulted in an award for permanent partial disability of 25 per centum to the body as a whole; (e) in July 1957, claimant suffered an injury to the low back. He received an award for 10 per centum permanent partial disability to the body as a whole; (f) the last accident occurred on May 26, 1958, and resulted in injury to his neck, shoulders and head.

Claimant originally sought to recover against the Fund after receiving an award for the preceding injury of July 1957, which, he maintained at the time, in combination with all of his pre-existing impairments, as outlined, had rendered him permanently totally disabled. The issue was then determined adversely to him. The order denying recovery against the Fund was affirmed by the State Industrial Court, en banc. The instant proceeding was commenced following claimant's last injury on May 26, 1958.

Prior to the last accident, the record discloses, claimant was engaged by the employer following a period of convalescence from the preceding injury which lasted several months. He was earning $1.25 per hour and satisfactorily performed 'light work' consisting of cleaning machinery equipment preparatory to painting. Dr. G, a neutral examiner, testified that although virtually unfit before the last injury for 'full unrestricted labor', claimant was neverthless capable of performing work 'lighter than ordinary manual labor.' Following the accident of May 26, 1958, Dr. G stated, his condition was such that there no longer was any work 'light enough' which he could do. As a result of the last injury standing alone, the physician continued, he suffered additional 5 per centum permanent partial disability to the body as a whole.

Dr. H, (as expert witness for the employee) after making due allowance for interim amelioration evaluated the condition prior to the last accident at approximately 80 per centum permanent partial disability to the body as a whole, and at 20 per centum due to the injury of May 26, 1958, standing alone. All the prior injuries combined with the latter, the physician followed, had rendered claimant permanently totally disabled.

It is not amiss to note that the two physicians who gave testimony for the Fund both stated claimant, before his last accident, had considerably less than total permanent disability.

The record, viewed in its entirety, amply shows employee possessed a modicum or residuum of capacity to engage in gainful occupation prior to sustaining the last specific injury for which compensation was awarded.

Under the Workmen's Compensation Law, 85 O.S.1951 § 22, par. 6, a disability cannot be ordinarily classified as total where the earning power of the workman is not wholly destroyed and there remains some capacity to perform remunerative employment without material discomfort or pain. Oklahoma Gas & Electric Co. v. Hardy, 179 Okl. 624, 67 P.2d 445; Dierks Lumber & Coal Co. v. Lindley, 182 Okl. 185, 77 P.2d 44; Starr Coal Co. v. Evans, 199 Okl. 342, 184 P.2d 638; Clyde's Auto Salvage & Coal Operators Cas. Co. v. Hughes, 204 Okl. 467, 231 P.2d 356; Special Indemnity Fund v. Long, Okl., 281 P.2d 933.

In Starr Coal Co. v. Evans, supra [199 Okl. 342, 184 P.2d 640] we said:

'Petitioner also contends that by reason of respondent's prior injury he was totally permanently disabled within the...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT