Spraigue v. Thompson
Decision Date | 26 April 1886 |
Citation | 6 S.Ct. 988,118 U.S. 90,30 L.Ed. 115 |
Parties | SPRAIGUE and others, Owners of the Saxon. v. THOMPSON. Filed |
Court | U.S. Supreme Court |
H. B. Tompkins, for plaintiffs in error.
No appearance for defendant in error.
This was an action at law, begun by the defendant in error in a magistrate's court in Chatham county, Georgia, against the plaintiffs in error, to recover $93.16, claimed to be due under the pilotage laws of Georgia, for inward pilotage on account of the steamer Saxon, of which the defendants were owners, the vessel having been spoken by the pilot while she was bearing towards the port of Savannah, and his services offered outside of Tybee bar, and refused, the vessel having arrived in port piloted by another Savannah pilot, who spoke her and entered on the discharge of his duties as pilot on the same day, but subsequently to the tender by the plaintiff below of his services. There was a judgment in favor of the plaintiff below in the magistrate's court for the amount claimed, which was reversed on appeal by the superior court of Chatham county, which judgment was in its turn reversed by the supreme court of Georgia, which ordered judgment to be entered for the plaintiff below. To reverse this judgment this writ of error is brought.
The case was submitted and decided upon an agreed statement of facts, as follows: ...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Cobb v. Department of Public Works
...969, 970 (3, 4), 971 (9); Johnson Transfer & Freight Lines v. Perry (D. C.) 47 F.(2d) 900-902 (8, 9). See, also, Spraigue v. Thompson, 118 U. S. 90, 6 S. Ct. 988, 30 L. Ed. 115. The ruling in Clark v. Poor, 274 U. S. 554, is to be distinguished from a case such as the present as shown by th......
-
State v. Watkins
... ... the main purpose of the act or cause results not contemplated ... in enacting the statute, as in Spraigue v. Thompson, ... 118 U.S. 90, 6 S.Ct. 988, 30 L.Ed. 115; 6 R. C. L. 129 ... Section ... 5 is designed to indicate that the statute ... ...
-
McCabe v. Atchison, T. & S.F. Ry. Co.
... ... by the Legislature one they may never have been willing by ... itself to enact.' ... In ... Spraigue v. Thompson, 118 U.S. 90, 94, 6 Sup.Ct. 988, 30 ... L.Ed. 115, the Legislature of Georgia had enacted a statute ... which would have been valid if ... ...
-
Galveston, H. & S. A. Ry. Co. v. Davidson
...substitute for the law intended by the Legislature one they may never have been willing by itself to enact." In Spraigue v. Thompson, 118 U. S. 90, 6 Sup. Ct. 988, 30 L. Ed. 115, it is again said: "The insuperable difficulty of an application of that principle to the present instance is tha......