State ex rel. Crumpacker v. LaPorte Circuit Court, 575S137
Decision Date | 10 December 1975 |
Docket Number | No. 575S137,575S137 |
Citation | 264 Ind. 27,338 N.E.2d 261 |
Parties | STATE of Indiana on the relation of Owen W. CRUMPACKER, Relator, v. LaPORTE CIRCUIT COURT and Honorable Alban M. Smith, Judge thereof, Respondents. |
Court | Indiana Supreme Court |
Richard A. Miller, Owen W. Crumpacker (pro se), Hammond, for relator.
Paul J. Baldoni, LaPorte, for respondents.
Relator, a lawyer, brought this original action. He claims that the respondent court made two orders against him without jurisdiction of his person or of the subject matter and moves this Court to require the respondent court to expunge them.
The orders were made on March 24, 1975, and April 29, 1975. The first order required relator, as a condition of his withdrawal as counsel for a party in a civil suit, to deliver his files relating to the case to his former clients and to return funds advanced by them on his contingent attorney fee together with unused funds advanced for pre-trial expenses. In the second order the respondent court found him in contempt for failure to comply with the March 24th order. On May 22, 1975, relator filed a motion to correct errors addressed to the March 24th order. The record before us does not reveal the disposition made of that motion to correct errors or whether an additional motion to correct errors was addressed to the order of April 29, 1975.
After these events, on June 22, 1975, relator submitted this original action to us. Embedded in the law governing original actions in this Court is the principle that a full and adequate legal remedy by way of appeal forecloses the right to extraordinary equitable relief by way of mandate or prohibition. O.A.Rule (A); State ex rel. Collins v. Lake Superior Court, Room Number 4 (1954), 233 Ind. 536, 121 N.E.2d 731; State ex rel. Beatty v. Nichols (1954), 233 Ind. 432, 120 N.E.2d 407; American Aggregates Corp. v. Superior Court of Marion County, Room 2 (1935), 207 Ind. 544, 194 N.E. 148. Here both orders meet the criteria for final judgments. Thompson v. Thompson (1972), 259 Ind. 266, 286 N.E.2d 657; Kalleres v. Glover (1935), 208 Ind. 472, 196 N.E. 679. Relator has not sought to establish that his appellate rights are inadequate or incomplete, and such was his burden. State ex rel. Conrad v. Hendricks Circuit Court (1967), 249 Ind. 141, 231 N.E.2d 145; State ex rel. Barner v. White Circuit Court (1958), 237 Ind. 443, 147 N.E.2d 10. Under the allegations, both orders may have been preceded by jurisdictional error and may themselves be jurisdictionally defective. Even so, under these circumstances, relator's remedy is by way of appeal. State ex rel. Rans v. Fulton Circuit Court (1960), 240 Ind. 288, 164 N.E.2d 111; State ex rel. Collins v. Lake Superior Court, Room Number 4, supra; State ex rel. Beatty v. Nichols, supra; State ex rel. Adams v. Hammitt (1939), 216 Ind. 237, 24 N.E.2d 30; State ex rel....
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Custody of Helwig, In re
...225. Once a judgment is final, the proper method to redress alleged errors is through an appeal. In State ex rel. Crumpacker v. LaPorte Circuit Court, (1975) 264 Ind. 27, 338 N.E.2d 261, an attorney brought an original action, claiming that the trial court had made two orders against him wi......
-
State ex rel. Wonderly v. Allen Circuit Court, 880S343
... ... State ex rel. Crumpacker v. LaPorte Circuit Court, (1975) 264 Ind. 27, 29, 338 N.E.2d 261, 262 ... The writ ... ...
-
State ex rel. Burns v. Sharp
... ... William T. SHARP, Special Judge of the Clay Circuit Court, ... Clay County, Indiana, and the Clay Circuit ... (Citations omitted.)" State ex rel. Crumpacker v. LaPorte Circuit Court, (1975) 264 Ind. 27, 338 N.E.2d ... ...
-
State ex rel. Courtney v. Superior Court of Marion County, Criminal Div. Four
... ... State ex rel. Pebblecreek, Inc. v. Clark Circuit Court (1982), Ind., 438 N.E.2d 984, 985. The denial of a motion for ... White 271 Ind. at 175-76, 391 N.E.2d at 597; State ex rel. Crumpacker v. LaPorte Circuit Court (1975), 264 Ind. 27, 29, 338 N.E.2d 261, 262 ... ...