State ex rel. Freebourn v. Yellowstone County
Decision Date | 02 March 1939 |
Docket Number | 7910. |
Citation | 88 P.2d 6,108 Mont. 21 |
Parties | STATE ex rel. FREEBOURN, Atty. Gen., v. YELLOWSTONE COUNTY et al. |
Court | Montana Supreme Court |
Original proceeding by the State of Montana, on the relation of Harrison J. Freebourn, Attorney General of the State of Montana, against Yellowstone County and others, to enjoin the issuance of a tax deed to certain property belonging to the state.
Permanent writ of injunction granted.
W. W Wertz, of Helena, for relator.
Geo. S Smith, of Billings, for respondents.
This cause comes before this court upon an original proceeding for injunctive relief, based upon a complaint and petition for injunction, and upon an order to show cause and temporary injunction issued by this court. The respondents have filed their answer and also supporting affidavits. The facts are not in dispute.
By Chapter 118 of the Laws of the Eighth Legislative Assembly 1903, establishment of a sub-experimental station of the Agricultural Experimental Station near Billings, Montana, was provided for, and provision was also made for acquiring land for that purpose. Section 3 of that chapter provided: "That for the purpose of securing title to the land selected by them for said sub-station, the Governor and Secretary of State are hereby authorized and empowered to either use the land hereto-fore acquired by the State for the Eastern State Prison, near Billings and described as: [here follows a description of numerous lots and blocks], or if such land, in their judgment is not suitable for the purpose of such sub-experimental station, then they shall and are hereby empowered to convey such land described as aforesaid in exchange for such suitable tract of land for the sub-experimental station as they may deem of at least equal value."
The land for the Eastern State Prison had been acquired under an Act of the legislature of the session of 1893, page 194. The establishment of the Eastern State Prison had evidently been abandoned, although land had been secured therefor. Apparently the land for a prison site was traded, and there was acquired by the State of Montana, under Chapter 118, supra, a site for a sub-experimental station, described as the S1/2 SE1/4 SE1/4 of section five (5), Township one (1) South, Range Twenty-six (26) East, comprising twenty (20) acres, more or less.
The project for a sub-experimental station near Billings was also abandoned, and, in view of the abandonment of the project, the state legislature in 1907 passed legislation, which was included in Chapter 188 of the Laws of 1907. The portion dealing with the lands here in question is as follows: "The State Board of Land Commissioners is hereby empowered to sell and dispose of all lands acquired under and by virtue of the provisions of Chapter 118, Session Laws of 1903, upon the same terms and conditions as provided by law for the sale and disposition of all other state lands."
In 1913 a strip of land four hundred feet (400') in width and extending across the S1/2 SE1/4 SE1/4 of section five (5) Township one (1) South, Range Twenty-six (26) East, immediately north of the south line thereof, was included in the O'Donnell Drain Special Assessment District in Yellowstone county. Special drain assessments were levied against the land which belonged to the state, and subsequently the lands were offered for sale for delinquent drainage district assessments. In what year this happened we are not informed. Just prior to the initiation of this proceeding, Yellowstone county, acting through its board of county commissioners and county clerk and recorder, gave notice of application for tax deed, and, unless restrained, the county treasurer of that county will issue a tax deed to the state's land which is included in the drain district.
At the time of the creation of the O'Donnell Drain Special Assessment District in 1913, there was in effect an Act approved March 7, 1905, Chapter 106, Ninth Legislative Session, and appearing as sections 2403 to 2497 in the Revised Codes of 1907. Section 2443 of the 1907 Codes reads as follows: There was also included in the Act approved March 7, 1905, above cited, a section to which no reference was made by either party to this proceeding, which has some bearing on the proceeding. This provision became section 2451 of the Revised Codes of 1907, and reads in part as follows: "All drain taxes assessed under the provisions of this act shall be subject to the same interest and charges, and shall be collected in the same manner as State and other general taxes are collected, and collecting officers are hereby vested with the same power and authority in the collection of such taxes as are or may be conferred by law for collecting general taxes."
To bring the history of this law up to date, we find that the Drain District Law was amended by Chapter 144 of the Eleventh Legislative Assembly, 1909, but the two sections above mentioned were not changed. Again we find that by Chapter 147 of the Fourteenth Legislative Assembly, 1915, the Drain District Law was re-enacted and amended, but that the two sections above mentioned were re-enacted without any substantial change. However, the present Drain District Law was enacted in 1921, as Chapter 129, Laws of 1921, and section 2443 of the 1907 Codes, supra, was apparently replaced by what has become section 7326 of the 1935 Codes, as follows:
In Chapter 129 of the Laws of 1921 the section known as section 2451 of the Codes of 1907, supra, was replaced in part by a section which became section 7329 of the Codes of 1935, as follows:
In order to get a complete picture of the legislation germane to this case, we will cite that portion of Chapter 129 of the Laws of 1921, which is now section 7364 of the 1935 Codes ...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Heiser v. Severy
... ... acting Montana State Fish and Game Commission, and others, to ... recover a gun ... hunting game birds in a field in Broadwater county, at which ... time and place 'the defendant Jack Thompson, ... 33; Fisk v. Cuthbert, 2 Mont. 593; State ex rel ... Journal Pub. Co. v. Kenney, 9 Mont. 389, 24 P. 96; ... Mont. 462, 54 P.2d 579; State ex rel. Freebourn v ... Yellowstone County, 108 Mont. 21, 88 P.2d 6; ... ...
-
United States v. Christensen
...M.1947. 5 See also State ex rel. City of Billings v. Osten, 1931, 91 Mont. 76, 80, 5 P.2d 562. 6 See State ex rel. Freebourn v. Yellowstone County, 1939, 108 Mont. 21, 27, 88 P.2d 6. 7 Other statutes dealing with redemption include sections 84-4154, 84-4155 and 8 The lien for the special im......
-
Sutter v. Scudder
... ... from District Court, Tenth District, Fergus County; S ... McConochie, Judge ... Suit to ... court has so indicated in State ex rel. Freebourn v ... Yellowstone County, 108 Mont. 21, ... ...
-
Peretti v. State
...constitutional provision or by statute. See, e.g., Heiser v. Severy (1945), 117 Mont. 105, 158 P.2d 501; State ex rel. Freebourn v. Yellowstone County (1939), 108 Mont. 21, 88 P.2d 6. Read by itself, Sec. 18-1-404, MCA, appears to provide just such an unambiguous and specific waiver of the ......