State v. Noyes
Decision Date | 07 May 1940 |
Citation | 13 A.2d 187,111 Vt. 178 |
Parties | STATE v. EARL NOYES |
Court | Vermont Supreme Court |
February Term, 1940.
INFORMATION for breach of the peace. Plea of not guilty. Trial by jury by Rutland Municipal Court, Christopher A Webber, Judge. Verdict and judgment of guilty, respondent excepted. The opinion states the case.
Exceptions overruled.
James E. Bigelow for the respondent.
Robert T. Stafford, City Grand Juror of the City of Rutland for the State.
Present: MOULTON, C. J., SHERBURNE, BUTTLES, STURTEVANT and JEFFORDS, JJ.
This respondent was charged with having committed a breach of the peace "by threatening, assaulting and striking with his motor vehicle another person, to-wit: one Joe LaPine." The jury found him guilty, and judgment was entered upon the verdict. The cause is here upon his exceptions.
The affair took place on Park Street in the City of Rutland near the north gate of the premises of the Rutland Agricultural Association, upon which the annual fair was then being held. The fence enclosing the fair grounds abuts upon the highway, but there is a space between the fence and the surfaced roadway which, with the knowledge and consent of the mayor of the city, had been set aside as a parking area for the use of the officials of the association. LaPine was an employee of the association and was stationed at the place for the purpose of directing the parking of automobiles, but he was not a member of the city police and had no legal authority to control the movements of motor vehicles. The testimony as to what happened was conflicting, but it was open to the jury to find that the respondent drove his car off the surfaced part of the street, and was about to enter a vacant space in the parking area when LaPine stepped in front of his car and stopped him. Upon inquiry from the respondent LaPine informed him that he was under orders from the mayor to reserve that space for the officials of the fair. The respondent pungently expressed his disdain of the mayor, said that, being a heavy taxpayer, he was going in there regardless of his orders, told LaPine to get out of the way or he would run over him, and at once put his car in motion. LaPine jumped aside, but too late, for he was struck and injured to an extent requiring medical attention.
The trial judge charged as follows: An...
To continue reading
Request your trial