State v. Regan
| Decision Date | 27 July 1990 |
| Docket Number | No. 89-01309,89-01309 |
| Citation | 564 So.2d 1208 |
| Parties | 62 Ed. Law Rep. 796, 15 Fla. L. Weekly D1938 STATE of Florida, Appellant, v. Howard REGAN, Appellee. |
| Court | Florida District Court of Appeals |
Robert A. Butterworth, Atty. Gen., Tallahassee, and Robert J. Krauss, Asst. Atty. Gen., Tampa, for appellant.
No appearance by appellee.
We affirm the trial court's downward departure from the sentencing guidelines. The trial court imposed two years community control followed by five years probation upon defendant's conviction for the purchase of cocaine within 1,000 feet of a school. The guidelines recommended 3 1/2 to 4 1/2 years imprisonment.
The trial court's reasons for the downward departure were as follows:
1. This crime occurred on Saturday, October 29, 1988, at approximately 4:08 p.m., in a residential neighborhood well known as a place where drugs are used, bought and sold. The seller was an undercover police officer who is an adult black female. She could not be mistaken for a school child. The officer was deliberately standing at a location within 1,000 feet of a school for the purpose of enhancing the penalty. There is no evidence that the Defendant knew he was within 1,000 feet of a school. The Defendant is an adult male who was alone when he made the purchase and intended the cocaine for his own use. There is no indication he intended to sell or give it to a minor.
The laudable intent of the legislature in passing this law was to severely punish persons who attempt to introduce drugs into the lives of our children. The problem with this case is that there is no nexus between the purchase of the drugs and the school except proximity and that proximity was deliberately created by law enforcement. If the purchase was made 1,0001 [sic] feet from the school the guidelines sentence would be any non-state prison sanction. The Defendant needs to be punished for what he did, no more or less.
2. The Defendant is employed full-time and has held the same job for many years.
3. The Defendant, who is 43 years old, has not been arrested during his adult life.
4. The Defendant is not dangerous and does not constitute a threat to society. To place him in prison would be a waste of valuable prison space which should be used for violent criminals.
The state argues that these reasons reflect no more than the trial court's dissatisfaction with the guidelines recommended range for a crime which defendant clearly committed. Citing Scott v. State, 508 So.2d 335, 337 (Fla.1987), the state correctly argues that dissatisfaction of that kind would by itself not provide a proper basis for a downward departure. While the trial court's reasons did reflect dissatisfaction with the guidelines recommended range, that dissatisfaction appears to have been attributable not to the existence of that range as such but to the trial court's conclusion that the particular circumstances of the crime in this case ameliorated the level of defendant's guilt and indicated less moral culpability. In that regard the first reason for departure reflects that defendant knew he was not dealing with a school child, had no reason to believe that his crime had anything to do with a school or school activities or personnel, and in fact was not shown to be aware that there was a school in the vicinity. Amelioration of the level of a defendant's guilt or moral culpability may in proper circumstances justify a downward departure. See State v. Sachs, 526 So.2d 48, 50 (Fla.1988); State v. D'Alexander, 496 So.2d 1007, 1008 (Fla. 2d DCA 1986). See also State v. Herrin, 555 So.2d 1288, 1291-92 (Fla. 2d DCA 1990) (Lehan, A.C.J., concurring specially).
The fourth reason for departure--that defendant did not constitute a threat to society--is closely related to the first reason and is in these circumstances a valid reason for departure. See Sachs; State v. Bingham, 549 So.2d 1173 (Fla. 2d DCA 1989).
The crime for which defendant was convicted having been committed after the enactment of section 921.001(5), Florida Statutes (1987), it is not determinative that others of the trial court's reasons for departure were invalid.
Affirmed.
I concur with the court's opinion. This case and other similar cases, however should generate a public debate concerning the advisability of undercover police officers conducting drug transactions inside school zones. I discuss the matter in hopes that the people involved in or affected by undercover operations will carefully consider whether these activities are actually protecting our children and fulfilling the mandate of our legislature.
In 1987, the legislature increased the penalty for drug transactions within 1,000 feet of a school. § 893.13(1)(e), Fla.Stat. (1987) (). In 1989, the legislature amended this statute to mandate a minimum sentence of three years' imprisonment with no eligibility for parole or section 944.275 statutory gain-time. § 893.13(1)(e), Fla.Stat. (1989) (). If the 1989 amendment had been in effect at the time of Mr. Regan's offense, the trial court may not have been able to provide this downward departure, even though the facts of this case warrant the departure. 1
By these enactments, the legislature clearly intends to create a drug-free zone surrounding the schools where our children congregate. I fully agree with the Fourth District that this legislative goal is a "laudable purpose." State v. Burch, 545 So.2d 279, 281 (Fla. 4th DCA 1989), approved, 558 So.2d 1 (Fla.1990). Drugs are a multifaceted problem for our children. The problem is more than the temptation to use drugs. The sale of illegal drugs in a neighborhood brings street violence, an increase in the presence and use of concealed handguns and other sophisticated weapons, and a host of related social problems. I believe that our legislators, as well as our teachers, school officials, and the parents of our children, want the drug-free school zone to protect children from all these problems.
The reported appellate cases indicate that the statutorily increased penalty may have induced some police departments to conduct many routine undercover operations inside school zones rather than outside school zones. 2 The 1989 change in sentencing may encourage some police departments to conduct even more undercover operations near our schools. I am concerned that these statutory changes may inadvertantly work against the very goals which prompted the legislature to enact the statutes. Instead of creating a drug-free zone, the statutes create an...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
State v. Johns, 90-51
...has not been factored into the defendant's recommended guidelines sentence. State v. Sachs, 526 So.2d 48 (Fla.1988); State v. Regan, 564 So.2d 1208 (Fla. 2d DCA 1990). In Sachs, the defendant pleaded no contest to a charge of DUI manslaughter. The trial court departed downward from the reco......
-
Stamps v. State
...rehabilitation. This is not the first time that such a questionable sting operation has occurred in Polk County. See State v. Regan, 564 So.2d 1208 (Fla.2d DCA 1990). From my perspective, it is unfortunate that law enforcement in Polk County continues to use the school rule, not for the val......
-
State v. Jenkins, 90-2736
...of this case ameliorate the level of Defendant's guilt and indicate less moral culpability. See Sate [State] v. Regan, 15 FLW 1928 [1938, 564 So.2d 1208] (Fla. 2d DCA 1990). 6. The Court further finds it is the policy of this State "to provide meaningful alternatives to criminal imprisonmen......
-
State v. Greisdorf, 90-2648
...circumstances of this case ameliorate the level of Defendant's guilt and indicate less moral culpability. See, State v. Regan, 564 So.2d 1208 (Fla. 2d DCA 1990). 5. The Court further finds it is the policy of this State "to provide meaningful alternatives to criminal imprisonment for indivi......