State v. Robertson
| Court | Louisiana Supreme Court |
| Citation | State v. Robertson, 630 So.2d 1278 (La. 1994) |
| Decision Date | 14 January 1994 |
| Parties | 92-2660 La |
Lennie F. Perez, Richard C. Guerriero, Jr., Baton Rouge, for applicant.
Richard P. Ieyoub, Atty. Gen., Douglas P. Moreau, Dist. Atty., Premila Burns, Gwendolyn K. Brown, Baton Rouge, for respondent.
[92-2660 La. 1] KIMBALL, Justice. *
A jury convicted defendant, Allen Robertson, Jr., of two counts of first degree murder and sentenced him to death for the January 1, 1991 stabbing deaths of Morris and Kazuko Prestenback. On direct appeal to this court under La. Const. Art. 5, § 5(D), defendant appeals his conviction and sentence, assigning thirty-one assignments of error. Because we find reversible error in the failure of the trial court to sustain defendant's challenge for cause of venire member Robert Payne, we reverse the convictions and the sentence of death, pretermit discussion of defendant's remaining assignments of error, and remand for a new trial.
Defendant argues the trial judge erred in denying his challenge for cause of prospective juror, Robert Payne, thus requiring defendant to exercise one of his peremptory challenges to excuse Mr. Payne, and thereby depriving him of the use of one of his peremptory challenges.
In State v. Breedlove, 199 La. 965, 7 So.2d 221 (1942), this court held three requirements were necessary before the ruling of a trial judge refusing to sustain a defendant's challenge for cause constituted reversible error: (1) an erroneous ruling refusing to sustain the defendant's challenge for cause; (2) exhaustion of all of the defendant's peremptory challenges; and (3) the forced acceptance by defendant of an obnoxious juror, either the one that should have been excused for cause, or, if the juror was peremptorily challenged, a subsequent juror that defendant would [92-2660 La. 2] have peremptorily challenged but for the fact that he had already exhausted his peremptory challenges. 1 Chief Justice O'Neill strongly dissented, arguing the latter requirement was not necessary.
When the Louisiana Code of Criminal Procedure became effective on January 1, 1967, it was clear, as the Official Revision Comment notes, that Article 800 legislatively overruled the Breedlove decision in part by adopting the dissenting opinion of Chief Justice O'Neill regarding the third requirement. 2 Thus, if the defendant could show (1) he had exhausted all of his peremptory challenges; and (2) the trial judge erred in refusing to sustain a challenge for cause by the defendant, then there was reversible error. 3 The error was held to be reversible, and not merely harmless, primarily because of the protection given to a defendant's right to peremptory challenges found in the Louisiana Constitution at Article 1, Section 17. As explained in State v. Monroe, 366 So.2d 1345, 1347 (La.1978), and State v. McIntyre, 365 So.2d 1348, 1351 (La.1978) (emphasis added):
La. Const. art. 1, § 17 provides that the accused has a right to challenge jurors peremptorily; the number of challenges to be fixed by law. La.Code Crim.P. art. 799 provides that in trials of offenses punishable by death or necessarily by imprisonment at hard labor, each defendant shall have twelve peremptory challenges. Therefore, an erroneous ruling of a trial judge which deprives a defendant of one of his peremptory challenges constitutes a substantial violation of a constitutional or statutory right requiring reversal of his conviction and sentence. La.Code Crim.P. art. 921.
In 1983, Article 800 was amended and currently provides in pertinent part:
A defendant may not assign as error a ruling refusing to sustain a challenge for cause made by him, unless an objection thereto is made at the time [92-2660 La. 3] of the ruling. The nature of the objection and grounds therefore shall be stated at the time of objection.
Whereas before 1983, a defendant who had been erroneously denied a valid challenge for cause could not even complain about the error on appeal unless he had exercised all his peremptory challenges, under the new version of Article 800, a defendant is now permitted to complain of a ruling refusing to sustain his challenge for cause even if he had not thereafter exercised all of his peremptory challenges. State v. Vanderpool, 493 So.2d 574, 575 (La.1986). See also State v. Copeland, 530 So.2d 526, 535 (La.1988). In such a case, the defendant must be able to show some prejudice in order to overcome the requirement of La.C.Cr.P. art. 921 that "[a] judgment or ruling shall not be reversed by an appellate court because of any error ... which does not affect substantial rights of the accused."
The 1983 amendment to Article 800 does not change the law, however, as regards a defendant who has exhausted all of his peremptory challenges. State v. Ross, 623 So.2d 643, 644 (La.1993) (citing McIntyre ) (citations omitted) (emphasis added). See also State v. Bourque, 622 So.2d 198, 225 (La.1993); State v. Lee, 559 So.2d 1310, 1317 (La.1990); State v. Comeaux, 514 So.2d 84 93 (La.1987); and State v. Brown, 496 So.2d 261, 263-66 (La.1986). To prove there has been reversible error warranting reversal of the conviction, defendant need only show (1) the erroneous denial of a challenge for cause; and (2) the use of all his peremptory challenges. Ross, 623 So.2d at 644; Bourque, 622 So.2d at 225; McIntyre, 365 So.2d at 1351.
Defendant in this case exhausted all of his peremptory challenges. Therefore, we must determine whether the trial court erred in denying defendant's challenge for cause as to potential juror Robert Payne. If so, then defendant's constitutional and statutory right to 12 peremptory challenges has been violated, prejudice is presumed, and there is reversible error requiring reversal of the convictions and sentence. 4
[92-2660 La. 4] At issue in this case is a challenge for cause based on a potential juror's apparent predisposition to automatically impose the death penalty, regardless of any evidence that might be developed at the trial or the sentencing hearing, and regardless of the fact the law requires a juror to consider mitigating circumstances in the sentencing phase. Under La.C.Cr.P. art. 797(2), a defendant may challenge a juror for cause on the ground that "[t]he juror is not impartial, whatever the cause of his partiality." Additionally, La.C.Cr.P. art. 797(4) provides a defendant may challenge a juror for cause on the ground that "[t]he juror will not accept the law as given to him by the court."
A trial judge is vested with broad discretion in ruling on challenges for cause, and his ruling will be reversed only when a review of the entire voir dire reveals the judge abused his discretion. State v. Knighton, 436 So.2d 1141, 1148 (La.1983). A refusal by a trial judge to excuse a prospective juror on the ground he is not impartial is not an abuse of discretion where, after further inquiry or instruction (frequently called "rehabilitation"), the potential juror has demonstrated a willingness and ability to decide the case impartially according to the law and the evidence. Copeland, supra, 530 So.2d at 534. "[A] challenge for cause should be granted, even when a prospective juror declares his ability to remain impartial, if the juror's responses as a whole reveal facts from which bias, prejudice or inability to render judgment according to law may be reasonably implied." State v. Hallal, 557 So.2d 1388, 1389-90 (La.1990). As Chief Justice Calogero stated in Lee, supra, 559 So.2d at 1318 (citations omitted):
When a juror expresses a predisposition as to the outcome of a trial [or in this case, as to a particular sentence], a challenge for cause should be granted. Yet, if after subsequent questioning the juror exhibits the ability to disregard previous views and make a decision based on the evidence presented at trial, the challenge is properly denied. When assessing whether a challenge for cause should be granted, the trial judge must look at the juror's responses during her entire testimony, not just "correct", isolated answers, or, for that matter, "incorrect", isolated answers.
During voir dire, Mr. Payne initially answered in the affirmative when asked by the judge whether or not he would be able to apply the law as instructed. Later, the following exchange took place between the District Attorney and Mr. Payne.
Q. .... In this case, the jury, if they find the defendant guilty, then will listen perhaps to additional evidence, perhaps not, then will go back and deliberate and will decide whether or not the defendant should receive the death penalty or should be sentenced to life imprisonment. Do you feel that you could carry out that part of your responsibility as a juror?
A. That's where I have a little problem with the sentencing.
[92-2660 La. 5] Q. Okay. Tell me what the problem is that you have?
A. Well, when a person--uh--it's, it's--with the double, with double murder--when he's--there are two people there and you made a decision to murder one--
Q. Uh-huh.
A. --and then you look at the other one, in that second, you've made a decision that the second one--you've you've already had a second decision, you know? That's what, that's what--the problem I have.
Q. I don't understand what the problem is.
A. Uh--
Q. Tell me what the problem is that you have?
A. --well, its's--uh--in guilt, you know. Uh--I want to use the example as a, as a hunter. Two eight point bucks come by and you know you are only supposed to kill one and you shot that eight point buck down, you know it's against the law to kill a second one, you think about it, and you still pull the trigger.
The District...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
People v. Harris
...State, 725 So 2d 613, 652 (Miss 1997), cert dismissed 525 US 1133 (1999); State v Hart, 691 So 2d 651, 656 (La 1997); State v Robertson, 630 So 2d 1278, 1280-1281 (1994); Garcia v State, 887 SW2d 846, 852 (Tex 1994) (en banc), cert denied 514 US 1005 (1995); People v Prator, 856 P2d 837, 84......
-
Wade v. Cain
...denies a challenge for cause and a defendant has exhausted his peremptory challenges. State v. Robertson, 92-2660, (La. 1/14/94), 630 So.2d 1278. Where an accused has exhausted all of his peremptory challenges before completion of the panel, he is entitled to complain on appeal of a ruling ......
-
State v. Odenbaugh
... ... State v. Jacobs, 99-1659, p. 5 (La.6/29/01), 789 So.2d 1280, 1284; State v. Cross, 93-1189 Page 25 (La.6/30/95), 658 So.2d 683, 686; State v. Maxie, 93-2158 (La.4/10/95), 653 So.2d 526, 534; State v. Robertson, 92-2660 (La.1/14/94), 630 So.2d 1278, 1280. A trial court is vested with broad discretion in ruling on challenges for cause, and its rulings will be reversed only when a review of the entire voir dire reveals the trial judge abused its discretion. Robertson, 92-2660, 630 So. 2d at p. 1281 ... ...