State v. Thompson, Cr. N
Decision Date | 10 June 1985 |
Docket Number | Cr. N |
Citation | 369 N.W.2d 363 |
Parties | STATE of North Dakota, Plaintiff and Appellant, v. Randy THOMPSON and Jackie Thompson, Defendants and Appellees. STATE of North Dakota, Plaintiff and Appellee, v. Randy and Jackie THOMPSON, Defendants and Appellants. o. 1045,o. 1051,o. 1046,o. 1052. |
Court | North Dakota Supreme Court |
Alan Duppler, States Atty., Stanton, for plaintiff and appellant.
Chapman & Chapman, Bismarck, for defendants and appellees; argued by Daniel J. Chapman, Bismarck.
Our task in these appeals is to ascertain the validity of a search warrant issued by a county magistrate on the basis of the sworn affidavit of a law enforcement officer acting on an anonymous informant's tip. We hold that, under the circumstances of this case, the search warrant should not have been issued because the officer's affidavit did not provide a substantial basis to support the magistrate's finding of probable cause, and, further, that all evidence obtained in the subsequent execution of the warrant must be suppressed.
On February 15, 1984, Mercer County Deputy Sheriff Wesley J. Berg obtained a search warrant authorizing the search of the defendants' residence and their vehicle for "marijuana, other controlled substances, and related drug paraphernalia." The search warrant was issued on the affidavit of Deputy Sheriff Berg, signed and sworn to before Donna M. Buchmann, a county magistrate. This affidavit reads:
The search warrant was executed at approximately 6:00 p.m. on February 15, 1984, by Deputy Berg and other law enforcement officers, including two special agents of the North Dakota Drug Enforcement Unit. As a result of the search, charges were filed in the District Court of Mercer County against Randy and Jackie Thompson for possession of a controlled substance with intent to deliver (288.96 grams of marijuana), a class B felony. The Thompsons were also charged in Mercer County Court with possession of drug paraphernalia, a class A misdemeanor.
On April 13, 1984, the Thompsons filed in county court, and on April 26, 1984, filed in district court, motions to suppress "any and all evidence, including personal observation of any person, made as the result of the search warrant" issued by the county magistrate. Following the submission of briefs by the parties, the county court, the Honorable O.A. Schulz, issued a memorandum opinion and order dated May 23, 1984, denying the motions. The district court, the Honorable Dennis A. Schneider, issued a memorandum opinion and order dated July 7, 1984, granting the motions.
The district court concluded that the affidavit of Deputy Berg did not comply with the standards set forth in Aguilar v. Texas, 378 U.S. 108, 84 S.Ct. 1509, 12 L.Ed.2d 723 (1964), and further explicated in Spinelli v. United States, 393 U.S. 410, 89 S.Ct. 584, 21 L.Ed.2d 637 (1969). 1 The district court recognized that the United States Supreme Court, in Illinois v. Gates, 462 U.S. 213, 103 S.Ct. 2317, 76 L.Ed.2d 527 (1983), abandoned the two-pronged Aguilar-Spinelli test in favor of a "totality of circumstances" approach for determining whether or not an informant's tip suffices to establish probable cause for the issuance of a warrant. The district court concluded, however, that Gates was inapplicable, reasoning that Gates did not "ipso facto" change North Dakota case law "which is grounded in our [State] Constitution, Article I, Section 8." In addition, the district court concluded that the affidavit failed to satisfy the "totality of circumstances" analysis of Gates. In so holding the court said:
The county court concluded that the search warrant was valid under Gates. In a bench trial had on August 20, 1984, the county court found Randy and Jackie Thompson guilty of the crime of possession of drug paraphernalia. Their convictions were based entirely on the use in evidence against them of drug paraphernalia that had been seized during the search of their residence and vehicle.
The State appeals from the district court's order suppressing evidence. 2 Although it concedes "that much of officer Berg's affidavit is merely a restatement of the word of an anonymous informant," and that the Thompsons are "probably correct" in asserting that the affidavit does not satisfy the basis of knowledge and veracity prongs of the Aguilar-Spinelli test, the State asserts that under the "totality of circumstances" analysis of Gates, the affidavit of Deputy Berg provides a substantial basis for the magistrate's determination that probable cause existed to search the Thompsons' residence and vehicle.
Randy and Jackie Thompson appeal from judgments of conviction entered in the county court. They contend in part, that the affidavit of Deputy Berg does not establish probable cause under the requirements of either Gates or Aguilar-Spinelli.
It is our view that even under the more flexible "totality of circumstances" standard of Gates, the affidavit does not provide a substantial basis for the magistrate's conclusion that probable cause existed to support the issuance of the search warrant.
In Gates, the Police Department of Bloomingdale, Illinois, a suburb of Chicago, received an anonymous letter which informed them that the defendants, husband and wife, "strictly make their living on selling drugs," and had "over $100,000.00 worth of drugs in their basement." The letter detailed the typical modus operandi of the couple's drug operation, to wit: the wife would drive their car to Florida, leave it "to be loaded up with drugs" and then fly back, after which the husband would fly down and drive the car back. The letter predicted that on May 3, the wife would be driving down to Florida and that the husband would be flying down in a few days, which would result in "over $100,000.00 in drugs" being brought back in the trunk of the car.
Acting on the tip, the police determined the defendants' address and confirmed that the husband had made a reservation to fly to West Palm Beach, Florida, on May 5. Through surveillance it was established that the husband made the flight, checked into a hotel room registered in the wife's name, and left the following morning, accompanied by an unidentified woman, in an automobile bearing Illinois license plates registered to him, heading north on an interstate highway used by travelers to the Chicago area. A search warrant was issued by a state circuit judge for the Gates' residence and automobile upon an affidavit which set forth the foregoing facts and a copy of the anonymous letter. 103 S.Ct. at 2325-26.
Gates holds that the task of a magistrate in viewing an affidavit in support of a search warrant is simply to make a practical, common-sense decision whether or not, given all the circumstances set forth in the affidavit, including the...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
State v. Sakellson
...shows there was not probable cause to support the issuance of the search warrant. Leon, 104 S.Ct. at 3421. See also State v. Thompson, 369 N.W.2d 363 (N.D.1985). While the case now before our Court involves the issue of the propriety of the service and execution of a search warrant, as oppo......
-
State v. Adkins, 16251
...817 (1985); State v. Wood, 457 So.2d 206 (La.App.1984); Commonwealth v. Honneus, 390 Mass. 136, 453 N.E.2d 1053 (1983); State v. Thompson, 369 N.W.2d 363 (N.D.1985); State v. Wise, 72 Or.App. 58, 695 P.2d 68 (1985); Adkins v. State, 675 S.W.2d 604 (Tex.App.1984). We, therefore, conclude tha......
-
State v. Ringquist, Cr. N
...course under Article 1, Sec. 8 of the North Dakota Constitution for assessing probable cause to issue a search warrant. State v. Thompson, 369 N.W.2d 363 (N.D.1985); State v. Ronngren, 361 N.W.2d 224 Although as a matter of state constitutional law we may provide the citizens of our state g......
-
State v. Lunde
...to adopt a good faith exception] for if the good-faith exception were to be adopted we would not apply it here."); State v. Thompson, 369 N.W.2d 363, 372 (N.D.1985) (explaining that even if we were to apply a good faith rule, the "affidavit was `so lacking in indicia of probable cause,' tha......