State v. Were
Decision Date | 17 June 2008 |
Docket Number | No. 2006-1578.,2006-1578. |
Citation | 2008 Ohio 2762,890 N.E.2d 263,118 Ohio St.3d 448 |
Parties | The STATE of Ohio, Appellee, v. WERE, Appellant. |
Court | Ohio Supreme Court |
Mark E. Piepmeier, Special Prosecuting Attorney, and William E. Breyer, Assistant Special Prosecuting Attorney, for appellee.
H. Fred Hoefle, Cincinnati, and Chris McEvilley, for appellant.
{¶ 1} In April 1993, inmates rioted at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility ("SOCF") in Lucasville, Ohio. During the riot, inmates killed corrections officer Robert Vallandingham. In 1995, James Were, the defendant-appellant, was convicted of aggravated murder for his participation in Vallandingham's killing and sentenced to death. On appeal, this court reversed, holding that Were had been deprived of a fair trial because the trial court did not hold a competency hearing. State v. Were (2002), 94 Ohio St.3d 173, 176-177, 761 N.E.2d 591.
{¶ 2} In 2003, a new jury convicted Were of aggravated murder and sentenced him to death. The court of appeals affirmed. State v. Were, Hamilton App. No. C-030485, 2005-Ohio-376, 2005 WL 267671. This cause is now before the court upon an appeal as of right.
{¶ 3} On Sunday afternoon, April 11, 1993, a group of inmates seized control of the L-complex ("L-Block") at SOCF. The L-Block contained eight cellblocks, and each cellblock contained 80 cells. During the riot, groups of inmates overpowered prison guards and held authorities at bay for several days. Before control was regained at the prison, several inmates and Vallandingham were killed.
{¶ 4} The riot was planned and started by a group of Muslim gang members imprisoned at SOCF. Once the riot began two other prison gangs, the Aryan Brotherhood and the Black Gangster Disciples, joined in. Carlos Sanders, Stanley Cummings, and Were — who was also known as "Namir" — were leaders of the Muslim gang during the riot. The Aryan Brotherhood, a white supremacist gang, was led by Jason Robb and George Skatzes. The Black Gangster Disciples was headed by Anthony Lavelle.
{¶ 5} After the riot started, each of the three gangs staked out separate territory within L-Block. The Muslims controlled the L-6 cellblock and stayed there for the duration of the riot. During the riot, Were wore a striped referee's shirt, signifying that he was allowed access to any area controlled by the prisoners.
{¶ 6} As the takeover began, a group of masked inmates entered the L-1 cellblock where Vallandingham was stationed. Vallandingham had locked himself into the officer's bathroom near the front of the L-1 cellblock. Several inmates turned over a metal desk and started banging that desk against the bathroom door. Inmate Steve Macko identified Were as one of the inmates near the bathroom at this time. Eventually, Vallandingham was removed from the bathroom.
{¶ 7} Were, Sanders, and Reggie Williams, another Muslim gang member, then took Vallandingham down the corridor to the L-6 cellblock. Vallandingham was put into the L-6 shower where his hands were cuffed behind his back and a sheet was placed over his head. Vallandingham was later moved to a cell in the L-6 cellblock.
{¶ 8} Organized negotiations between the authorities and the inmates began on the second day of the riot. Additionally, on the second day, the Ohio State Highway Patrol ("OSP") installed listening devices in the large tunnels underneath L-Block. Shortly thereafter, the FBI supplied more sophisticated listening devices, which were placed in crevices at ten locations underneath L-Block. Authorities then listened and recorded inmate conversations, referred to as the "tunnel tapes," during the duration of the riot. A total of 591 "tunnel tapes" were created. Also, on the second day of the riot, the water and power were turned off inside L-Block.
{¶ 9} On April 14, the public information officer for the Department of Corrections responded to media questions about inmate threats. She stated that there had been threats and that they were a standard part of the negotiations. The inmates, who were following the news on battery-operated televisions and radios, were upset by these comments and felt that the authorities were not taking them seriously.
{¶ 10} During a meeting on April 15 that was recorded on tunnel tape 61, Were and other inmate leaders discussed killing one of the hostages to show the authorities that they meant business. Were, who described himself as a hardliner, urged others to take a firmer stand during the negotiations. Were said that the water and power must be turned back on. He continued, Were also said, "[F]rom this point on we're turning it over to the hardliners."
{¶ 11} Before the April 15 meeting concluded, Were and the other inmate leaders voted to kill a corrections officer if their demands were not met. The Muslim inmates decided that Vallandingham would be killed because he had seen them kill another inmate at the beginning of the riot. After the meeting, Were stated,
{¶ 12} Around 9:00 a.m. on April 15, Skatzes had a telephone conversation with state negotiators. Skatzes said, The inmates' demands were not met.
{¶ 13} During the riot, inmate Thomas Taylor was locked in a cell in the L-6 cellblock. On the morning of April 15, Taylor saw Were and another inmate remove Vallandingham from his cell and take him to the end of the L-6 cellblock. Around the same time, inmate Sherman Sims walked past the L-6 shower area. Were was standing at the shower door and looking into the shower. Were noticed Sims and asked what he was doing there. While this exchange took place, Sims looked into the shower and saw a man with something over his head being strangled with a rope by two people. He also saw one of them "putting a bar to [the man's] throat."
{¶ 14} Were told Sims that he would have to help carry the body out of the prison. Were directed the inmates to wrap the body in sheets. At 11:10 a.m. on April 15, Sims and three other masked inmates carried Vallandingham's body from the prison and into the recreation yard.
{¶ 15} After the body was taken into the yard, Reginald Williams, a Muslim inmate, saw Were talking to Cummings while Cummings was on the phone with the state's negotiator. Were said,
{¶ 16} At 12:10 p.m. on April 15, a SWAT team recovered Vallandingham's body from the recreation yard.
{¶ 17} On April 17, Were and other inmate leaders had a meeting to discuss the progress of negotiations. This meeting was recorded on tunnel tape 32. Were argued that the hardliners should control the negotiations. During the meeting, Were said,
{¶ 18} Were continued,
{¶ 19} A short time later, Were said,
{¶ 20} The riot ended on April 21, 2003, when the remaining hostages were released. Investigators then began interviewing witnesses and collecting evidence from inside the prison. No useful physical evidence linking any person to Vallandingham's murder was ever recovered.
{¶ 21} Dr. Patrick Fardal, Franklin County Deputy Coroner, conducted the autopsy on Vallandingham. Vallandingham suffered an injury to his neck that was about eight inches in length, and another abrasion about two and one-half inches long was above the primary one. Fardal testified that petechial hemorrhages on the victim's face and eyes showed that considerable force was exerted upon Vallandingham's neck. An internal exam showed that the hyoid bone and the cornu of the thyroid cartilage had been fractured by the force exerted upon the victim's neck. Vallandingham had also suffered a small chip fracture in his anterior cervical spine. Fardal concluded that Vallandingham died from ligature strangulation. Fardal did not see anything across the victim's neck that indicated a weight bar had been used to kill him though he could not rule out the possibility that such a weapon had been used.
{¶ 22} At trial, Williams testified that after the riot, he was transferred to a prison in Mansfield, Ohio. On June 23, 1993, Were and Williams were transported on a bus from Mansfield to Lucasville. As they approached Lucasville, Were looked very concerned, and Williams asked what was bothering him. Were responded, "I think they know I killed that guard."
{...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Dickerson v. Warden
... ... UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO EASTERN DIVISION April 26, 2016 Judge Frost OPINION AND ORDER Petitioner, a state prisoner, brings this action for a writ of habeas corpus pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 2254. This matter is before the Court on the Petition (ECF No. 1), ... 3 All of these claims, being readily apparent from the face of the record, should have been raised on direct appeal, but were not. Further, Petitioner may now no longer present any of the foregoing claims to the state courts by operation of Ohio's doctrine of res judicata ... ...
-
State v. Washington
...2011-Ohio-3641, 952 N.E.2d 1121, ¶119, citing State v. Perez, 124 Ohio St.3d 122, 2009-Ohio-6179, 920 N.E.2d 104, ¶ 217; State v. Were, 118 Ohio St.3d 448, 2008-Ohio-2762, 890 N.E.2d 263, ¶219; State v. Elmore, 111 Ohio St.3d 515, 2006-Ohio-6207, 857 N.E.2d 547, ¶121. {¶142} The substance o......
-
State v. Graham
... ... The state 164 Ohio St.3d 188 presented the testimony of, among others, the two surviving robbery victims and Graham's three codefendants. A. Kremling plans to rob Haithcock { 3} Connor Haithcock, a 19-year-old, and Justin Lewandowski, a 20-year-old Kent State University student, were roommates at the Ryan Place apartments in Kent. Massa, an 18-year-old Kent State University student, often visited the apartment. { 4} Haithcock sold marijuana and "dabs," a concentrated form of tetrahydrocannabinol, also known as THC, from the apartment. Haithcock sold marijuana to 17-year-old Ty ... ...
-
State v. Lawson
... ... Lawson discarded the condom in the kitchen wastebasket. He then returned to the bedroom and covered Stacey's body with a blanket and the futon's mattress. { 13} As these events were occurring, Todd was at a worksite in Maysville, Kentucky, where he clocked in at 6:43 a.m. It was Stacey's habit to send Todd a text message early every morning to make sure he had arrived safely at work. When she failed to do so on October 11, Todd began to worry. He repeatedly tried to call and ... ...
-
Authentication
...F.R.E. 901(a) requires an audiotape to be authenticated, but does not require that it be authenticated by a witness. State v. Were , 890 N.E.2d 263 (Ohio 2008). Partly inaudible tunnel tape recordings made during a prison riot were properly admitted into evidence where participants in recor......
-
Authentication
...F.R.E. 901(a) requires an audiotape to be authenticated, but does not require that it be authenticated by a witness. State v. Were , 890 N.E.2d 263 (Ohio 2008). Partly inaudible tunnel tape recordings made during a prison riot were properly admitted into evidence where participants in recor......
-
Authentication
...F.R.E. 901(a) requires an audiotape to be authenticated, but does not require that it be authenticated by a witness. State v. Were , 890 N.E.2d 263 (Ohio 2008). Partly inaudible tunnel tape recordings made during a prison riot were properly admitted into evidence where participants in recor......
-
Authentication
...F.R.E. 901(a) requires an audiotape to be authenticated, but does not require that it be authenticated by a witness. State v. Were , 890 N.E.2d 263 (Ohio 2008). Partly inaudible tunnel tape recordings made during a prison riot were properly admitted into evidence where participants in recor......