State v. Z.A.B. (In re Z.A.B.), 14MH0001

Decision Date21 August 2014
Docket NumberA156148.,14MH0001
Citation266 Or.App. 708,338 P.3d 802 (Mem)
PartiesIn the Matter of Z.A.B., Alleged to be a Mentally Ill Person. State of Oregon, Respondent, v. Z.A.B., Appellant.
CourtOregon Court of Appeals

Garrett A. Richardson and Multnomah Defenders, Inc., for appellant's petition.

Before LAGESEN, Presiding Judge, and TOOKEY, Judge, and EDMONDS, Senior Judge.

Opinion

PER CURIAM.

Appellant has petitioned for reconsideration of our opinion in State v. Z.A.B., 264 Or.App. 779, 334 P.3d 480 (2014). In that case, we accepted the state's concession of error, and exercised our discretion to reverse the trial court's decision to commit appellant to the Addiction and Mental Health Division of the Oregon Health Authority for a period not to exceed 180 days pursuant to ORS 426.130(1)(a)(C). In his petition for reconsideration, appellant points out that we did not address a second order that was also the subject of the appeal: an order prohibiting appellant from purchasing or possessing firearms pursuant to ORS 426.130(1)(a)(D). He argues that our reversal of the commitment decision necessarily requires reversal of the firearms order, because the statutory authority to prohibit the purchase or possession of firearms under ORS 426.130(1)(a)(D) requires a determination that a person is a “person with mental illness” under ORS 426.005(1)(e) —just as is required for an order of commitment under ORS 426.130(1)(a)(C).

We agree with appellant. See State v. W.B., 264 Or.App. 777, 778, 333 P.3d 1099 (2014) (“Finding that an individual ‘is a person with mental illness' is a condition precedent to the issuance of an order prohibiting the purchase or possession of a firearm, ORS 426.130(1)(a)(D).”). Accordingly, we allow reconsideration and modify our opinion as follows:

We delete the following sentence, which appears at 264 Or.App. at 780, 334 P.3d 480 : Appellant seeks reversal of a judgment committing him for a period not to exceed 180 days pursuant to ORS 426.130.”

In its place, we substitute:

Appellant seeks reversal of an order committing him for a period not to exceed 180 days pursuant to ORS 426.130(1)(a)(C) and an order prohibiting him from purchasing or possessing firearms pursuant to ORS 426.130(1)(a)(D).”

Reconsideration allowed; former opinion modified and adhered to as modified.

To continue reading

Request your trial
16 cases
  • State v. K.M. (In re K. M.)
    • United States
    • Court of Appeals of Oregon
    • November 19, 2014
    ...of a full and fair hearing); State v. Z.A.B., 264 Or.App. 779, 780, 334 P.3d 480, adh'd to as modified on recons., 266 Or.App. 708, 338 P.3d 802, 2014 WL 5473850 (2014) (failure to advise of right to subpoena witnesses alone sufficient plain error to justify reversal); State v. B.T., 262 Or......
  • State v. D.B. (In re D.B.)
    • United States
    • Court of Appeals of Oregon
    • May 11, 2016
    ...(Internal quotation marks omitted.)); State v. Z.A.B., 264 Or.App. 779, 780, 334 P.3d 480, adh'd to as modified on recons., 266 Or.App. 708, 338 P.3d 802 (2014) (failure to advise of right to subpoena witnesses alone constitutes plain error justifying reversal); State v. M.L.R., 256 Or.App.......
  • State v. H. D. (In re H. D.)
    • United States
    • Court of Appeals of Oregon
    • April 25, 2018
    ...both the commitment order and the order prohibiting appellant from purchasing and possessing firearms. See State v. Z. A. B. , 266 Or. App. 708, 709, 338 P.3d 802 (2014) (" ‘Finding that an individual "is a person with mental illness" is a condition precedent to the issuance of an order pro......
  • State v. J. D. P. (In re J. D. P.), A163511
    • United States
    • Court of Appeals of Oregon
    • August 29, 2018
    ...results of the proceedings was plain error"); State v. Z. A. B. , 264 Or.App. 779, 780, 334 P.3d 480, adh'd to as modified on recons. , 266 Or.App. 708, 338 P.3d 802 (2014) (failure to inform a person of the right to subpoena witnesses constitutes plain error). We agree that the error is pl......
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT