Stoddard v. Eaton
Decision Date | 08 October 1927 |
Docket Number | No. 3035.,3035. |
Citation | 22 F.2d 184 |
Court | U.S. District Court — District of Connecticut |
Parties | STODDARD v. EATON, Collector of Internal Revenue. |
Henry Stoddard, of New Haven, Conn., pro se.
Frederick W. Dewart, Sp. Atty., Bureau of Internal Revenue, of Washington, D. C., and John Buckley, U. S. Atty., and George H. Cohen, Asst. U. S. Atty., both of Hartford, Conn., for defendant.
This is an action brought by the plaintiff to recover from the defendant certain additional income taxes assessed against the plaintiff in connection with his income tax returns for the years 1919, 1920, and 1921. The plaintiff paid these taxes under protest, and, his claim for refund having been rejected, he brings this action to recover the amounts paid. The additional taxes so assessed by the department and paid by the plaintiff were as follows: For the year 1919, $598.85; for 1920, $843.16, and for 1921, $2,488.47, plus interest in the amount of $502.10, making a total of $4,432.58.
The question involved is whether the plaintiff is entitled to deduct from his gross income claimed losses on the sale of securities which were held by trustees under the particular trust instrument given by the plaintiff, wherein, as it will appear, he was both donor and beneficiary.
The plaintiff is an individual and a resident of Connecticut. For a number of years it has been the custom of the plaintiff and his wife, both of whom are of advanced age, to spend the winter of each year in the South.
On December 21, 1916, the plaintiff voluntarily, for his personal convenience and purposes, and without consideration, executed, and Clifford I. Stoddard, son of the plaintiff, and the Union & New Haven Trust Company, accepted, the trust created by the following instrument:
Subsequent to the execution of this instrument, the following securities, which are referred to in the instrument as being listed in Exhibit A, were delivered to the Union & New Haven Trust Company and placed in a safe deposit box: 500 shares, Brooklyn Rapid Transit Company. 100 shares, Scranton Electric Company, preferred. 100 shares, Mackay Company, preferred. 400 shares, Interborough Consolidated Corporation, preferred. 300 shares, American Telephone & Telegraph Company. 300 shares, General Electric Company. 161 shares, Associated Dry Goods Corporation, first preferred. 80 shares, Associated Dry Goods Corporation, second preferred. $13,000 par value, New York, New Haven & Hartford Railroad Company's debenture, due March 1, 1947, Nos. 1028 to 1031, both inclusive, 1045, 1712 to 1717, both inclusive, 1937 and 1938.
The stock certificates representing part of the securities were transferred to Clifford I. Stoddard and the Union & New Haven Trust Company, trustees under the deed of Henry Stoddard.
Subsequently, Henry Stoddard, Amelia E. Stoddard, his wife, Clifford I. Stoddard, his son, and the Union & New Haven Trust Company, executed the following instrument:
From time to time, after the execution of the instrument in 1916, the plaintiff directed the sale...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
McRitchie v. Comm'r of Internal Revenue
...Act of 1934.In prior years there had not been unanimity among the courts as to the meaning of the word ‘trust.’ Compare Stoddard v. Eaton, 22 F.2d 184, 186 (D. Conn.), and Prudence Miller Trust, 7 T.C. 1245, 1248, with Hart v. Commissioner, 54 F.2d 848, 850-851 (C.A. 1). 5. The fact that pe......
-
Paster v. Commissioner
...in its application than the broad meaning of that term as sometimes used in equity. In Stoddard v. Eaton 1927 CCH ¶ 7265, 22 F. 2d 184, 186 (1927) (D. C. D. Conn.), the court held that Congress did not use the word "trust" in section 219 of the early acts as comprehending every type of trus......
-
Western Prods. Co. v. Comm'r of Internal Revenue
...acts and the Code relating to trusts are addressed to express trusts and not to constructive, resulting, or ex maleficio trusts. Stoddard v. Eaton, 22 F. 2d 184; Claud McCauley, 17 B. T. A. 886, affd. 44 F. 2d 919; Benjamin F. Wollman, 31 B. T. A. 37; Prudence Miller Trust, 7 T. C. 1245; Le......
- THE IDA B. CONWAY