Subway Restaurants, Inc. v. Kessler
| Court | Kansas Supreme Court |
| Writing for the Court | SIX; Sheppard's Rulings; Sheppard; Russell; Russell's |
| Citation | Subway Restaurants, Inc. v. Kessler, 266 Kan. 433, 970 P.2d 526 (Kan. 1998) |
| Decision Date | 18 December 1998 |
| Docket Number | Nos. 78,907,79,740,s. 78,907 |
| Parties | SUBWAY RESTAURANTS, INC., et al., Appellees, v. Nancy KESSLER and Dane Banks, Defendants, and David M. Duree, Appellant. |
Syllabus by the Court
In a non-admitted attorney's appeal from a K.S.A. 60-2007(b) monetary sanction and revocation of the attorney's pro hac vice admission to practice, the record is examined and it is held: (1) The sanctioned attorney was not denied due process of law, (2) a judge's ex parte conversation with a nonparty attorney referencing the sanctioned attorney occurring before the memorandum opinion ordering sanctions was issued was improper but does not require reversal, (3) the record reflects substantial competent evidence to support the imposition of sanctions and revocation of the pro hac vice admission, and (4) denial of the sanctioned attorney's K.S.A. 60-259(f) motion to alter or amend by a judge to whom the motion was assigned after the judge imposing the sanctions recused herself was not an abuse of discretion.
Douglas Lancaster, of Overland Park, argued the cause, and Greer S. Lang, of Lawrence, was with him on the briefs for appellant.
Edward W. Dunham, of Wiggin and Dana, of New Haven, Connecticut, argued the cause, and Stanley N. Wilkins, of Turner and Boisseau, Chartered, of Overland Park, was with him on the brief for appellees.
This is a K.S.A. 60-2007(b) attorney sanctions case. David M. Duree's pro hac vice admission to practice in Kansas was revoked and he was ordered to pay plaintiff Subway/Doctors Associates, Inc., (DAI) $408,445.25 by District Judge Janice D. Russell. Judge Russell found that Duree deliberately directed the preparation of a false 1989 partnership tax return to support his clients' fraud counterclaims. Judge Lawrence E. Sheppard, after Judge Russell recused herself, denied Duree's K.S.A. 60-259(f) motion to alter or amend, refusing to set aside Judge Russell's order. Duree appeals from the rulings of both judges.
Our jurisdiction is under K.S.A. 20-3018(c), a transfer on our own motion.
We consider two issues: (1) Was Duree denied due process by the circumstances surrounding Judge Russell's recusal, and (2) was there substantial competent evidence to support Judge Russell's imposition of sanctions and revocation of Duree's pro hac vice admission? Finding no error, we affirm.
A review of the facts in the underlying lawsuit is necessary to provide background as Duree's objections to the sanctions unfold in this appeal. Defendants in the underlying lawsuit, Nancy Kessler and Dane Banks, contracted with DAI, the national franchisor of Subway sandwich shops, to become a Subway franchisee in Olathe. Kessler and Banks borrowed to finance construction and start-up. They immediately began to pay personal expenses from the borrowed funds, leaving the shop short of the estimated start-up costs.
Lack of operating funds became an immediate problem. Kessler and Banks had seven different checking accounts at four different banks during their 19 months of operation. They bounced 224 checks and failed to deposit at least $112,219.38 in cash receipts during the first 13 months. As a result, the Subway shop's bank statements did not accurately reflect performance. The most accurate documents reflecting performance were Weekly Inventory and Sales Reports (WISR's). DAI requires all franchisees to produce WISR's. Kessler received WISR training. She testified: (1) the forms were simple to fill out and (2) the WISR's she filled out were accurate. Kessler and Banks used the WISR's in the shop's original tax return prepared September 1990 by H & R Block. The original return showed gross receipts of $139,369 and a profit of $20,143 for the first 8 1/2 months of operation. The figures in the original return were primarily from the WISR's.
DAI filed a collection action against Kessler and Banks in 1990 seeking to recover unpaid franchise royalties and arrearages on a real estate sublease and an equipment lease. Kansas counsel for Kessler and Banks filed a counterclaim in February 1991. Duree was hired sometime in the summer of 1991. Matters against DAI accounted for about 20% of Duree's practice. Judge Russell admitted Duree pro hac vice. (Duree is admitted to practice law in Missouri and Illinois.) He assumed the role as lead counsel. Kessler and Banks' series of five amended counterclaims alleging various claims, including fraud and punitive damages, commenced. The fifth amended counterclaim, central to this appeal, contained 47 allegations of fraud and a claim for punitive damages. Kessler and Banks contended that DAI had fraudulently induced them into purchasing a Subway franchise doomed to fail because of a poor location and lack of promised operational support.
Duree drafted the fifth amended counterclaim. Before filing, he decided to have an amended 1989 tax return prepared for the Subway shop. Duree hired Robert Seiffert, a CPA, from St. Louis. (Duree used Seiffert as an expert in five other cases against DAI.) They were personal friends and had a close working relationship, especially on Subway shop matters. Both Duree and Seiffert knew of the existence, use, and purpose of the shop's WISR's.
Seiffert was given all of the shop's financial documentation, including the WISR's, but he prepared the amended return using only bank records. The 1989 amended return reported a loss based on gross receipts of $71,543, compared with $139,369 on the original return. Kessler testified that she and Banks failed to deposit at least half of their cash receipts in the bank. Seiffert also admitted later in his deposition that the bank deposits "for sure understate[d] gross receipts." Seiffert attached a disclaimer to the amended return stating: "We are not able to determine whether this information supplied to us is complete and accurate." (He had been involved in the preparation of between 200 to 400 tax returns but could recall using such a disclaimer on only one or two other returns.)
Intensive and hard-fought discovery continued for the next 2 years. Duree, his co-counsel, and his clients were sanctioned $1,000 for discovery abuse by the special master appointed by Judge Russell to conduct discovery.
DAI submitted 267 statements of uncontroverted fact to support its motion for summary judgment on the fifth amended counterclaim. DAI argued that the reason Kessler and Banks failed in their business was not because of any misrepresentations made by DAI, but because of their own mismanagement. Most of the uncontroverted facts submitted by DAI came directly from either Kessler's deposition or the franchise agreement.
Kessler and Banks' response to DAI's summary judgment motion: (1) contained many accusations of unethical conduct by DAI, (2) did not comply with Rule 141(b) (1998 Kan. Ct. R. Annot. 176), (3) failed to controvert many of DAI's statements of uncontroverted facts, and instead objected on the grounds of relevancy, materiality, or that the fact was misleading, and (4) moved for sanctions against DAI's counsel Edward Dunham. (Duree later withdrew the motion for sanctions against Dunham.)
In support of the request for sanctions against Dunham, Duree submitted an affidavit from Seiffert. Seiffert repeatedly attempted to controvert facts regarding the shop's losses by pointing to the 1989 amended tax return. DAI had ignored the amended return because the copy provided during discovery was neither signed nor dated and did not appear to have been filed. Seiffert's affidavit claimed that the amended return contained the "correct figures" and that DAI had attempted to mislead the court by relying on the original return.
After reading Seiffert's affidavit, DAI realized Duree was relying on the amended return to support the claim that the Subway shop lost money. Seiffert's claim that DAI had relied on the wrong tax return was questioned at the summary judgment hearing. Seiffert testified in his deposition that he did not know if the amended return had been filed. (His deposition was taken before his sworn affidavit.) Judge Russell then questioned Duree about the amended return. Duree said that he did not know whether the return had been filed, calling it an "evidentiary detail." Judge Russell responded, Judge Russell was compelled to call a recess so that Duree and local counsel could confer and try to "get their story straight." After the hearing, it was still unclear whether the amended return had been filed. Counsel for DAI pursued the matter. DAI's motion to reopen discovery as to the 1989 amended return was granted.
Meanwhile, Judge Russell issued her opinion granting summary judgment in favor of DAI on Kessler and Banks' fifth amended counterclaim. She found the counterclaim totally without merit, stating: "It is not just that [defendants] cannot sustain their burden of proving the falsity of these statements; they have no proof whatsoever."
The Court of Appeals affirmed Judge Russell's decision, citing her "thorough and careful examination" of a voluminous record, and characterizing her analysis of the uncontroverted facts as "disciplined." Subway Restaurants, Inc. v. Kessler, No. 75,053, 931 P.2d 1270, unpublished opinion filed February 21, 1997, rev. denied, 262 Kan. ---- (1997).
Judge Russell held an evidentiary hearing on various motions for sanctions against Duree related to the summary judgment response. After a lengthy proceeding, she imposed a $5,250 monetary sanction against Duree and his co-counsel. Judge Russell found the accusations of impropriety against DAI were unfounded and an attempt to "divert [the court's] attention from the facts of the case." Duree sidestepped the issue of the 1989 amended tax return, professing...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
Canaan v. Bartee
...reviewed the denial of a K.S.A. 60-259(f) motion to alter and amend under an abuse of discretion standard. Subway Restaurants, Inc. v. Kessler, 266 Kan. 433, 441, 970 P.2d 526 (1998). The award of sanctions, including attorney fees, for discovery violations is also reviewed using an abuse o......
-
Doctor's Associates, Inc. v. Duree
...Russell's imposition of sanctions against Duree and Judge Sheppard's denial of Duree's post-trial motion. Subway Restaurants, Inc. v. Kessler, 266 Kan. 433, 970 P.2d 526, 528 (1998). The court initially reviewed Judge Sheppard's ruling and addressed Duree's contention that Judge Russell's f......
-
Price ex rel. Situated v. Philip Morris, Inc.
...support of the counterclaim. Duree, 319 Ill.App.3d at 1038, 253 Ill.Dec. 736, 745 N.E.2d at 1277 (citing Subway Restaurants, Inc. v. Kessler, 266 Kan. 433, 970 P.2d 526, 534 (1998)). The court further found that Duree violated Kansas court rules by denying uncontroverted facts with no basis......
-
Michel v. Michel
...–––– (June 13, 2012). The standard of review for a motion to alter and amend is an abuse of discretion. Subway Restaurants, Inc. v. Kessler, 266 Kan. 433, 441, 970 P.2d 526 (1998), cert. denied526 U.S. 1112 (1999). A motion to reconsider is the equivalent of a motion to alter or amend judgm......