T. M. Monroe v. Chicago & Alton Railroad Co.
| Decision Date | 02 April 1923 |
| Citation | 297 Mo. 633,257 S.W. 469 |
| Parties | T.M. MONROE v. CHICAGO & ALTON RAILROAD COMPANY, Louisiana & Mississippi Railroad Company, and John A. Brown, Appellants. |
| Court | Missouri Supreme Court |
For majority opinion, see 297 Mo. 633, 249 S. W. 644.
In Banc. Concurring opinion.
I concur in the result of this opinion, but not for the reasons stated therein. I fully recall the Steele Case, 265 Mo. 97, 175 S. W. 177, but it is not authority here. In that case the two statements were made at the same trial, and that was the matter discussed by Judge Faris. It was a much-discussed opinion at the time, and certainly goes as far as we should go. It suffices to say that it does not go far enough to be effective in any case where the two statements occur at different trials.
To continue reading
Request your trial
68 cases
-
Hancock v. Crouch
... ... Calloway v. Fogel, 358 Mo. 47, 213 S.W.2d 405, 409(4); Monroe v. Chicago & A. Ry. Co., 297 Mo. 633, 249 S.W. 644, 646(1), 257 S.W. 469 ... ...
-
London Guarantee & Accident Co. v. Woelfle
... ... Northern Pacific Railroad Co. v. Urlin, 158 U. S. 271, 275, 15 S.Ct. 840, 39 L.Ed. 977; Cleveland ... for you to look at, although they were willing to bring a man from Chicago, all the way from Chicago, pay him a hundred dollars — two hundred ... 583; Tucker v. Henniker, supra, 41 N.H. 317, at page 322; Monroe v. Chicago & Alton R. R. Co., 297 Mo. 633, 644, 249 S.W. 644, 257 S.W ... ...
-
Hardin v. Ill. Central Railroad Co.
... ... After a few days, this doctor sent him to defendant's hospital in Chicago where, after an ulcer developed, an operation was performed upon his eye. Plaintiff lost the sight ... Nafziger Baking Co., 328 Mo. 423, 41 S.W. 559; Schupback v. Meshevsky (Mo.), 300 S.W. 465; Monroe v. C. & A. Ry. Co., 297 Mo. 633, 249 S.W. 644, 257 S.W. 469; Kibble v. Q., O. & K.C. Ry. Co., 285 ... ...
-
Bishop v. Musick Plating Works
... ... 695; Morgan v. Hinge Mfg. Co., 120 Mo. App. 590; Railroad v. Conarty, 238 U.S. 243; Lang v. Railroad, 255 U.S. 455; Ferguson v. Coal ... Co., 298 S.W. 827; Busse v. White, 302 Mo. 672; Monroe v. Railroad, 297 Mo. 633. (8) The damages are excessive ... ...
Request a trial to view additional results