THE FREDENSBRO
Decision Date | 23 April 1927 |
Docket Number | No. 63.,63. |
Citation | 18 F.2d 983 |
Parties | THE FREDENSBRO. |
Court | U.S. District Court — Western District of Pennsylvania |
Fraley & Paul, of Philadelphia, Pa., for libelant.
William J. Conlen, of Philadelphia, Pa., for respondents.
The Fredensbro is a vessel owned by A/S Det Oeversoiske Compagnie, a Danish corporation. John Kelly, Limited, a corporation of Great Britain and Ireland, the libelant, entered into a contract of charter party in writing dated September 24, 1926, wherein the respondent corporation agreed to load upon the steamship Fredensbro at the port of Philadelphia, and deliver at Belfast, Ireland, a cargo of coal, freight to be paid, at the rate of 25 shillings per ton of 20 hundred weight, "in cash in London on completion of loading, without discount, and not to be returnable if ship lost on passage."
The libel sets out the loading and shipment on October 27, 1926, upon the Fredensbro at Philadelphia of 3,972 tons of coal and the payment of freight in cash in London on completion of the loading in the sum of £4,965. It is averred that the Fredensbro on the same day was in collision with the steamship Manchester Shipper in the Delaware river, and as a result the Fredensbro sank, resulting in the loss of a part of the cargo of coal and severe damage to the balance of the cargo, resulting in a total loss of the value of the cargo, subject to salvage. The libelant claims a return of the freight moneys paid in the total sum of $24,162.17.
The Fredensbro, having been raised, was attached by process of foreign attachment. The master of the vessel, Jens Martin Olsen, specially appearing, without admitting the jurisdiction of the court, filed a claim as bailee of the vessel, and proctors for the claimant and the respondent entered a special appearance, for the sole purpose of questioning the jurisdiction of the court, and filed exceptions to the libel.
The first ground of exception is that, the plaintiff and respondent being corporations of Great Britain and of Denmark, respectively, and neither a resident nor citizen of the United States, and no facts being set forth showing that the parties cannot settle their difficulties in their own courts, this court should not take jurisdiction. The suit is brought upon a charter party, a maritime contract. The action is in personam and in rem. The Fredensbro is, or was at the time of the filing of the libel, and at the time of the attachment, within the jurisdiction of this court.
Unless the exceptants' contention that a libel in rem will not lie for recovery of freight money is sound, the ruling of Mr. Justice Story in The Jerusalem, 2 Gall. 191, Fed. Cas. No. 7,293, justifies the court in the exercise of its discretion in taking jurisdiction of the suit. In citing the above case in The Belgenländ, 114 U. S. 355, 366, 5 S. Ct. 860, 865 (29 L. Ed. 152) Mr. Justice Bradley said:
In addition to the presence of the vessel within the jurisdiction, there is the further circumstance that, as a result of the collision between the...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Andros Compania Maritima, SA v. Andre & Cie.
... ... v. Saguenay Terminals Limited, 293 F.2d 796 (9th Cir. 1961); see The Graig Shipping Co. v. Midland Overseas Shipping Corporation, 259 F.Supp. 929 (S.D. N.Y.1966); Irini Stefanou, 1966 A.M.C. 920 (S.D.C.D.Cal.1966); Danielsen v. Entre Rios Rys. Co., supra ; and The Fredensbro, 18 F.2d 983 (E.D.Pa.1927). And, to the extent that it questions the Court's power to order arbitration abroad under Section 8—a matter that is in any event academic in view of the presently pending arbitration noted earlier —Garnac is referred to Section 206, 5 9 U.S.C. § 206, which, the ... ...
-
Fox Film Corp. v. Buchanan
... ... (C. C. A.) 129 ... F. 849, 68 L. R. A. 968; (Rederiaktiebolaget) Atlanten Case ... (D. C.) 232 F. 403; United States Asphalt Co. v. Trinidad ... Lake Petroleum Co. (D. C.) 222 F. 1006; The Eros Case ... (C. C. A.) 251 F. 45. As to the arbitration clause, see The ... Fredensbro (D. C.) 18 F.2d 983; Danielsen v. Entre Rios ... Rys. Co. (D. C.) 22 F.2d 326 ... "The ... authoritative rule as to separable or divisible contracts is ... laid down by Lord Mansfield, in Boone v. Eyrne, 6 ... Term. R. 573, as follows: 'Where mutual covenants go to ... the whole of ... ...
-
Fox v. The Giuseppe Mazzini
... ... Darwins, Ltd. (1942) App.Cas. 356 ... The British Arbitration Act of 1889 (52 and 53 Vict., c. 49) provides: ... "(a) If no other mode of reference is provided, the reference shall be to a single arbitrator." ... See also The Fredensbro, D.C., 18 F.2d 983; Danielsen v. Entre Rios Rys. Co., Ltd., D.C., 22 F.2d 326; and International Refugee Organization v. Republic Steamship Corporation, D.C., 93 F.Supp. 798 ... It is also urged by the libellants that even though the law governing the validity and interpretation of ... ...