U.S. v. One 1995 Turbo Commander Aircraft Model 114TC, 3:99-CV-2590 (EBB) (D. Conn. 10/31/2000)

• Decision Date: 31 October 2000
• Docket Number: 3:99-CV-2590 (EBB).,3:99-CV-2589 (EBB).
• Parties: U.S., Plaintiff, v. ONE 1995 TURBO COMMANDER AIRCRAFT MODEL 114TC, SERIAL NO. 20002, ETC, ET AL., Defendants. U.S., Plaintiff, v. $11,014,165.20 IN U.S. CURRENCY CONVERTED FROM GOLD COINS, ETC., ET AL., Defendants.
• Court: U.S. District Court — District of Connecticut

Page 1

U.S., Plaintiff, v. ONE 1995 TURBO COMMANDER AIRCRAFT MODEL 114TC, SERIAL NO. 20002, ETC, ET AL., Defendants. U.S., Plaintiff, v. $11,014,165.20 IN U.S. CURRENCY CONVERTED FROM GOLD COINS, ETC., ET AL., Defendants.

3:99-CV-2590 (EBB).

3:99-CV-2589 (EBB).

United States District Court, D. Connecticut.

October 31, 2000.

RULING ON MOTIONS TO INTERVENE

ELLEN BREE BURNS, Senior District Judge.

INTRODUCTION

Peoples Benefit Life Insurance Company ("Peoples") and Veterans Life Insurance Company ("Veterans") have moved this Court to grant them the right to intervene, pursuant to Rule 24 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, as parties with a direct interest in the outcome of the above-referenced litigations, which arise out of the looting of insurance companies by Martin Frankel. The Receivers of the estates have filed timely objection thereto.

STATEMENT OF FACTS

The Court sets forth only those facts deemed necessary to an understanding of the issues raised in, and decision rendered on, these Motions.

In approximately 1993, Martin Frankel established one Thunor Trust in Franklin, Tennessee. The Thunor Trust was established to acquire ownership of insurance companies, including First National Life Insurance Company ("FNLIC") and Franklin American Life Insurance Company ("FALIC").

In June, 1998, a broker of blocks of insurance business put Peoples and Veterans in touch with FALIC to explore the possibility of FALIC reinsuring certain blocks of insurance business that were originally underwritten by Peoples and Veterans.

Peoples and Veterans rejected the proposal due to the fact that FALIC's financial rating was not high enough to assure regulatory approval of the proposed transaction. As an alternative, FALIC officials offered a substitute deal with FNLIC, FALIC's highest rated affiliate under the folds of the Thunor Trust. Based on a series of representations regarding the financial condition of FNLIC and its statutory financial statements, Peoples and Veterans entered into a set of agreements with FNLIC.

The Agreements entered into included a Master Agreement, a Reinsurance Agreement and an Assumption Agreement. The Agreements were to transfer the initial blocks of insurance business from Peoples and Veterans to FNLIC, as well as the corresponding $14,689,593.00 Reserve Fund which accompanied those blocks of insurance business.

The Agreements provided that they would not and could not become effective until the Mississippi Commissioner of Insurance approved the Assumption Agreement. The documents also provided that FNLIC would immediately return any portion of the insurance business — and the concomitant portion of the Reserve Fund — that was not approved for transfer by the appropriate regulatory authorities.

The Agreements failed because certain conditions set forth in the Agreements did not occur. However, rather than returning the business and the Reserve Fund, Peoples and Veterans assert that Frankel absconded with the Reserve Fund. As a consequence, Peoples and Veterans lost the Reserve Fund but remained liable for all claims and expenses for the corresponding insurance business.

LEGAL ANALYSIS

Intervention as a matter of right under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 24(a)(2) is permitted when the party proposing to intervene meets the following requirements: (1) the motion to intervene must be timely filed; (2) the party must demonstrate an interest in the property or transaction which is the subject of the underlying action; (3) the party must show that a prejudice to that interest will result if intervention is not permitted; and (4) the applicant's interest...