United Wire, Metal and Mach. Health and Welfare Fund v. Morristown Memorial Hosp.
| Decision Date | 14 May 1993 |
| Docket Number | 92-5320,92-5341,92-5343,AFL-CIO,LABOR-MANAGEMENT,92-5352,92-5354,NYSA-ILA,Nos. 92-5317,No. 25,No. 475,92-5345,92-5319,25,475,s. 92-5317 |
| Parties | , 61 USLW 2723, 16 Employee Benefits Cas. 2182, Medicare & Medicaid Guide P 41,415 UNITED WIRE, METAL AND MACHINE HEALTH AND WELFARE FUND; Jack Stoll; Esther Borja; Javier Restrepo; United Food and Commercial Workers International Union Local 464A,Group Reimbursement Welfare Plan; Frank Lacatena; Dolores Lacatena; New Jersey Carpenters Welfare Fund; Local # 807 Labor-Management Health Fund; Trustees of the Local # 807 Labor-Management Health Fund; Prosper Alexander; Marie Alexander; District Council of Ironworkers of Northern New Jersey Welfare Fund; Archie G. Ferguson; Ronald W. Jensen; John J. Irvine; Walter Phillips; Michael J. McDermott; Samuel Pacich; Albert J. Irwin; Nicholas J. Andretta, Sr.; Gary Ugaro; Walter F. Steinmetz; John D. Mulvany; Michael W. Featherson; Francis E. Arny; John J. Clark, Sr.; Ronald W. Williams; Daniel J. Perez; Keith E. Zdep; Edward Weidler; Louis Rocco; Raymond J. Rodgers; Francis J. Akesson; Donald J. Banta, Sr.; Charles W. Bird; David F. Brown; Clifford Crooks; Robert T. Cusick; James P. Fitzgerald; Joseph A. Fusaro; Charles Gamba; Richard Gougeon; John Keating; Gerard McCloud; Robert McGee; Alexander McLellan; John Murphy; Laurence O'Brien; Peter O'Conner; Raul Rodriguez; Robert Schweitzer; Robert Sickles; Andrew L. Smith; Richard Sparks; George Sudak; Edward Tedesco; James Toal; Enoch P. McMahan; Local Union 400, IBEW Welfare Fund; Brian Hruska; William Marsh; Charles Work; Harold Rutledge; Ralph Allen; Thomas Vadas; Vincent Worth; Timothy Hill; Ronald Ramsey; John Ireland; James Martin; Michael Almasi; Beverly A. Ruby; Peter Namotka; Daniel Kennedy; George Cole; Walter Davies; Robert Hermann; Frank Hermann; Charles Keller; Dennis Johnson; Connie J. Koehler; Frank O'Day; Vincent La Stella; Donald McNeil; Jean-Louis Pouliot; Nicholas Aemisego; Robert Stahnke; Philip Cerza; Gary Giorgio; Edward Osowski; Glenn Halvorsen; William Stadelman; Daniel Julio, Jr.; Francis Alexander; Leonard Dahl; Michael Devine; Joseph George; Ralph Jens |
| Court | U.S. Court of Appeals — Third Circuit |
Division; Riverview Medical Center
Southern Ocean County Hospital; St. Mary's Hospital; The
General Hospital Center at Passaic; Wallkill Valley
Hospital and Health Centers; St. Mary's Hospital (Passaic)
United Hospital; Pascack Valley Hospital; West Hudson
Hospital; Johnson University Hospital; Administrator of
the New Jersey Health Care Trust Fund; New Jersey
Department of Human Services Division of Medical Assistance
and Health Services
New Jersey Hospital; New Jersey Hospital Association
Intervenors-Defendants
UNITED WIRE, METAL AND MACHINE HEALTH AND WELFARE FUND; Esther Borja
v.
ST. MARY'S HOSPITAL; New Jersey Commissioner of Health;
New Jersey State Department of Health; New Jersey
Hospital Rate Setting Commission;
Frances J. Dunston;
UNITED WIRE, METAL AND MACHINE HEALTH AND WELFARE FUND;
Javier Restrepo
v.
ST. JOSEPH'S HOSPITAL AND MEDICAL CENTER; Frances J.
Dunston, in her capacity as New Jersey Commissioner of
Health; New Jersey State Department of Health; New Jersey
Hospital Rate Setting Commission.
UNITED FOOD AND COMMERCIAL WORKERS INTERNATIONAL UNION,
LOCAL 464A, AFL-CIO GROUP REIMBURSEMENT WELFARE
PLAN; Frank Lacatena; Dolores Lacatena
v.
WAYNE GENERAL HOSPITAL; Frances J. Dunston; New Jersey
Commissioner of Health; New Jersey State
Department of Health; New Jersey
Hospital Rate Setting Commission.
DISTRICT COUNCIL OF IRONWORKERS OF NORTHERN NEW JERSEY
WELFARE FUND; Archie G. Ferguson; Ronald W. Jensen; John
J. Irvine; Walter Phillips; Michael J. McDermott; Samuel
Pacich; Albert J. Irwin; Nicholas J. Andretta, Sr.; Gary
Ugaro; Walter F. Steinmetz; John D. Mulvaney; Michael W.
Featherson; Francis E. Arny; John J. Clark, Sr.; Ronald
W. Williams; Daniel J. Perez; Keith E. Zdep; Edward
Weidler; Louis Rocco; Raymond J. Rodgers; Francis J.
Akesson; Donald J. Banta, Sr.; Charles W. Bird; David
Brown; Clifford Crooks; Robert T. Cusick; James P.
Fitzgerald; Joseph A. Fusaro; Charles Gamba; Richard
Gougeon; John Keating; Gerard McCloud; Robert McGee;
Alexander McLellan; John Murphy; Laurence O'Brien; Peter
O'Conner; Raul Rodriguez; Robert Schweitzer; Robert
Sickles; Andrew L. Smith; Richard Sparks; George Sudak;
Edward Tedesco; James Toal; Enoch P. McMahan
v.
Frances J. DUNSTON, in her capacity as New Jersey
Commissioner of Health; New Jersey State Department of
Health; New Jersey Hospital Rate Setting Commission;
Deborah Heart and Lung Center; Hunterdon Medical Center;
St. Francis Hospital; Hospital Center at Orange; St.
Peter's Medical Center; St. Clare's/Riverside Medical
Center; John F. Kennedy Medical Center; Dover General...
To continue reading
Request your trial
71 cases
-
Romney v. Lin
... ... No. 1602, Docket 95-9275 ... United States Court of Appeals, ... Second Circuit ... to recover contributions owed to an ERISA fund." Id. at 166. In so deciding, the district ... ) (statute that specified "the existing health coverage of the employee" referred to ERISA plans ... and, as such, are not pre-empted."); United Wire, Metal and Machine Health & Welfare Fund v. stown Memorial Hosp., 995 F.2d 1179, 1192 n. 6 (3d Cir.) ... ...
-
Thiokol Corp. v. Roberts
... ... No. 4:90-CV-12 ... United States District Court, W.D. Michigan, Southern ... beneficiaries, including payments under health and welfare noninsured benefit plans and payments ... force no state law could resist." United Wire and Machine Health and Welfare Fund v. Morristown Memorial Hosp., 995 F.2d 1179, 1197 (3rd Cir.1993) ... ...
-
Thomas v. Aetna, Inc., Civil Action No. 98-2552 (D. N.J. 6/8/1999)
... ... Civil Action No. 98-2552 ... United States District Court, D. New Jersey ... June ... Indiana Hosp. , 843 F.2d 139, 143 (3d Cir. 1988). All facts ... The plaintiff was enrolled in the Group Health Care Plan (the "Plan") provided by USH as of May ... and AUSHC; (4) defrauded her "through the wire services by taking her premium payments while ... and exclusively regulate employee welfare benefit plans. See Pilot Life Ins. Co. v ... any plan, fund, or program which was heretofore or is hereafter ... 1995) (quoting United Wire v. Morristown Mem'l Hosp. , 995 F.2d 1179, 1192 (3d Cir ... ...
-
Travelers Ins. Co. v. Cuomo
... ... Health Insurance Association of America, American ... United States Court of Appeals, ... Second Circuit ... and Commercial Workers Local 174 Health Care Fund, Trustees of and United Food and Commercial rs Local 174 Retail Welfare Fund, and Trustees of and United Food and ... St. Mary's Hosp., Inc., 947 F.2d 1341, 1348 (8th Cir.1991) ("Like ... that our holding conflicts with United Wire, Metal & Machine Health & Welfare Fund v. own Memorial Hosp., 995 F.2d 1179 (3rd Cir.), cert. denied, ... ...
Request a trial to view additional results
1 books & journal articles
-
New York State Conference of Blue Cross & Blue Shield Plans v. Travelers Insurance Company: the United States Supreme Court Gives Commercial Insurers a Severe Case of "the Blues" - Mark A. Williams
...Id. Additionally, the court found that "the entire justification for the [slurcharges [was] premised on that exact result." Id. 14. 995 F.2d 1179 (3d Cir. 1993), cert, denied, 510 U.S. 944 (1993). 15. 995 F.2d at 1179. The Second Circuit reasoned that ERISA preempted any state law that "pur......