Veal v. Phillips
Decision Date | 28 May 1970 |
Docket Number | 5 Div. 898 |
Parties | Quinton VEAL v. Edwin F. PHILLIPS, d/b/a Phillips Oil Company and Shell Oil Company. |
Court | Alabama Supreme Court |
Walker, Hill & Gullage, and Phillip E. Adams, Jr., Opelika, for appellant.
Miller & Hoffmann, Montgomery, for Edwin F. Phillips, d/b/a Phillips oil co.
Samford, Torbert, Denson & Horsley, Spelika, for Shell Oil Co.
This appeal is from a judgment of the Circuit Court of Lee County, at law, granting a nonsuit to the appellant because of the adverse rulings of the court in sustaining the demurrers of both defendants to the appellant's complaint as last amended.
This was a suit brought by appellant, Quinton Veal, plaintiff below, to recover damages for personal injuries incurred by him while he was working for the appellees as an independent contractor on property owned and controlled by the appellees, defendants below.
Appellants assign several errors on appeal but argue only the action of the trial court in sustaining demurrers filed by both defendants to Count 3 of the amended complaint.
The decision must turn on the pleading question presented. Therefore, we set out here the allegations of Count 3 of the amended complaint:
(Emphasis added) (Parenthesis added)
We will not set out the specific grounds of demurrer, but each defendant raised by demurrer (1) that the complaint failed to show that defendants owed any duty to the plaintiff; (2) that defendants breached this duty; (3) that the...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Shaneyfelt v. REC I/Blue Springs Ltd. P'ship
...706 (Ala. 2001) (quoting Glenn v. United States Steel Corp., 423 So. 2d 152, 154 (Ala. 1982), quoting in turn Veal v. Phillips, 285 Ala. 655, 657-58, 235 So. 2d 799, 802 (1970)). Moreover, "'[t]here is no duty to warn' ... an independent contractor 'who has equal or superior knowledge of a ......
-
Wallace v. The Hous. Auth. of the City of Talladega
... ... injury. Crawford Johnson &Co. v. Duffner , 279 ... Ala. 678, 189 So.2d 474 (1966).'" ... 423 So.2d at 154 (quoting Veal v. Phillips , 285 Ala ... 655, 657-58, 235 So.2d 799 (1970)). In his dissent in ... Glenn, Justice Jones acknowledged that the general ... ...
-
Hand v. Butts
...dangers. Crawford Johnson & Co. v. Duffner, supra. On the other hand, counsel for appellee relies somewhat heavily upon Veal v. Phillips, 285 Ala. 655, 235 So.2d 799, in support of his argument that the complaint in the present case is defective in failing to allege any breach of duty on th......
-
McGregory v. LLOYD WOOD CONST. CO.
...to warn the [sub]contractor and if he does not do this, of course, he is liable for resultant injury." Veal v. Phillips, 285 Ala. 655, 657-58, 235 So.2d 799, 802 (1970). "`The duty to keep an area safe for invitees is limited to hidden defects which are not known to the invitee and would no......