Wayne Tp. v. Lutheran Hospital
Decision Date | 18 June 1974 |
Docket Number | No. 3--673A77,3--673A77 |
Citation | 312 N.E.2d 120,160 Ind.App. 427 |
Parties | WAYNE TOWNSHIP and William J. Cooper, Wayne Township Trustee, Appellants, v. LUTHERAN HOSPITAL, Appellee. |
Court | Indiana Appellate Court |
Kenneth M. Waterman, of Parker, Hoover & Roush, Ft. Wayne, for appellants.
Frank A. Webster, Ft. Wayne, for appellee.
Clara J. Kapp had taken an overdose of heroin. Her condition demanded immediate medical services. She was admitted to the Lutheran Hospital for treatment. Later, Lutheran Hospital filed a complaint against Wayne Township, William J. Cooper, Wayne Township Trustee, and Clara J. Kapp for payment of the medical services which had been rendered during the emergency. The facts were stipulated and adopted by the trial court as its finding of facts. Judgment was rendered for the Lutheran Hospital in the sum of $757.87 plus $70.00 in costs. The sole question presented by this appeal for our consideration is:
Is an Indiana township, rather than the state or county, liable for the reasonable value of emergency hospital services rendered by a private hospital to a resident, indigent drug addict?
Our opinion concludes that there is no statutory conflict in the present case and that other statutory provisions are supplementary. We affirm the trial court's judgment.
On May 4, 1971, Clara J. Kapp was admitted to Lutheran Hospital suffering from an overdose of heroin. She remained at the hospital undergoing treatment for the overdose and for her addition to heroin until May 22, 1971. During this time she received hospital services having a reasonable value of $757.87. The facts stipulated by the parties on November 29, 1972 and adopted by the trial court as its findings of fact on January 16, 1973 are as follows:
'1. That the defendant, Clara J. Kapp, was, at all relevant times herein, a poor person.
'2. That, at all relevant times herein, she was a resident of Wayne Township of Allen County, Indiana.
'3. That plaintiff is a hospital providing hospital services within the Wayne Township of Allen County, Indiana.
'4. That defendant, Clara J. Kapp, received hospital services from the plaintiff which were necessary and incurred bills for such services, copies of which are attached hereto as Exhibits A--1, A--2, and A--3, and are admitted into evidence.
On January 16, 1973, the trial court entered judgment in favor of Lutheran Hospital against Wayne Township, William J. Cooper, Wayne Township Trustee, and Clara J. Kapp in the amount of $757.87 plus $70.00 costs. Wayne Township and William J. Cooper appeal from this judgment raising one issue for this Court's determination.
The sole issue presented on appeal for our consideration is:
Is an Indiana township, rather than the state or county, liable for the reasonable value of emergency hospital services rendered by a private hospital to a resident, indigent drug addict?
It is not disputed that Clara J. Kapp was an indigent deserving emergency medical care. Wayne Township and William J. Cooper, Wayne Township Trustee, admit in their brief that as overseer of the poor, 1 a township trustee has a mandatory duty to provide medical care for all the poor of his township who are not provided for in public institutions. 2 I.C.1971, 12--2--1--6 (Burns Code Ed.) provides in petitinent part:
'Duties of trustees--Service to be rendered.--The overseer of the poor in each See also Washington Township v. Parkview Memorial Hospital (1969), 144 Ind.App. 359, 366, 246 N.E.2d 391; Newcomer v. Jefferson Township (1914), 181 Ind. 1, 5, 103 N.E. 843.
township shall have the oversight and care of all poor persons in his township so long as they remain in a charge, and shall see that they are properly relieved and taken care of in the manner required by law. He shall, in cases of necessity, promptly provide medical and surgical attendance for all of the poor in his township who are not provided for in public institutions; and shall also see that such medicines and/or medical supplies and/or special diets and/or nursing as are prescribed by the physician or surgeon in attendance upon the poor are properly furnished. . . .'
However, Wayne Township and William J. Cooper contend that when emergency medical treatment is rendered a drug addict for treatment of that addition, it is the obligation of the state or county to provide such care under I.C.1971, 16--14--9--1 through I.C.1971, 16--14--9--31 (Burns Code Ed.) (hereinafter referred to as admission statutes). I.C.1971, 16--14--9--2 (Burns Code Ed.) provides:
'Types of admissions.--Any mentally ill person residing in the state of Indiana and having a legal settlement in any county therein, shall be entitled to receive medical care and treatment in the psychiatric hospital of the hospital district in which such mentally ill person resides, at such cost as may be prescribed by law, subject to the restrictions, provisions and limitations hereafter prescribed in this act (16--14--9--1--16--14--9--31), by complying with any of the following admission procedures:
(1) Voluntary application for admission; or
(2) Temporary commitment by a court of competent jurisdiction; or
(3) Regular commitment by a court of competent jurisdiction. . . .'
I.C.1971, 16--14--9--1(2) (Burns Code Ed.) provides:
'(2) The term 'psychiatric disorder' means any mental illness or disease and shall include, but not be limited to, any mental deficiency, epilepsy, alcoholism or addition to narcotic or dangerous drugs; . . .'
Finally, I.C.1971, 16--14--9--21 provides:
Wayne Township and William J. Cooper contend that the above statutes relieve them of liability for services rendered Clara J. Kapp on two grounds. First, the admission statutes are special statutes and therefore prevail over I.C.1971, 12-- 2--1--6, supra, a general statute. Secondly, it was the Legislature's intent in passing the admission Both arguments of Wayne Township and William J. Cooper regarding relief of the township trustee from liability for services rendered an indigent drug addict are predicated upon conflict between the admission statutes and I.C. 1971, 12--2--1--6, supra. For a specific statute to prevail over or modify a general statute, there must be a conflict in the two statute's application to the same subject matter. Grether v. Indiana State Board of Dental Examiners (1959), 239 Ind. 619, 159 N.E.2d 131; O'Donnell v. Krneta (1958), 238 Ind. 582, 593, 154 N.E.2d 45. For the admission statutes to preempt the treatment of drug addicts, including emergency treatment; this Court must find an implied modification of I.C.1971, 12--2--1--6, supra, as it relates to the care of indigent drug addicts.
statutes to preempt the whole subject of drug addiction and provide for such treatment on a state level rather than on a township level.
We do not find the admission statutes to conflict with I.C.1971, 12--2--1--6, supra, as it applies to this appeal, and we affirm the trial court's judgment in favor of Lutheran Hospital.
In construing the statutes here at issue, this Court is bound by several well settled rules of statutory construction. Where there are two statutes on the same subject, they should be construed together so as to harmonize and give effect to each. New York Central R. Co. v. Public Service Commission of Indiana (1958), 237 Ind. 544, 147 N.E.2d 547; Salem Community School Corp. v. Easterly (1971), Ind.App., 275 N.E.2d 317. There is a presumption that the Legislature in enacting...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
In re Whyte
...43, 54, 30 N.E.2d 713, 717 (1940); Schrenker v. Clifford, 270 Ind. 525, 527, 387 N.E.2d 59, 60 (1979); Wayne Twp. v. Lutheran Hospital, 160 Ind. App. 427, 432, 312 N.E.2d 120, 124 (1974); Sekerez v. Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co., 166 Ind.App. 563, 568, 337 N.E.2d 521, 524 In the absence of a ......
-
Economy Oil Corp. v. Indiana Dept. of State Revenue
...to interpret ambiguous statutes in order to ascertain and effectuate the general intent of the legislature. Wayne Township v. Lutheran Hospital (1974), Ind.App., 312 N.E.2d 120; Kirby v. Indiana Employment Security Board (1973), Ind.App., 304 N.E.2d 225; Morgan City R.E.M.C., supra; Thompso......
-
U.S. Steel Corp. v. Northern Indiana Public Service Co., Inc.
...While we may take such notice, cf. Roeschlein v. Thomas (1972), 258 Ind. 16, 280 N.E.2d 581, 584; Wayne Township v. Lutheran Hospital (1974), 160 Ind.App. 427, 312 N.E.2d 120, n. 2; Merriman v. Standard Grocery Co. (1968), 143 Ind.App. 654, 242 N.E.2d 128, 130, the existence of a separate c......
-
State v. Davies, 2-377A79
...effect to each. Economy Oil Corp. v. Indiana Department of State Revenue (1974), Ind.App., 321 N.E.2d 215; Wayne Township v. Lutheran Hospital (1974), 160 Ind.App. 427, 312 N.E.2d 120. In enacting the amendment to Ind. Code 6-4-1-37 in the Indiana Inheritance and Estate Tax Act it is presum......