Weatherford v. AMERICAN NAT. CAN CO.
| Court | North Carolina Court of Appeals |
| Writing for the Court | BRYANT. |
| Citation | Weatherford v. AMERICAN NAT. CAN CO., 607 S.E.2d 348, 168 NC App. 377 (N.C. App. 2005) |
| Decision Date | 01 February 2005 |
| Docket Number | No. COA03-1374.,COA03-1374. |
| Parties | David N. WEATHERFORD, Employee, Plaintiff, v. AMERICAN NATIONAL CAN CO., Employer, Gallagher Bassett Services, Carrier, Defendants. |
Robinson & Lawing, L.L.P., by Jolinda J. Babcock, Winston-Salem, for plaintiff-appellee.
Teague, Campbell, Dennis & Gorham, L.L.P., by George H. Pender and Tara D. Muller, Raleigh, for defendant-appellants. BRYANT, Judge.
American National Can Company, Inc.1 (employer-defendant) and Gallagher Bassett Services (carrier-defendant), collectively defendants, appeal from an opinion and award of the North Carolina Industrial Commission (Commission) dated 6 August 2003 awarding David N. Weatherford (plaintiff) ongoing total disability compensation after 1 July 2000 as a result of his work related knee injuries.
Plaintiff, age 64 (born 1940), began working for defendant in 1976. For the final fifteen years of his employment, plaintiff worked as a back-end maintainer of the decorator machine which prints out labels directly onto soda and beer cans. He worked twelve-hour shifts, four days per week, occasionally working overtime. His job consisted of standing, walking, climbing steps and kneeling on cement and metal surfaces.
In 1998, plaintiff began experiencing knee problems. On 17 August 1998, plaintiff met with Dr. King who diagnosed plaintiff with chondromalacia, patella femoral joint and internal derangement with mild synovitis in his left knee. Dr. King authorized plaintiff to be out of work from 15 September 1998 through 8 November 1998 in order to perform arthroscopic surgery on plaintiff's left knee.
After having surgery on his left knee, plaintiff resumed his same job duties as a maintainer for defendant. On 17 June 1999, plaintiff returned to see Dr. King for problems that had developed with his right knee. Dr. King diagnosed internal derangement with chondromalacia patella of plaintiff's right knee and performed arthroscopic surgery on 13 July 1999. Plaintiff returned to work on 27 September 1999.
On 20 March 2000, plaintiff once again consulted with Dr. King, complaining of pain and swelling in his right knee. Dr. King prescribed Novacain, physical therapy and authorized plaintiff to be out of work until 1 July 2000. Because plaintiff continued to experience knee pain even after he had been authorized to return to work, he retired 2 July 2000.
Plaintiff received short-term group disability payments for the periods of medical leave that Dr. King had authorized. Plaintiff was paid a gross weekly amount of $313.00 in addition to the following payments: a) $2,369.84 for 9 September 1998 through 7 November 1998; b) $4,247.86 for 20 June 1999 through 3 October 1999; and c) $4,292.57 for 20 March 2000 to 1 July 2000.
On 13 September 2000, plaintiff filed two separate occupational disease claims, one for each knee. Defendants filed an Industrial Commission (I.C.) Form 61 on 15 November 2000, denying plaintiff's claims. In April 2002, Dr. King testified in his deposition plaintiff was not physically capable of returning to his former job with defendant due to his knee conditions.
After reviewing Dr. King's deposition and hearing testimony from plaintiff, two of plaintiff's co-workers, and plaintiff's wife, the parties stipulated to plaintiff's disability and the compensability of plaintiff's claim. They further stipulated plaintiff was disabled from 9 September 1998 to 7 November 1998; from 17 June 1999 to 2 October 1999; and from 20 March 2000 to 1 July 2000. However, no I.C. Form 21 was ever filed. Nonetheless, pursuant to the stipulation, defendants agreed to pay plaintiff for periods of work missed due to his occupational diseases, subject to a credit for all disability paid by the defendant's group insurance plan. The parties also stipulated to plaintiff's compensation rate: $532.00 for the left knee, and $560.00 for the right knee.
At the hearing before the Deputy Commissioner, the sole issue was whether the plaintiff was entitled to benefits after 1 July 2000; and, if so, the amount and type of benefits. After hearing live testimony, reviewing deposition testimony, exhibits and other submissions of the parties, the Deputy Commissioner issued an opinion and award on 15 October 2002. The Deputy Commissioner concluded that plaintiff sustained a compensable occupational disease as a result of work related injury to his knees and was therefore entitled to ongoing disability benefits. Defendants were ordered to pay past medical compensation as well as ongoing temporary total disability benefits and future medical treatment for plaintiff's knee condition.
Defendants appealed to the Full Commission. In an opinion and award dated 1 August 2003, the Commission found plaintiff to be totally disabled, affirmed the opinion and award of the Deputy Commissioner, with modifications, and ordered defendants "to pay total disability benefits from 9 September 1998 to 7 November 1998; from 17 June 1999 to 2 October 1999; and from 20 March 2000 continuing through the present date until further order of the Commission." In addition, defendants were ordered to pay all medical expenses related to plaintiff's work related injury. Defendants appeal from the Commission's order dated 1 August 2003.
At the outset, defendant argues, and we agree, that plaintiff had no continuing presumption of disability after 1 July 2000. Johnson v. Southern Tire Sales and Serv., 358 N.C. 701, 706, 599 S.E.2d 508, 512 (2004) (). We now review the dispositive issue raised on appeal: whether the Commission erred in finding and concluding that plaintiff's knee pain makes him incapable of any employment after 1 July 2000.
It is well-settled that review of an Industrial Commission decision by this Court is limited to the determination of whether there is competent evidence to support the Commission's Findings of Fact and whether those findings support the Conclusions of Law. Cox v. City of Winston-Salem, 157 N.C.App. 228, 232, 578 S.E.2d 669, 673 (2003); Pernell v. Piedmont Circuits, 104 N.C.App. 289, 292, 409 S.E.2d 618, 619 (1991) (citation omitted). The Commission's findings of fact are conclusive on appeal even where there is contrary evidence, and such findings may only be set aside where there is a "complete lack of competent evidence to support them." Johnson v. Herbie's Place, 157 N.C.App. 168, 171, 579 S.E.2d 110, 113 (2003) (citation omitted); see also Adams v. AVX Corp., 349 N.C. 676, 681, 509 S.E.2d 411, 414 (1998). It is the Commission's duty to judge the credibility of the witnesses and to determine the weight given to testimony. Bailey v. Sears Roebuck & Co., 131 N.C.App. 649, 653, 508 S.E.2d 831, 834 (1998).
Disability under the Workers' Compensation Act is defined as "incapacity because of injury to earn the wages which the employee was receiving at the time of injury in the same or any other employment." N.C. Gen.Stat. § 97-2(9) (2003). The burden is on the employee to show that he is unable to earn pre-injury wages, either in the same employment or in other employment. Hilliard v. Apex Cabinet Co., 305 N.C. 593, 595, 290 S.E.2d 682, 684 (1982). Plaintiff may show his incapacity to earn pre-injury wages in one of four ways:
(1) the production of medical evidence that he is physically or mentally, as a consequence of the work related injury, incapable of working in any employment; (2) the production of evidence that he is capable of some work, but that he has, after reasonable effort on his part, been unsuccessful in his effort to obtain employment; (3) the production of evidence that he is capable of some work but that it would be futile because of preexisting conditions, i.e. age, inexperience, lack of education, to seek other employment; or (4) the production of evidence that he has obtained other employment at a wage less than he earned prior to the injury.
Russell v. Lowes, 108 N.C.App. 762, 765, 425 S.E.2d 454, 457 (1993) (emphasis added). Medical evidence that the plaintiff suffers from pain as a result of physical injury, combined with the plaintiff's own testimony that he is in pain has been held to be sufficient to support a conclusion of total disability. Webb v. Power Circuit, Inc., 141 N.C.App. 507, 512-13, 540 S.E.2d 790, 793-94 (2000) (); Barber v....
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
Griffin v. Absolute Fire Control, Inc.
...futile given plaintiff's limited education, limited experience, limited training, and poor health); Weatherford v. Am. Nat'l Can Co. , 168 N.C. App. 377, 383, 607 S.E.2d 348, 352-353 (2005) (upholding Commission's conclusion that plaintiff was disabled under prong three based on plaintiff's......
-
Smith v. Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co., No. COA04-839 (NC 6/7/2005), COA04-839
...that he is in pain has been held to be sufficient to support a conclusion of total disability." Weatherford v. Am. Nat'l Can Co., ___ N.C. App. ___, ___, 607 S.E.2d 348, 351 (2005) (citation omitted); Webb v. Power Circuit, Inc., 141 N.C. App. 507, 512, 540 S.E.2d 790, 793 (2000); Barber v.......
-
Latter v. La Petite Academy, No. COA07-652 (N.C. App. 9/2/2008)
...regarding his or her pain was sufficient to support a finding of disability by the Commission: Weatherford v. Am. Nat'l Can Co., 168 N.C. App. 377, 381, 607 S.E.2d 348, 351 (2005), and Webb v. Power Circuit, Inc., 141 N.C. App. 507, 512-13, 540 S.E.2d 790, 793-94 (2000), cert. denied, 353 N......
- Drewry v. NORTH CAROLINA DEPT. OF TRANSP.