Webb Oil Co., Inc. v. Holmes

• Decision Date: 18 November 1994
• Citation: 651 So.2d 36
• Parties: WEBB OIL COMPANY, INC., and Federated Insurance Company v. Peggy HOLMES. AV93000421.
• Court: Alabama Court of Civil Appeals

Page 36

651 So.2d 36

WEBB OIL COMPANY, INC., and Federated Insurance Company v. Peggy HOLMES.

AV93000421.

Court of Civil Appeals of Alabama.

Nov. 18, 1994.

Russell Q. Allison and Rhonda Pitts Chambers of Rives & Peterson, Birmingham, for appellants.

William M. Bouldin of Guin, Bouldin & Alexander, Russellville, for appellee.

THIGPEN, Judge.

This is a workmen's compensation case.

In July 1993, Peggy Holmes filed a complaint against Webb Oil Company, Inc., and Federated Insurance Company (Webb Oil), for workmen's compensation benefits. ¹ Following ore tenus proceedings, the trial court found that Holmes suffered a 75% permanent partial disability, and it awarded Holmes unpaid and future medical expenses and benefits. Webb Oil's post-judgment motion was denied; hence, this appeal.

Webb Oil raises several issues on appeal; however, we find the dispositive issue to be whether the trial court erred in awarding benefits without finding that Holmes suffered a loss of ability to earn.

Although the trial court's order included findings and conclusions of law, it did not find any loss of Holmes's ability to earn. Absent that finding, no grounds exist for awarding compensation. Marley Erectors, Inc. v. Rice, 560 So.2d 1083 (Ala.Civ.App.1990). Physical disability does not necessarily coincide with the loss of ability to earn. Wheeler v. Lake Forest Property Owners' Association, Inc., 523 So.2d 1083 (Ala.Civ.App.1988). Although no specific wording is required, there is nothing in this trial court's order connecting Holmes's disability with her earning capacity. Absent a finding that Holmes's earning capacity was diminished by the disability, there is simply no basis for an award. Hooper v. Denney, 619 So.2d 1388 (Ala.Civ.Ap...