Webb v. County of Lincoln, No. 58164

• Court: United States State Supreme Court of Mississippi
• Writing for the Court: DAN M. LEE; ROY NOBLE LEE; GRIFFIN
• Citation: 536 So.2d 1356
• Parties: Robin Ann WEBB and Christopher Robert Webb v. The COUNTY OF LINCOLN, Mississippi; Clifton Givens, Isaiah Ard, Ramsey Smith and F.H. Britt, Jr., each Individually and in his Official Capacity as a Member of the Board of Supervisors of Lincoln County; Mississippi State Highway Commission; John R. Tabb, Director of the Mississippi State Highway Department in his Official Capacity as Director of the Mississippi State Highway Department.
• Decision Date: 21 December 1988
• Docket Number: No. 58164

Page 1356

536 So.2d 1356 Robin Ann WEBB and Christopher Robert Webb
v.
The COUNTY OF LINCOLN, Mississippi; Clifton Givens, Isaiah
Ard, Ramsey Smith and F.H. Britt, Jr., each Individually and
in his Official Capacity as a Member of the Board of
Supervisors of Lincoln County; Mississippi State Highway
Commission; John R. Tabb, Director of the Mississippi State
Highway Department in his Official Capacity as Director of
the Mississippi State Highway Department. No. 58164. Supreme Court of Mississippi. Dec. 21, 1988.

T. Mack Brabham, McComb, for appellants.

Page 1357

Donald B. Patterson, Brookhaven, Edwin Lloyd Pittman and Mike Moore, Attys. Gen. by P.O. Gibson, Asst. Atty. Gen., and Thomas S. Coleman, Jackson, for appellees.

En Banc.

DAN M. LEE, Presiding Justice, for the Court:

Robin Ann and Christopher Robert Webb, filed suit on September 13, 1986, in the Circuit Court of Lincoln County, Mississippi, for damages growing out of a one-vehicle accident on July 8, 1986. Interrogatories and requests for production were attached to the complaint. Among the numerous defendants below, now appellees, were the Mississippi State Highway Commission, a body incorporated under the laws of the State of Mississippi; John R. Tabb, director of the Mississippi State Highway Department, in his official capacity as the director of the Mississippi State Highway Department; and Lincoln County and its five supervisors in their individual and official capacities.

All appellees filed an answer. Additionally, the appellees presented to the court a motion pursuant to Rule 12(b)(6) of the Miss.R.Civ.Proc. to dismiss the complaint. On January 30, 1987, the court granted the motion to dismiss all parties pursuant to the case of State v. Lewis, 498 So.2d 321 (Miss.1986). Feeling aggrieved by the holding of the lower court, the Webbs appeal and assign two assignments of error. Ultimately finding no error, we affirm.

STATEMENT OF FACTS

Christopher Robert Webb, his wife, Robin Ann Webb, and their one- (1-) year-old son, Robert Anthony Webb, were travelling in Lincoln County, Mississippi, at approximately 9:45 p. m. on July 8, 1986. The weather conditions that night were foggy and rainy. The Webbs were travelling down a road known as "Robert Adams Road." Unbeknownst to Mr. Webb, and without any warning, the road suddenly came to a dead end where Robert Adams Road made a "T" intersection with Old Hog Chain Road. Mr. Webb, unable to stop his automobile, proceeded through the intersection and struck a tree. The accident inflicted serious injuries on Robin Ann Webb, who sustained a broken nose, broken maxilla (upper jaw), broken shoulder, broken ankle and the breaking of most all other facial bones between the level of Mrs. Webb's eye and mandible.

In their complaint, the Webbs specifically allege that the intersection had previously been marked by a stop sign. On the day in question, the stop sign no longer existed at that particular intersection; therefore, the Webbs charged that the appellees failed to properly supervise or maintain the intersection in a reasonably safe manner. The plaintiffs further alleged two additional acts of negligence, (1) a failure to warn members of the motoring public of the condition that existed at the intersection, and (2) the failure to properly maintain the intersection according to the uniform traffic control device manual.

Through answers to interrogatories and affidavit attached to their motion, appellees, Mississippi State Highway Commission and John R. Tabb, in his official capacity of director of the Highway Department, denied any obligation to maintain the intersection at which the accident occurred.

Similarly, appellees, Lincoln County and its supervisors, answered the complaint and asserted in their "Second Defense" that appellants action was barred by sovereign immunity. Additionally, in their "First Defense," Lincoln County and its supervisors moved for a 12(b)(6) dismissal for failure to set a claim upon which relief can be granted, or in the alternative for a judgment on the pleadings.

The circuit court, after considering briefs filed by appellants and appellees, held "this case is governed by the decision in State of Mississippi for the Use and Benefit of Nelda M. Brazeale and Nelda M. Brazeale, Individually, v. Richard A. Lewis, Individually, and United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co., 498 So.2d 321 (Miss.1986)." The Court sustained the 12(b)(6) motion and dismissed the complaint.

DISCUSSION

The essential issue of this appeal is whether the doctrine of sovereign immunity

Page 1358

forestalls the Webbs' recovery in this cause. The Webbs, reviewing this Court's opinion in State v. Lewis, supra, point out that...