Wiest v. School District No. 24, Marion County

• Citation: 68 Or. 474,137 P. 749
• Parties: WIEST v. SCHOOL DISTRICT NO. 24, MARION COUNTY.
• Decision Date: 06 January 1914
• Court: Supreme Court of Oregon

137 P. 749

68 Or. 474

WIEST v. SCHOOL DISTRICT NO. 24, MARION COUNTY.

Supreme Court of Oregon

January 6, 1914

Department 1.

Appeal from Circuit Court, Marion County; Percy R. Kelly, Judge.

Action by W. A. Wiest against School District No. 24, Marion County. From a judgment for defendant, plaintiff appeals. Affirmed.

This is an action for libel. The complaint, after alleging the corporate character of defendant and the fact that plaintiff was a duly employed teacher in one of its public schools continues as follows: "That in or about the beginning of the month of December, 1912, one Laura De Bord made certain false and malicious charges and accusations against the plaintiff in his capacity as a teacher, and on the 13th day of January, 1913, the board of directors of said school district No. 24 held a meeting for the pretended purpose of investigating the said charges and accusations made against the plaintiff, and an investigation thereof was held on the said date, and the defendant caused to be entered upon its records and journals certain minutes of and concerning the business transacted at said meeting and said investigation as follows: 'Record of Clerk, page 236. School Board Meeting, Salem, Oregon, Jan. 13, 1913. The following witnesses were examined and cross-examined: Laura De Bord Mrs. Pickering, Mrs. De Bord, Miss Pohle, Mr. Howe (janitor) Mr. Jenks, Mr. Trindle. Following examination of above witnesses, Mr. Corby, on behalf of W. A. Wiest, addressed the board. Upon motion board went into executive session. After due consideration the board found that W. A. Wiest had been guilty of immoral conduct and behavior unbecoming a teacher with one Laura De Bord, and that the charges preferred against him had been sustained. After due consideration the board found that the charges had been sufficiently substantiated to warrant the dismissal of W. A. Wiest. It was moved and duly seconded that W. A. Wiest be dismissed as teacher in the public schools of district No. 24, Marion county, Oregon, for immoral conduct and behavior unbecoming a teacher with one Laura De Bord, which motion being placed before the board received the affirmative vote and was by the chair declared carried, and the chair declared said W. A Wiest duly dismissed as a teacher in the schools of school district No. 24, Marion county, Oregon. Upon motion, clerk was instructed to notify W. A. Wiest of their findings. W. A Wiest being present before the board, he was in open meeting dismissed as a teacher. Adjournment followed.' That the false and defamatory matter, to wit, that plaintiff was guilty of immoral conduct and behavior unbecoming a teacher, was and is wholly...