William Carr, Appellant v. Samuel Duval and Others, Appellees
Decision Date | 01 January 1840 |
Citation | 10 L.Ed. 361,14 Pet. 77,39 U.S. 77 |
Parties | WILLIAM A. CARR, APPELLANT, v. SAMUEL H. DUVAL AND OTHERS, APPELLEES |
Court | U.S. Supreme Court |
ON appeal from the Court of Appeals for the Territory of Florida.
The case is fully stated in the opinion of the Court.
The cause was argued by Mr. Coxe and Mr. Webster, for the appellant; and by Mr. Jones and Mr. Crittenden, for the appellees.
In October 1825, William Harris, of Montgomery, Alabama, made his will, devising to his two sons, William and Stephen, the tract of land in controversy; lying on Lake Jackson, in Florida. Stephen and William, at their father's death were both minors; and William soon after died, leaving two brothers and three sisters, who are his heirs; and two of whom were infants when this bill was filed, and two of them married women. The land was unimproved and undivided. In the fall of 1835, William A. Carr, the complainant desired to purchase the land, and applied to Stephen W. Harris for the purpose, by letter; he Carr, residing in Georgia. The letter of Carr, opening the correspondence, is not in the record, but the answer to it is sufficiently explanatory. The answer is dated August 17th, 1835; in which Stephen W. Harris says, his father left the land to his young brother and himself, that his brother had died long since, and he had just come of age, and was entitled to half the land, which could be divided at any time; 'and my half,' says he, 'is for sale, but it has first to be divided; my price for that is ten dollars per acre.'
The next letter from Stephen W. Harris to complainant, is dated December 15th, 1835, acknowledging the receipt of one the day before from complainant, requesting to be informed of the quantity of the land. The answer stated it to be two thousand and hundred and thirty-one and one-fourth acres; and proposed to take Carr's offer for it, with interest on the last note, having two years to run.
On January 2d, 1836, Harris acknowledged the receipt of another letter from Carr, dated the 25th December, preceding. 'I have,' says he, 'come to the determination to sell you the land on the terms you mentioned:' and then asks to be informed when, and where they shall meet to make the necessary arrangements.
The letter of Carr of the 25th December, referred to, offers to exchange some lands of his in Georgia, (which, he says, he had previously described,) rated by him at twenty thousand dollars, for the Florida lands, he giving three thousand dollars difference; or, he would make the same offer he had previously done. What this offer was, appears by Harris' letter of the 16th January, 1836; and as this letter is the conclusion of the correspondence, so far as Harris was concerned, and is the principal evidence relied on to establish the agreement, it becomes necessary for the purposes of its proper understanding, and to ascertain the sense in which the parties understood it, to set it forth, together with the answers to it, of the 3d and 19th of February.
'Montgomery, January 16th, 1836.
'MR. WILLIAM A. CARR.
'Athens, February 3d, 1836.
'MR. STEPHEN W. HARRIS.
'Macon, February 19th, 1836.
'MR. STEPHEN W. HARRIS.
...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Binghampton Trust Company v. Auten
... ... appellant ... The ... Little Rock bank ... ...
-
Mccain v. Hartford Live Stock Ins. Co
...contemplated agreement had no existence; therefore there was no contract. Eliason v. Henshaw, 4 Wheat. 227, 4 L. Ed. 556; Carr v. Duval, 14 Pet. 77, 81, 10 L. Ed. 361; Misselhorn v. Mut. Reserve Fund Life Ass'n, supra; Paine v. Pac. Mut. Life Ins. Co., supra; Reserve Loan Life Ins. Co. v. H......
-
Leaf v. Codd
... ... 667, 43 Am. St ... 596, 27 S.W. 385; Carr v. Duval, 14 Pet. (U.S.) 77, ... 10 L.Ed. 361; ... JOHNSON, ... District Judge. William A. Lee, C. J., and Wm. E. Lee, Budge ... and ... of Minnie Karow but which the appellant Minnie Karow contends ... were written by her ... insisted by counsel for appellees that in writing the letter ... and signing ... ...
-
Prairie Development Co., Ltd. v. Leiberg
... ... 320, 13 S.Ct ... 886, 37 L.Ed. 749; Carr v. Duval, 14 Pet. 79-83, 10 ... L.Ed. 361; ... ...