Williams v. Romanowski, Civil Number 14-12171

CourtUnited States District Courts. 6th Circuit. United States District Court (Eastern District of Michigan)
Writing for the CourtHonorable David M. Lawson
PartiesSPENCER WILLIAMS, Petitioner, v. KENNETH ROMANOWSKI, Respondent.
Docket NumberCivil Number 14-12171
Decision Date21 July 2017


Civil Number 14-12171


July 21, 2017

Honorable David M. Lawson


Michigan prisoner Spencer Williams has filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus under 28 U.S.C. § 2254 challenging his convictions for assault with intent to murder, felon in possession of a firearm, and possession of a firearm during the commission of a felony (felony firearm), after a bench trial in the Wayne County, Michigan circuit court. He was sentenced to concurrent prison terms of 18 to 30 years plus a consecutive term of two years. Williams contends that the trial evidence was insufficient to support his convictions, trial and appellate counsel were ineffective, the prosecutor committed misconduct, the trial court failed to consider a lesser included offense, and the bind-over decision was defective. The respondent filed an answer to the petition contending that it should be denied because the claims lack merit and certain claims are barred by procedural default. The Court finds that the petitioner's claims do not warrant federal habeas relief. The Court, therefore, will deny the petition.


The petitioner's convictions arise from the non-fatal shooting of Damon Moore outside of Moore's residence in Hamtramck, Michigan in October 2009. Before trial, the petitioner was offered a plea deal in which he could plead guilty to assault with intent to murder and felony firearm

Page 2

in exchange for the dismissal of other charges, coupled with a sentencing agreement of consecutive prison terms of 11 to 20 plus two years. Against the advice of counsel, he rejected that offer and proceeded with a bench trial.

At trial, 31-year-old victim Damon Moore testified that he and the petitioner were like brothers. The petitioner had dated his cousin and they had known each other for 15 years. He never had a problem with the petitioner. That changed on October 4, 2009.

That night, Moore went to a party hosted by the petitioner's cousin, which was only a few blocks from his house. He was at the party with the petitioner and another man named Mike and he drank a few beers. At some point, the petitioner asked to borrow his car to go pick up some girls. Moore let him take the car. The petitioner was gone for several hours, perhaps as long as six hours, which upset Moore.

When the petitioner returned, the girls were in the backseat. Moore got into his car with the petitioner, Mike, and the girls and they drove back to Moore's house sometime after midnight. Moore went into the house and spoke to his girlfriend. He then went back outside to park his car in back of the house. As he drove in the alley, the petitioner with Mike and the two girls, now in the petitioner's car, followed him. The petitioner flashed his lights. Moore stopped his car and the petitioner came over and retrieved something from Moore's car. Moore and the petitioner argued and tussled in the back of Moore's car. Mike then grabbed Moore from behind and Moore let the petitioner go. While Moore continued to tussle with Mike, the petitioner went back to his car. When Moore next saw him, he was holding a gun, which Moore described as a black and woodgrain "AK."

Page 3

The petitioner was standing about six feet away when he shot Moore in the right thigh. Moore fell down. The petitioner walked back and forth and moved closer to Moore until he was about five feet away. According to Moore, the petitioner looked spaced out and was saying things like, "I'm gonna start killing mother fucker, mother fucker gonna stop disrespecting me." The petitioner then shot Moore again in the calf of the same leg while continuing to mutter to himself. He then shot Moore a third time above the knee in the same leg.

Moore was surprised by the shooting and thought that the petitioner was going to kill him. Moore also testified that the petitioner pointed the gun at his chest and tried to fire again, but it did not fire. While the petitioner was messing with the gun, someone yelled out and threatened to call the police. Moore yelled at them to take him to the hospital, but the petitioner, Mike, and the girls left the scene, driving away in both cars. Moore was woozy and next remembered waking up in the hospital. Moore underwent several surgeries and lost his right leg due to his injuries. Moore spoke with the police, his girlfriend, and his mother at the hospital and told them that the petitioner was the person who shot him.

Moore's girlfriend, 27-year-old Tenisha Lewis, testified that she lived with Moore in the house where the shooting occurred in October 4, 2009. She recalled that Moore went to a party hosted by one of the petitioner's relatives that day and returned home late during the early morning hours. The petitioner's car was at the house while Moore was at the party. She spoke with Moore on the phone around 11:00 a.m. and then spoke to him in person when he came home around 1:00 a.m., although she was not sure of the exact time. When Moore went back outside, she got out of bed and looked out of the window. She saw Moore get into his car and the petitioner get into his own car. Moore pulled around to the back and the petitioner followed him. She went back to bed.

Page 4

A few minutes later, she heard three gunshots. She called Moore's brother and told him that she heard gunshots. The police and an ambulance arrived, as did Moore's brother. She did not see Moore's car outside after the shooting. When she visited Moore in the hospital, he told her who shot him and she reported it to the police. She did not personally witness the shooting.

Hamtramck Police Officer Robert George testified that he was called to the scene of the shooting where he found Moore lying in the alley with gunshot wounds to his leg. Moore told him his name and then fell into unconsciousness. Moore had lost a large amount of blood and his leg looked mangled. Officer George assisted EMS in transporting Moore to the hospital. When George returned to the scene of the shooting, he recovered a shell casing that had been hidden in the blood and two bullets from holes in the asphalt where Moore had been lying on the ground.

The parties stipulated to the admission of Moore's medical records and stipulated that the petitioner had prior felony convictions and was not eligible to possess a firearm at the time of the shooting.

Defense counsel moved for a directed verdict; the motion was denied. The petitioner presented an alibi defense. Defense counsel indicated that there were three potential alibi witnesses: the petitioner's sister, mother, and girlfriend. The petitioner's sister was not present at trial and his mother and girlfriend refused to testify. The petitioner, however, testified on his own behalf, stating that he was 27 years old and admitting that he had prior convictions for theft and dishonesty and had used aliases in the past. The petitioner acknowledged that he was Moore's friend, that he had dated Moore's cousin, and that he had known him for 15 years. He also admitted that he did not have any problems with Moore or his girlfriend. The petitioner denied being in the Detroit area when the shooting occurred and claimed that he was in Saginaw babysitting his sister's two children at that

Page 5

time. He testified that he went to Saginaw on September 23, 2009 where he remained until his arrest on November 13, 2009. The petitioner theorized that Moore was pinning the shooting on him because the petitioner knew who committed the crime but refused to tell Moore. The petitioner also testified that Moore was a gang member who had been on America's Most Wanted and that Moore was blaming him for the shooting because he knew about murders that Moore had committed.

The trial court found the petitioner guilty of assault with intent to commit murder, felon in possession, and felony firearm, explaining:

In reviewing the evidence presented in this matter, I've considered most significantly the testimony of Damon Moore and that testimony that I found to be important and to be credible was Mr. Moore's testimony that the Defendant borrowed his vehicle, that that was at a party on October 4th, 2009, that was a family member of the Defendant. Mr. Moore described it as his cousin's. And that was a 2002 Cadillac that was borrowed and the purpose of borrowing the car was that he was going to — Mr. Williams was going to find some women to bring back to the party.

Mr. Moore testified that he drank some beers at the party and that he initially said no to borrowing the car but eventually allowed Mr. Williams to borrow the car. And at one point, after several hours, he called Mr. Williams and Mr. Williams indicated he'd come back and he didn't but he did eventually come back with two girls in the back seat.

That eventually they left the party, went back to Mr. Moore's house on Lumpkin and that was also the home of Tenisha Lewis. And that Mr. Moore indicated that he went inside and spoke to Ms. Lewis and when he came back out, he got in his vehicle and was going to pull it around to the back of the alley where he was going to park it, but that the lights were flashed on the car that Mr. Williams was driving. Then he stopped and got out of the vehicle and that's when the fight ensued. He called it a tussle between himself and Mr. Williams. And that that tussle lasted for a short while and that when that broke up, I think my recollection of the testimony was it broke up in part because this individual who was identified as Mike, and say for the record that Mr. Moore testified that he didn't know Mike's last name. He said he thought it might be Mike Johnson, but wasn't sure what his name — but Mike grabbed him around the neck and they began to tussle and it was at that point that he noticed that Mr. Williams had got a gun, which he identified as an AK-47, was pointing

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT