Witt v. Rosenbush

• Decision Date: 17 April 1941
• Docket Number: 2 Div. 167.
• Citation: 1 So.2d 651,241 Ala. 168
• Parties: WITT. et al. v. ROSENBUSH.
• Court: Alabama Supreme Court

1 So.2d 651

241 Ala. 168

WITT. et al. v. ROSENBUSH.

2 Div. 167.

Supreme Court of Alabama

April 17, 1941

Thos. F. Seale, Jr., of Livingston, for appellants.

Ira D. Pruitt and Geo. O. Miller, both of Livingston, for appellee.

BROWN Justice.

This is a statutory action in the nature of the action of ejectment instituted by the appellee against appellants for the possession of a house and lot situated in Livingston, Sumter County. At the conclusion of the evidence, the court, at plaintiff's request, gave the general affirmative charge with hypothesis for him, and refused a like charge requested by the defendants.

The parties claim title through a common source, Devie Witt, now deceased. The plaintiff sought to establish title through the levy of an execution issued on a judgment by default rendered by a Justice of the Peace, for want of personal property of the defendant subject to levy, sufficient to satisfy the writ, followed by notice of the levy, and an order of the circuit court, affirming the regularity of the proceedings and a sale of the property thereunder.

The defendants claim title as the only heirs at law of said Devie Witt, deceased.

The statutes authorizing the proceedings, under which plaintiff claims, Code of 1923, §§ 8745-8748, provide:

§ 8745. "If the defendant has no personal property known to the constable, or if it is insufficient to satisfy the execution he must indorse the fact upon the execution, and may then levy on land of the defendant subject to execution, describing it in his levy, and make return thereof to the justice, who shall thereupon immediately transmit all the papers in the cause to the circuit court, or court having like jurisdiction."

§ 8746. "If the defendant on whose land the levy is made is a resident of, and within the county, personal notice of the levy must be given him; otherwise, he must be served by posting a notice in a conspicuous place on the land levied on."

§ 8747. "If the proceedings before the justice are regular, and establish a judgment against the defendant, issue of execution and levy on land for want of personal property, and twenty days' notice thereof, and no sufficient objection is made, the court must, on motion of the plaintiff, direct a sale of the land for the satisfaction of the judgment."

§ 8748. "The clerk of the court in which the motion is made must record all the proceedings before the justice, together with the return of the constable, the motion of the plaintiff, and the order of the court thereon, and must issue a writ directing the sheriff to sell the land for the satisfaction of the judgment." [Italics supplied.]

The jurisdiction of the circuit court to order a sale of lands upon which execution from a Justice of the Peace has been levied, is statutory and limited, and strict compliance with the statute must appear on the face of the proceedings. Code 1923, § 8747; Johnson v. Dismukes, 104 Ala. 520, 16 So. 424.

The statute requires that "all the proceedings before the justice, together with the return of the constable, the motion of the plaintiff, and the order of the [circuit] court," be recorded, and that the clerk must issue "a writ directing the sheriff to sell the land for the...