Young v. Harvey

• Decision Date: 07 June 1861
• Citation: Young v. Harvey, 16 Ind. 314 (Ind. 1861)
• Parties: Young v. Harvey
• Court: Indiana Supreme Court

16 Ind. 314

Young v. Harvey

Supreme Court of Indiana

June 7, 1861

A Petition for Rehearing Was Overruled in This Case

APPEAL from the Marion Common Pleas.

The judgment is reversed, with costs. Cause remanded for another trial.

J. W Gordon and J. A. Beale, for the appellant.

G. K Perrin, for the appellee.

OPINION

Perkins J.

Young sued Harvey for the value of a horse alleged to have been killed through the negligence of the latter. The facts in the case are as follows:

Harvey, the defendant, commenced digging a well upon a lot owned by him. He sunk it to the depth of six feet, being forty-two inches across, and then abandoned it. It was located in an uninclosed lot, near the line of a street, in a suburb of Indianapolis, but without the corporate limits. It remained a long time in this condition, except that it was sometimes partially covered over with loose boards, never entirely, and most of the time not at all. The hole, or pit was useless. The city of Indianapolis, in a suburb of which the well was, contained 25,000 inhabitants, a very large number of whom were in the habit, or custom, of keeping cows, horses, and hogs, and permitting them to graze, especially during the day, upon the public commons; of which there was a great extent, and almost always covered with the kind of animals above mentioned, in the vicinity of the lot on which the hole in question was dug, and of which commons said lot formed a part. Children sported and adults promenaded on said commons. The county board of Marion county, in which is Indianapolis and its suburbs, had authorized the running at large on the public commons of all animals, except certain stud horses and jack asses. The order of the board was admitted in evidence without objection. On a certain day the gelding of the plaintiff, while grazing on said commons, fell into said hole, so made as the commencement of a...