Youse v. Norcum
| Court | Missouri Supreme Court |
| Writing for the Court | NAPTON |
| Citation | Youse v. Norcum, 12 Mo. 549 (Mo. 1849) |
| Decision Date | 31 October 1849 |
| Parties | JOSEPH YOUSE v. FREDERICK NORCUM. |
APPEAL FROM ST. LOUIS COURT OF COMMON PLEAS.
This was an action of ejectment for a lot of ground in the city of St. Louis, fronting on the river, brought in the Common Pleas, in August, 1848. A judgment was rendered for Norcum, plaintiff below, in December last, from which Youse took an appeal. The recovery was for a lot of 18 feet 8 1/2 inches in front, running back some 137 feet 11 inches. This lot was part of a square or block of ground lying between Cherry street on the north, and Oak street on the south, Main street on the west, and Front street on the east, separating it from the river. The plaintiff below, as well as defendant, claimed under one Nicolas Hebert dit Lecompte. No documentary evidence of title in said Nicolas Lecompte, was given by plaintiff below, but he proved by oral testimony that said Lecompte lived on that square as far back as 1787, and continued to reside there till his death on the 27th April, 1815. That block was, under the Spanish government, the last block in the town towards the north reaching up to near the half-moon fortification. It appeared that Lecompte had his ground entirely inclosed by fences, the front fence running along on Main street, the south along the cross street towards the river, since called Oak street, and the fence on the river side was some distance back from the river, supposed to be about forty yards distant from low water, by the witness Paschall L. Cerre. The same witness testified that Lecompte did not occupy the whole block or square in front on Main street, but that one Charles Buisson, son-in-law of Lecompte, occupied the northern part of the square next to what is now Cherry street, and lived on it, having his lot inclosed, and there being between his fence and the northern fence of Lecompte, a passage left which ran the whole depth of Buisson's fence. He further stated that Lecompte's house was near his (Lecompte's) northern fence, and that Lecompte's front on Main street extended from Oak street on the south, more than half the square, but did not comprehend the whole square, and did not embrace Buisson's lot; that he could not tell the size of Buisson's lot, whether more or less than 50 feet; that Buisson lived there about the time of the change of government, but whether before or not he could not say. The plaintiff below gave in evidence a deed from said Lecompte to Julie Bissonet, his daughter, dated 2nd July, 1812, conveying to her the southern portion of said block, to-wit: 45 feet French measure on Main street, running to the river, bounded south by cross street, (afterwards Oak), also a second deed from Lecompte to Julie Bissonet, dated 27th July, 1814, conveying to her 25 feet, French measure, bounded south by the other lot conveyed to her, and north by land reserved by the grantor, thus giving to that daughter, 70 feet, French, off from the south side of the block. The plaintiff read in evidence also a deed from Joseph Bissonet and Julie, his wife, dated 6th September, 1815, to McKnight & Brady, conveying to them the lot last above mentioned of 25 feet in width, bounded north by the property of Nicolas Lecompte, deceased; also a deed dated the 9th September, 1815, purporting to have been executed by the heirs of said Nicolas Lecompte, to-wit: Nicolas Hebert Lecompte, Guillaum Hebert Lecompte, Hyacinth Hebert Lecompte, Charles Buisson, Joseph Bissonet and Julie, his wife, Marie Hebert dit Lecompte, and Pierre Chouteau, jr., acting for Pierre Hebert dit Lecompte. This deed, after reciting that they are the heirs of Nicolas Lecompte, sets forth, that they are desirous of regulating and disposing of the property and effects of his estate, with the intervention of a court of justice, and provides that Charles Buisson shall make an inventory of the movables, and a sale and division of the proceeds, said moveables comprehending certain slaves; that Nicolas Hebert Lecompte and Guillaum Hebert Lecompte, transfer and convey to the estate 200 arpents of land, situate at the point of Missouri, which had been sold to them by the said Nicolas Hebert did Lecompte, by deed dated 17th March, 1815, “reserving to themselves, only the town lot mentioned in said deed, which contains 85 feet front on Main street, by 150 feet more or less in depth, bounded west by Main street, east by Mississippi river, north by the lot of Charles Buisson, and south by the lot of Marie Hebert dit Lecompte; the deed then proceeds as follows: Fourthly, that by these presents, for the considerations known and recognized between the undersigned heirs, they, the said undersigned heirs, sell, assign, transfer, quit-claim and convey to the said Marie Hebert dit Lecompte, a town lot situate in this city of St. Louis, containing thirty-five feet in front, and 150 feet more or less in depth, bounded in front on the first principal street that separates it from the lot of Jacques Lajeunisse, east by the river Mississippi, north by the lot of Nicolas and Guillaum Hebert dit Lecompte, and south by the lot of McKnight & Brady, heretofore of Joseph Bissonet, for her, her heirs and assigns, to enjoy and dispose of,” &c. Said deed then states that the reserve by Nicolas & Guillaum above stated, is ratified; and that Buisson is authorized to sell a tract of 400 arpents of land lying in the point of the Missouri, and to divide the proceeds thereof, and of the personalty equally among said heirs. This deed was acknowledged by the parties, and recorded on the 28th September, 1815. The lot sued for in this action is part of the one described as conveyed to Marie Hebert Lecompte. She was born on the 2nd May, 1798, and was married the 4th September, 1816 to Joseph Vasquez. On the 4th November, 1816, Joseph Vasquez and Marie, his wife, conveyed the said lot of 35 feet, in fee, to Thomas Hanley. Hanley and wife mortgaged the same, in fee, to John Mullanphy; on the 27th March, 1818, that mortgage was foreclosed, and a sale made of the lot to John Mullanphy, and a sheriff's deed executed therefor to him, dated 6th November, 1824, which several deeds were duly recorded at or near their respective dates. It was proved that Mullanphy took possession of said lot in 1824 or 1825, and he and his representatives have held continued possession thereof ever since; and that in 1826 or 1827, he built warehouses on the front of it, and that the defendant is tenant of the heirs of said John Mullanphy. Marie Hebert was a little over 18 1/2 years of age at the time she and her husband, Vasquez, made the deed to Hanley. She and her husband lived in and near St. Louis always, till his death in June, 1848; at the time of his marriage he lived with his mother, about 300 feet from the lot in question, and continued to reside at the same place for many years, and then removed to Viede Posche, and never lived out of the county of St. Louis.
On the 5th February, 1846, Joseph Vasquez and wife made their deed to Louis A. Labeaume of that date, conveying their right, title and interest in said lot, without any covenants for the title, and by deed dated 29th May, 1846, Labeaume and wife convey to plaintiffs below the same lot.
Nicolas Hebert Lecompte, the elder, left at his death children and heirs, to-wit: Nicolas Hebert dit Lecompte, Pierre Hebert dit Lecompte, Guillaum Hebert dit Lecompte, Hyacinth Hebert dit Lecompte, Julie Bissonet, Marie Louise, afterwards married to Vasquez. All these are dead except this Vasquez; and none left children except Pierre, Hyacinth and Julie.
A deed was read in evidence by defendant below, dated 4th September, 1815, from Pierre Hebert dit Lecompte to Charles Buisson, which set forth that his father, Nicolas Hebert Lecompte, and his mother in their life-time had often told him that they had given to Buisson a lot 50 feet French measure, part on Main street, bounded north by a cross street or Madame Lachaisse, south by lot of said Nicolas, and east by the bank of the river; and that he knew that Buisson had advanced them money or other effects to more than the value of the lot; that therefore he the said Pierre quit-claimed and conveyed said lot to Buisson in fee. This deed was acknowledged on the 4th September, 1815. Below it, on the same sheet, is the deed of Nicolas, Guillaum, Hyacinth, Bissonet and wife Julie, and Marie Hebert Lecompte, dated the 9th of September, 1815. The defendant also gave in evidence the deed of Joseph Vasquez and wife Marie, to Robert N. Moore, dated the 10th April, 1845, conveying to Moore her interest in Bussion's 50 feet lot. This deed recorded in October, 1848.
The defendant asked the following instructions: 1st. If the court, sitting as a jury, find from the evidence that the title of the land in controversy in this action, was conveyed in fee to Marie Louise Lecompte, in the year 1815, and that afterwards, in September of that year, she was married to Joseph Vasquez; that on the 4th November, 1816, the said Vasquez and wife executed and delivered to Hanley the deed given in evidence in this case of that date, and that that deed described and purported to convey the same land; that the said Marie Louise was born on the 2nd May, in the year 1798, and that neither she or her husband, at any time within four years after she married, at the age of twenty-one years, rescinded, or attempted to rescind their said conveyance to Hanley, nor within that time brought any suit for, or set up any claim to said land inconsistent with their said deed, then they will find for the defendant. 2nd. If the court, sitting as a jury, find from the evidence that Joseph Vasquez and wife executed to Hanley the deed given in evidence of 4th September, 1816; that it embraces the land in controversy, and was duly acknowledged and recorded in a year from its date; that the same land has been ever since claimed and held under that deed by Hanley, and those claiming under him; that said Vasquez and wife...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
Harris v. Ross
...is necessary before bringing ejectment. Chadburn v. Radcliff, 30 Me. 354; Cole v. Pennoyer, 14 Ill. 158; 1 Am. Lead. Cases, 256; Youse v. Norcum, 12 Mo. 549; Peterson v. Laik, 24 Mo. 541; Jackson v. Carpenter, 11 Johns. 538. And this is especially the case in reference to the disaffirmance ......
-
Linville v. Greer
... ... confirmation. Indeed, nothing of the sort is claimed ... Harris v. Ross, 86 Mo. 89; Yanse v. Norcum, ... 12 Mo. 563; Huth v. Carondelet, 56 Mo. 210; Lacy ... v. Pikler, 120 Mo. 388; Throckmorton v. Pence, ... 121 Mo. 59; Sim v. Everhart, ... 65.] ... Mere ... silence, however long, or omission ... [65 S.W. 584] ... to act, is not an affirmance. [ Youse v. Norcum, 12 ... Mo. 549; Huth v. Carondelet, ... ...
-
Holcomb v. Pressley
...(3) Mere silence, acquiescence, or omission to act, however long continued, is not an affirmance. Linville v. Greer, 165 Mo. 398; Youse v. Norcum, 12 Mo. 549; Huth Carondolet, 56 Mo. 210; Stull v. Harris, 51 Ark. 294; Tucker v. Moreland, 10 Pet. 75, 76; Jackson v. Carpenter, 11 Johns. 542; ......
-
Goodnow v. Empire Lumber Company
... ... Parr, 20 Ark. 600; ... Boody v. McKenney, 23 Me. 517; ... Davis v. Dudley, 70 Me. 236; Prout ... v. Wiley, 28 Mich. 164; Youse v ... Norcum, 12 Mo. 549; Norcum v ... Gaty, 19 Mo. 65; Peterson v. Laik, ... 24 Mo. 541; Baker v. Kennett, 54 Mo. 82; ... Huth v. Car. Mar ... ...