Peter O'callaghan v. Michael Cronan &Amp; Another

Decision Date10 October 1876
Citation121 Mass. 114
CourtUnited States State Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts Supreme Court
PartiesPeter O'Callaghan v. Michael Cronan & another

Worcester. Tort against Michael Cronan and John Cronan. The declaration was as follows.

"The plaintiff says that on or about August 4, 1870, by articles in writing, duly executed by both parties thereto, he formed a copartnership with John Cronan, one of the defendants, in the business of making clothing and buying and selling ready-made clothing, and by the terms of said articles said copartnership was to continue five years from its date aforesaid, and, at the time of the grievances hereinafter set forth, the said copartnership had a long time, to wit, the period of about two years, to run, and said company had always done and were then doing a large and profitable business, and the plaintiff expected and had reasonable cause to expect that large profits would accrue to him from the continued business of said firm up to the end of said period. And the defendants heretofore, to wit, on or about October 10, 1873, with the unlawful purpose of forcing and compelling the plaintiff to withdraw from said firm and to dispose of his interest therein to them or one of them, unlawfully conspired together to accomplish said unlawful purpose, and in pursuance thereof, by false and malicious representations and, by other unlawful inducements offered to various creditors of said firm, procured said creditors to attach on several writs all the stock in trade belonging to said firm and to represent to the attaching officer that said goods so attached were liable greatly to depreciate in value, and to petition said officer to sell said goods forthwith on said writs. And the plaintiff says that said creditors, by reason of said false and malicious representations and inducements did attach all of said goods, and petition for the sale of the same on said several writs as aforesaid; and said defendants, in further pursuance of said unlawful purpose induced said officer, and said officer threatened to sell all said goods in the lump, whereby the same were liable to be sacrificed and sold for much less than their true value. And the plaintiff says that by said unlawful means he was forced to and did withdraw from said firm against his will, and give up and surrender the large profits he reasonably hoped to make in the prosecution of said business in said firm, and sell and dispose of his interest in said goods for...

To continue reading

Request your trial
21 cases
  • Burdict v. The Missouri Pacific Railway Company
    • United States
    • Missouri Supreme Court
    • 18 June 1894
    ...Redfield on Negligence, sec. 3. (2) There can be no negligence in the absence of a legal duty due from one person to another. O'Callaghan v. Cronin, 121 Mass. 114; Cooley Torts, p. 60; Kerwhacker v. Railroad, 3 Ohio St. 188; Wharton on Negligence, secs. 3 and 24; Rich v. Railroad, 87 N.Y. 3......
  • Willett v. Herrick
    • United States
    • United States State Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts Supreme Court
    • 8 March 1927
    ...not evidence of duress. Forbes v. Appleton, supra; Grimes v. Briggs, supra; Chandler v. Sanger, 114 Mass. 364, 19 Am. Rep. 367;O'Callaghan v. Cronan, 121 Mass. 114;Lajoie v. Milliken, 242 Mass. 508, 136 N. E. 419. On the facts disclosed in this case the motives of a creditor in bringing an ......
  • Mahoney v. Roberts
    • United States
    • Arkansas Supreme Court
    • 27 April 1908
    ... ... for the mere inducing another to break his contract, there ... being no ... ...
  • Jackson v. Morgan
    • United States
    • Indiana Appellate Court
    • 9 May 1911
    ...conspiracy or malice, or oppression or vindictive purpose, they are of no avail; they merely heap up epithets.” And again, in O'Callahan v. Cronan, 121 Mass. 114: “The allegations of conspiracy, illegality, falsehood, and malice will not support an action, unless either the purpose intended......
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT