20 Mo.App. 1 (Mo.App. 1885), Pickens v. Dorris

Citation:20 Mo.App. 1
Opinion Judge:ROMBAUER, J.
Party Name:ANDREW J. PICKENS, Respondent, v. THOMAS DORRIS ET AL., Appellants.
Attorney:HUGO, MUENCH, and BOYLE, ADAMS & MCKEIGAN, for the appellants: JAMES M. LEWIS, for the respondent; J. B. HENDERSON and J. P. KERR, of counsel.
Case Date:December 08, 1885
Court:Court of Appeals of Missouri
 
FREE EXCERPT

Page 1

20 Mo.App. 1 (Mo.App. 1885)

ANDREW J. PICKENS, Respondent,

v.

THOMAS DORRIS ET AL., Appellants.

Court of Appeals of Missouri, St. Louis.

December 8, 1885

APPEAL from the St. Louis Circuit Court, DANIEL DILLON, Judge.

Affirmed.

HUGO, MUENCH, and BOYLE, ADAMS & MCKEIGAN, for the appellants: The interest of Thomas Dorris in the net income from rents and profits, being an equitable right conferred upon him by a volunteer and not out of his own property or by trusts of his own creation, are not subject to the payment of his debts, until they become his by reduction to possession so as to be his property. McIlvaine v. Smith, 42 Mo. 45; Hardenburgh v. Blair, 30 N.J.Eq. 645; Pom. Eq. Jur., §§ 102-106?? Nichols v. Eaton, 91 U.S. 716 (bk. 23, L. ed. 254), and cases cited; Hyde v. Woods, 94 U.S. 523 (bk. 24, ?? 265); Montague v. Crane, 12 Mo.App. 582; No. ?? and cases cited; Thackara v. Mintzer, 100 Pa.St. 151, Swaby's App., 18 Rep. 350; Campbell v. Foster, 35 N.Y. 361. Devises of income may, by limitation, be withheld from the liability for payment of the debts of the beneficiary; and whether or not there be such limitation may be gathered from the evident intention of the donor as gathered from all the provisions of the will. Steib v. Whitehead, 111 Ill. 247; Nichols v. Eaton, supra; Rhoads v. Rhoads, 43 Ill. 239; Spindle v. Shreve, 9 Biss. 199; Broadway Nat. Bk. v. Adams, 133 Mass. 170; Turner v. Timberlake, 53 Mo. 371; Smith v. Hutchinson, 61 Mo. 83; Allison v. Chaney, 63 Mo. 279; Crecelius v. Horst, 78 Mo. 566, and cases cited on point first; 2 Redf. Wills (4 Ed.) 302, n. 93.

JAMES M. LEWIS, for the respondent; J. B. HENDERSON and J. P. KERR, of counsel.

OPINION

ROMBAUER, J.

George P. Dorris made his will, in which, among other things, he devised certain houses to trustees " in trust to possess and keep the same rented as advantageously as may be, and out of the rents to pay for all proper repairs to said houses and for a reasonable insurance thereon and the expenses of their care, and all taxes, charges, and assessments, levied, imposed, or charged thereon and within the times required by law, and the balance to my son, Thomas Dorris, during his natural life."

The remainder of his estate he devised to the same trustees to be held, sold, and put into condition to realize as large a net income as possible, and to pay such net income...

To continue reading

FREE SIGN UP