In re Nat'l Football League Players Concussion Injury Litig.
| Decision Date | 18 April 2016 |
| Docket Number | 15–2234,15–2294,15–2291,Nos. 15–2206,15–2217,15–2305.,15–2230,15–2292,15–2304,15–2290,15–2272,15–2273,s. 15–2206 |
| Citation | 821 F.3d 410 |
| Parties | IN RE NATIONAL FOOTBALL LEAGUE PLAYERS CONCUSSION INJURY LITIGATION. Craig Heimburger; Dawn Heimburger, Appellants (15–2206) Cleo Miller; Judson Flint; Elmer Underwood; Vincent Clark, Sr.; Ken Jones; Fred Smerlas; Jim Rourke ; Lou Piccone; James David Wilkins, II, Appellants (15–2217) Curtis L. Anderson, Appellant (15–2230) Darren R. Carrington, Appellant (15–2234) Raymond Armstrong; Nathaniel Newton, Jr.; Larry Brown; Kenneth Davis; Michael McGruder; Clifton L. Odom; George Teague ; Drew Coleman; Dennis DeVaughn; Alvin Harper; Ernest Jones ; Michael Kiselak; Jeremy Loyd; Gary Wayne Lewis; Lorenzo Lynch; Hurles Scales, Jr.; Gregory Evans; David Mims ; Evan Ogelsby; Phillip E. Epps; Charles L. Haley, Sr.; Kevin Rey Smith; Darryl Gerard Lewis; Curtis Bernard Wilson; Kelvin Mack Edwards, Sr.; Dwayne Levels; Solomon Page ; Tim McKyer; Larry Barnes; James Garth Jax; William B. Duff; Mary Hughes; Barbara Scheer, Appellants (15–2272) Liyongo Patrise Alexander; Charlie Anderson; Charles E. Arbuckle; Cassandra Bailey, as Representative of the Estate of Johnny Bailey; Ben Bronson; Curtis Ceaser, Jr.; Larry Centers; Darrell Colbert; Harry Colon; Christopher Crooms; Jerry W. Davis ; Tim Denton ; Michael Dumas; Corris Ervin; Doak Field; Baldwin Malcolm Frank; Derrick Frazier; Murray E. Garrett; Clyde P. Glosson; Roderick W. Harris; Wilmer K. Hicks, Jr.; Patrick Jackson; Gary Jones; Ryan McCoy ; Jerry James Moses, Jr.; Anthony E. Newsom; Rance Olison; John Owens; Robert Pollard; Derrick Pope; Glenell Sanders; Thomas Sanders; Dwight A. Scales; Todd Scott; Frankie Smith; Jermaine Smith; Tyrone Smith ; James A. Young, Sr., Appellants (15–2273) Scott Gilchrist, individually and on behalf of the Estate of Carlton Chester “Cookie” Gilchrist, Appellant (15–2290) Jimmie H. Jones; Ricky Ray ; Jesse Solomon, Appellants (15–2291) Andrew Stewart, Appellant (15–2292) Willie T. Taylor, Appellant (15–2294) Alan Faneca; Roderick “Rock” Cartwright; Jeff Rohrer; Sean Considine, Appellants (15–2304) James Mayberry, Appellant (15–2305). |
| Court | U.S. Court of Appeals — Third Circuit |
TerriAnne Benedetto, Esquire, Seeger Weiss, Gene Locks, Esquire, David D. Langfitt, Esquire, Locks Law Firm, Dianne M. Nast, Esquire, NastLaw, Arnold Levin, Esquire, Frederick S. Longer, Esquire, Levin, Fishbein, Sedran & Berman, Robert C. Heim, Esquire, Dechert, Sol H. Weiss, Esquire, Anapol Schwartz, Philadelphia, PA, David R. Buchanan, Esquire, Diogenes P. Kekatos, Esquire, Christopher A. Seeger, Esquire, Seeger Weiss LLP, Samuel Issacharoff, Esquire (Argued), New York University Law School, Brad S. Karp, Esquire, Theodore V. Wells, Jr., Esquire, Lynn B. Bayard, Esquire, Bruce A. Birenboim, Esquire, Walter R. Reiman, Esquire, Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison, New York, NY, Stephen F. Rosenthal, Esquire, Steven C. Marks, Esquire, Podhurst Orseck, Miami, FL, Beth A. Wilkinson, Esq., Wilkinson Walsh & Eskovitz, Paul D. Clement, Esquire (Argued), Andrew N. Ferguson, Esquire, David Zachary Hudson, Esquire, Robert M. Bernstein, Esquire, Bancroft PLLC, Washington, DC, for Appellees.
Alan B. Morrison, Esquire, George Washington University, Scott L. Nelson, Esquire, Public Citizen Litigation Group, Washington, DC, for Amicus Appellant Public Citizen Inc.
Shana De Caro, Esquire, Michael V. Kaplen, Esquire, De Caro & Kaplan, Pleasantville, NY, for Amicus Curiae Brain Injury Association of America.
Christopher A. Bandas, Esquire, Bandas Law Firm, Corpus Christi, TX, Howard J. Bashman, Esquire (Argued), Willow Grove, PA, Gary P. Lightman, Esquire, Glenn A. Manochi, Esquire, Lightman & Manochi, Philadelphia, PA, for Appellants Craig and Dawn Heimburger.
Edward W. Cochran, Esquire, Cochran & Cochran, Shaker Heights, OH, John J. Pentz, Esquire, Sudbury, MA, for Appellants
Cleo Miller; Judson Flint; Elmer Underwood; Vincent Clark, Sr.; Ken Jones ; Fred Smerlas; Jim Rourke; Lou Piccone; James David Wilkins, II.
George W. Cochran, Esquire, Streetsboro, OH, for Appellant Curtis L. Anderson.
Joseph Darrell Palmer, Esquire, Carlsbad, CA, Jan L. Westfall, Esquire, Menifee, CA, for Appellant Darren R. Carrington.
Richard L. Coffman, Esquire, The Coffman Law Firm, Mitchell A. Toups, Esquire, Weller Green Toups & Terrell, Beaumont, TX, Deepak Gupta, Esquire (Argued), Matthew W.H. Wessler, Esquire, Jonathan E. Taylor, Esquire, Gupta Wessler PLLC, Washington, DC, Jason C. Webster, Esquire, The Webster Law Firm, Houston, TX, for Appellants Raymond Armstrong; Nathaniel Newton, Jr.; Larry Brown ; Kenneth Davis; Michael McGruder; Clifton L. Odom; George Teague ; Drew Coleman; Dennis DeVaughn; Alvin Harper; Ernest Jones ; Michael Kiselak; Jeremy Loyd; Gary Wayne Lewis ; Lorenzo Lynch; Hurles Scales, Jr.; Gregory Evans; David Mims; Evan Ogelsby; Phillip E. Epps; Charles L. Haley, Sr.; Kevin Rey Smith; Darryl Gerard Lewis; Curtis Bernard Wilson; Kelvin Mack Edwards, Sr.; Dwayne Levels; Solomon Page; Tim McKyer; Larry Barnes ; James Garth Jax; William B. Duff ; Mary Hughes; Barbara Scheer; Willie T. Taylor.
Lance H. Lubel, Esquire, Adam Q. Voyles, Esquire, Lubel Voyles, Mickey L. Washington, Esquire, Houston, TX, Charles L. Becker, Esquire (Argued), Kline & Specter, Philadelphia, PA, for Appellants Liyongo Patrise Alexander; Charlie Anderson ; Charles E. Arbuckle; Cassandra Bailey, as Representative of the Estate of Johnny Bailey; Ben Bronson; Curtis Ceaser, Jr.; Larry Centers; Darrell Colbert; Harry Colon; Christopher Crooms; Jerry W. Davis; Tim Denton; Michael Dumas; Corris Ervin; Doak Field; Baldwin Malcolm Frank; Derrick Frazier; Murray E. Garrett; Clyde P. Glosson; Roderick W. Harris; Wilmer K. Hicks, Jr.; Patrick Jackson; Gary Jones ; Ryan McCoy; Jerry James Moses, Jr.; Anthony E. Newsom; Rance Olison; John Owens ; Robert Pollard; Derrick Pope; Glenell Sanders: Thomas Sanders ; Dwight A. Scales; Todd Scott; Frankie Smith; Jermaine Smith; Tyrone Smith ; James A. Young, Sr.
Jared H. Beck, Esquire, Elizabeth Lee Beck, Esquire, Beck & Lee Trial Lawyers, Antonino G. Hernandez, Esquire, Miami, FL, Cullin A. O'Brien, Esquire (Argued), Fort Lauderdale, FL, Jeffrey J. Cairlanto, Esquire, Profy Promisloff & Ciarlanto, Philadelphia, PA, for Appellant Scott Gilchrist, individually and on behalf of the Estate of Carlton Chester “Cookie” Gilchrist.
Dwight P. Bostwick, Esquire, Zuckerman Spaeder LLP, Washington, DC, Cyril V. Smith, Esquire, Zuckerman Spaeder LLP, Baltimore, MD, Ramya Kasturi, Esquire, Zuckerman Spaeder LLP, New York, NY, for Appellants Jimmie H. Jones; Ricky Ray; Jesse Solomon.
Stuart D. Lurie, Esquire, Rosenthal Lurie, Exton, PA, Michael H. Rosenthal, Esquire, Rosenthal Lurie, Philadelphia, PA, for Appellant Andrew Stewart.
Steven F. Molo, Esquire (Argued), Thomas J. Wiegand, Esquire, Kaitlin R. O'Donnell, Esquire, MoloLamken LLP, New York, NY, Eric R. Nitz, Esquire, Rayiner I. Hashem, Esquire, Jeffrey M. Klein, Esquire, MoloLamken LLP, Washington, DC, William T. Hangley, Esquire, Michele D. Hangley, Esquire, Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller, Philadelphia, PA, Linda S. Mullenix, Esquire, Austin, TX, for Appellants Alan Faneca; Roderick “Rock” Cartwright; Jeff Rohrer; Sean Considine.
David S. Coale, Esquire, Edward J. Dennis, Esquire, Kent D. Krabill, Esquire, Lynn Tillotson Pinker and Cox, Dallas, TX, for Appellant James Mayberry.
Before AMBRO, HARDIMAN, and NYGAARD, Circuit Judges.
AMBRO
, Circuit Judge.
| TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| I. | INTRODUCTION | 420 |
| II. | BACKGROUND | 421 |
| A. | Concussion Suits Are Brought Against the NFL | 421 | |
| B. | The Parties Reach a Settlement | 422 | |
| C. | The Proposed Settlement | 423 |
| 1. | Monetary Award Fund | 423 | ||
| 2. | Baseline Assessment Program | 424 | ||
| 3. | Education Fund | 425 | ||
| 4. | The Proposed Class | 425 |
| III. | JURISDICTION & STANDARD OF REVIEW | 425 |
| IV. | CLASS CERTIFICATION | 426 |
| A. | Numerosity | 426 | |
| B. | Commonality | 426 | |
| C. | Typicality | 427 | |
| D. | Adequacy of Representation | 428 |
| 1. | Class Counsel | 429 | ||
| 2. | Class Representatives | 430 | ||
| 3. | Conflicts of Interest | 431 |
| E. | Predominance | 434 | |
| F. | Superiority | 434 |
| V. | CLASS NOTICE | 435 |
| VI. | CLASS SETTLEMENT | 436 |
| A. | Presumption of Fairness | 436 | |
| B. | Girsh & Prudential Factors | 437 | |
| C. | Settlement's Treatment of CTE | 441 |
| VII. | ATTORNEYS' FEES | 444 |
| A. | Deferral of Fee Petition | 444 | |
| B. | Clear Sailing Provision | 447 |
| VIII. | CONCLUSION | 447 |
The National Football League (“NFL”) has agreed to resolve lawsuits brought by former players who alleged that the NFL failed to inform them of and protect them from the risks of concussions in football. The District Court approved a class action settlement that covered over 20,000 retired players and released all concussion-related claims against the NFL. Objectors have appealed that decision, arguing that class certification was improper and that the settlement was unfair. But after thorough review, we conclude that the District Court was right to certify the class and approve the settlement. Thus we affirm its decision in full.
In July 2011, 73 former professional football players sued the NFL and Riddell, Inc. in the Superior Court of California. Compl., Maxwell v. Nat'l Football League, No. BC465842 (Cal.Super.Ct. July 19, 2011). The retired players alleged that the NFL failed to take reasonable actions to protect them from the chronic risks of head injuries
in football. The players also claimed that Riddell, a manufacturer of sports equipment, should be liable for the defective design of helmets.
The NFL removed the case to federal court on the ground that the players' claims under state law were preempted by federal labor law. More lawsuits by retired players followed and the NFL moved under 28 U.S.C. § 1407
to consolidate the pending suits before a single judge for pretrial proceedings. In January 2012, the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation consolidated these cases before Judge Anita B. Brody in the ...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
In re Allergan Biocell Textured Breast Implant Prods. Liab. Litig.
... ... Plaintiffs Master Long Form Personal Injury Complaint ("PIC") (ECF No. 119) on non-preemption ... In re NFL Players Concussion Injury Litig. , 821 F.3d 410, 428 (3d ... ...
-
In re Suboxone (Buprenorphine Hydrochloride & Nalaxone) Antitrust Litig.
... ... of Suboxone Tablets suffered antitrust injury on a class-wide basis. Dr. Lamb has also ... or course of conduct." In re Nat'l Football League Players Concussion Injury Litig. , 821 ... ...
-
Skaar v. Wilkie
... ... personally have been injured, not that injury has been ... suffered by other, ... Orange" Prod. Liab. Litig. , 506 F.Supp. 762 ... (E.D.N.Y. 1980) ... 2014); see ... In re Nat'l Football League Players Concussion Injury ... Litig ... ...
-
Bear Creek Bible Church v. Equal Emp't Opportunity Comm'n
... ... First, the plaintiff must have suffered an injury in factan invasion of a legally protected ... (citing 571 F.Supp.3d 603 In re Nat'l Football League Players Concussion Inj. Litig. , 821 F.3d ... ...
-
Private Antitrust Suits
...(9th Cir. 2020) (duty exists independent of any objection by the class); In re National Football League Players Concussion Injury Litig., 821 F.3d 410, 445 (3d Cir. 2016) (protecting class members’ right to object or opt out of settlement to avoid potential waiver of fee objections); Rogers......
-
THE UNDEMOCRATIC CLASS ACTION.
...include In re Rhone-Poulenc Rorer, Inc., 51 F.3d 1293 (7th Cir. 1995), and In re Nat'l Football League Players Concussion Inj. Litig., 821 F.3d 410, 420 (3d Cir. 2016), as amended (May 2, (56.) Almendares, supra note 48, at 302. (57.) See generally id. (58.) Much of the previous work on thi......
-
NEGOTIATING LEGITIMACY: AN EVALUATION OF THE NEGOTIATION CLASS PROPOSAL.
...those variations are irrelevant to certification of a settlement class."); In re Nat'l Football League Players Concussion Inj. Litig., 821 F.3d 410, 434 (3d Cir. 2016) ("We are nonetheless 'more inclined to find the predominance test met in the settlement context.'" (quoting Sullivan v. DB ......
-
How Class Action Fees Work in the Eleventh Circuit
...Montessori Learning Centers v. Ashford Gear LLC, 662 F.3d 913, 917 (7th Cir. 2011)). See also In re NFL Players Concussion Injury Litig., 821 F.3d 410, 446 (3d Cir. 2016) ("[W]e are sympathetic to [these] concerns . . ."); In re Samsung Top-Load Washing Mach. Mktg., Sales Pracs. & Prod Liab......