Air Line Emp. Ass'n Intern. (A.L.P.A./A.F.L.-C.I.O.) v. Turner
Decision Date | 05 March 1974 |
Docket Number | No. 73--662,73--662 |
Parties | 85 L.R.R.M. (BNA) 2832, 73 Lab.Cas. P 53,316 AIR LINE EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION INTERNATIONAL (A.L.P.A./A.F.L.C.I.O.), Appellant, v. Evelyn W. TURNER, Appellee. |
Court | Florida District Court of Appeals |
Wyatt Johnson, Coral Gables, for appellant.
Horton & Perse, Lubow & Gary, Miami, for appellee.
Before BARKDULL, C.J., and PEARSON and CARROLL, JJ.
The appellee filed an action against the appellant for damages for slander. It was alleged that during a strike, the appellee, a member of the defendant union who was not in sympathy with the strike and had advocated a 'return to work' program, was maliciously criticized by an officer of the union, in a public meeting or meetings of the members thereof, as being a scab and a fink; and that appellee had received an anonymous telephone call threatening her with physical violence. She sought compensatory and punitive damages for the embarrassment, inconvenience, anxiety and fear suffered as a result thereof. She prevailed at trial and the verdict in favor of the appellee was for $3,000 compensatory damages and $175,000 punitive damages. Judgment was entered thereon and the defendant appealed.
The appellant makes a strong argument that denunciation of the appellee by the union was justified and that the words or terms used in denouncing her at the union meeting were not libelous, because they were the terms of the trade by which a member acting as had the appellee is customarily designated. Based thereon, the appellant argues the court erred in denying its motion to dismiss the complaint and motion for directed verdict. On consideration thereof we hold the court did not err in those respects.
We have also considered, and find to be without merit, the appellant's argument that the charge to the jury with relation to malice was contradictory.
However, we find merit in the contention of the appellant that the award of punitive damages was excessive and beyond any reasonable relation to the compensatory damages awarded.
The question of whether punitive damages must bear some reasonable relation to the amount of the actual (compensatory) damages awarded does not appear to have been definitely determined in the law of Florida.
The point has been referred to in several federal court decisions involving cases originating in Florida. In Scalise v. National Utility Service, 5 Cir. 1941, 120 F.2d 938, 941, the Court said: 'In Florida as in the federal courts, the giving of punitive damages is not dependent upon, nor must it bear any relation to, the allowance of actual damages.' Later, speaking through the same judge who authored the opinion in the Scalise case, that court applied the contrary rule to a case originating in Florida, saying: '* * * exemplary to punitive damages awarded must bear some, though not an exact relation to actual damages.' That pronouncement was followed in a federal district court decision in Florida (Ging v. American Liberty Insurance Company, D.C., N.D.Fla.1968, 293 F.Supp. 756, 760) where the court said: The...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Wackenhut Corp. v. Canty
...to the compensatory damages awarded and which is excessively out of relation to compensatory damages. Air Line Employees Association International v. Turner, Fla.App.1974, 291 So.2d 670; Lan-Chile Airlines, Inc. v. Rodriguez, Fla.App.1974, 296 So.2d 498." Wackenhut, supra, at An unusual cir......
-
Lassiter v. International Union of Operating Engineers
...there should be some reasonable, albeit imprecise, relationship between punitive and compensatory damages. Air Line Employees Ass'n Int. v. Turner, 291 So.2d 670 (3d D.C.A. Fla.1974); Crowell-Collier Pub. Co. v. Caldwell, 170 F.2d 941 (5th Cir. 1948); Hutchinson v. Lott, 110 So.2d 442 (1st ......
-
Owner's Adjustment Bureau, Inc. v. Ott
...a libel per se as a matter of law. Campbell v. Jacksonville Kennel Club, 66 So.2d 495 (Fla. 1953); Air Line Employees Association International v. Turner, 291 So.2d 670 (Fla. 3d DCA 1974); Carter v. Sterling Finance Co., 132 So.2d 430 (Fla. 1st DCA 1961). See Sharp v. Bussey, 137 Fla. 96, 1......
-
Bobenhausen v. Cassat Ave. Mobile Homes, Inc., BB--468
...award of $25,000.00 compensatory damages was held sufficient to justify $75,000.00 punitive damages. In Airline Employees Ass'n. Internat'l. v. Turner, 291 So.2d 670 (Fla.3rd DCA 1974), an award of $175,000.00 punitive damages based on $3,000.00 compensatory damages was reduced to $30,000.0......