American Trust Co. v. Catawba Sales & Processing Co., 524
Decision Date | 30 June 1955 |
Docket Number | No. 524,524 |
Court | North Carolina Supreme Court |
Parties | AMERICAN TRUST COMPANY, Executor and Trustee under the Last Will and Testament and Estate of Thomas Lee Wilson, Sr., v. CATAWBA SALES & PROCESSING COMPANY, a corporation. |
R. Gregg Cherry, Gastonia, Helms & Mulliss, Fred B. Helms and John D. Hicks, Charlotte, for plaintiff, appellee.
Pierce & Blakeney, Charlotte, for defendant, appellant.
The complaint alleges two causes of action.
First Cause of Action.
This is a summary of the material allegations of the firs cause of action--the numbering of the paragraphs is ours:
One. The American Trust Company, the plaintiff and hereafter called the Trust Company, brought this action as executor and trustee under the last will and testament of Thomas Lee Wilson, Sr., who died on 30 March 1951. This action is for the recovery of monies due under three agreements involving three parties. One, the late Thomas Lee Wilson, Sr. (hereafter called Wilson), of Gastonia. Two, Catawba Sales & Processing Co. (hereafter called Catawba), a North Carolina corporation with its principal place of business in Gastonia. Three, Bowling Green Spinning Co. (hereafter called Bowling Green), a South Carolina corporation having its principal place of business at Bowling Green, South Carolina.
Two. Bowling Green was engaged in the manufacture and sale of textile goods. Prior to 1950 Wilson had been in charge of the management and sales of Bowling Green, and through his efforts he had developed it from an insolvent condition to a profitable business in 1950. In 1950 Wilson's health became impaired. At the time Bowling Green had 645 shares of capital stock outstanding, and Wilson and his family owned 324 of these shares.
Three. After Wilson's health became impaired, he desired to provide good management and adequate sales service for Bowling Green. To effectuate his desire he sold 162 shares of the capital stock of Bowling Green to Catawba, and the three contracts set forth below were executed and delivered simultaneously in Gaston County First Contract.
This contract, hereafter called the 'Sales Agreement,' was entered into on 22 August 1950 by and between Bowling Green, party of the first part, and Catawba, party of the second part. It gave Catawba the exclusive selling rights of the entire production of Bowling Green on a 5% commission, to be paid to Catawba, whether the goods were sold by Catawba or not--the agreement being that Catawba will be paid a 5% commission on the entire sales of Bowling Green. This contract further provides:
'(3) This contract shall become effective August 22, 1950; and shall continue in effect so long as Catawba Sales & Processing Company and Thomas L. Wilson, Sr., or his executors, administrators, donees, legatees, widow, next of kin or other persons, firms, or corporations claiming under or through the said Thomas L. Wilson, Sr., own the majority of the outstanding stock in Bowling Green Spinning Company.'
Second Contract.
This contract, hereafter called the 'Management and Voting Control Agreement,' was entered into on 22 August 1950, by and between Catawba, party of the first part, and Wilson, party of the second part. After stating that Bowling Green has 645 shares of capital stock outstanding, and that Wilson and Catawba own each 162 shares of this stock, it provides as follows:
'(1) That Catawba Sales & Processing Company through its officers and agents shall manage and operate the mill, plant and business of Bowling Green Spinning Company, for such time as the said Catawba Sales & Processing Company and Thomas L. Wilson, Sr., or his executors, administrators, legatees, next of kin, widow or donees, own the majority of the outstanding stock in Bowling Green Spinning Company.
'(2) During the life of Thomas L. Wilson, Sr., Catawba Sales & Processing Company shall be, and it hereby is, given the right to vote the 162 shares of stock in the aforesaid corporation owned by Thomas L. Wilson, Sr.; and upon the death of the said Thomas L. Wilson, Sr., the said Catawba Sales & Processing Company shall continue to vote the said 162 shares owned by the said Thomas L. Wilson, Sr. at the time of his death, and continue to operate and manage the aforesaid plant, mill and business of Bowling Green Spinning Company, so long as the said 162 shares of stock in the said corporation is owned by the executors, administrators, legatees, next of kin, widow or donees of the said Thomas L. Wilson, Sr.
Third Contract.
This contract was entered into on 22 August 1950, by and between Catawba, party of the first part, and Wilson, party of the second part. These are its provisions:
'Witnesseth, That Whereas, Catawba Sales & Processing Company has a contract with Bowling Green Spinning Company, a corporation of Bowling Green, South Carolina, dated August 22, 1950, by the terms of which the said Bowling Green Spinning Company has given to the Catawba Sales & Processing Company the exclusive selling of the entire production of the plant of Bowling Green Spinning Company on a straight five (5%) per cent commission, and the Catawba Sales & Processing Company has agreed to devote whatever time is necessary to selling the said production of Bowling Green Spinning Company; and
'Whereas, Thomas L. Wilson, Sr. has agreed to advise the Catawba Sales & Processing Company in connection with its selling efforts and to assist it in establishing outputs of a satisfactory and permanent character for the production of the said Bowling Green Spinning Company;
'Now, Therefore, for and in consideration of the mutual covenants herein contained, It Is Agreed:
'(1) That Catawba Sales & Processing Company will pay to Thomas L. Wilson, Sr. thirty (30%) per cent of all such selling commissions as may be paid by Bowling Green Spinning Company to the Catawba Sales & Processing Company.
'(2) Thomas L. Wilson, Sr. agrees to advise the said Catawba Sales & Processing Company and to assist it in an advisory capacity in selling the production of the aforesaid Bowling Green Spinning Company.
Four. Since 22 August 1950 the officers and directors of Bowling Green and Catawba have had full knowledge of the three agreements set forth above. Since 1949, and now, D. R. LaFar, Jr. has been President and Treasurer, Dan S. LaFar, Vice-President and Secretary, and Robert E. Caldwell,...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Snyder v. Freeman
... ... at least three such theories: (1) breach of trust by defendants as directors of General Aviation; ... v. Phoenix Indemnity Co., 241 N.C. 473, 478, 85 S.E.2d 677, 680 (1955), ... 298, 102 S.E. 389 (1920); Anderson v. American Suburban Corp., 155 N.C. 131, 71 S.E. 211 (1911) ... v. Catawba Sales & Processing Co., 242 N.C. 370, 88 S.E.2d ... ...
-
Battleground Veterinary Hospital, P.C. v. McGeough
... ... duties to Plaintiffs by, among other things, co-opting resources and time that should have been ... proprietary information "in confidence and trust" and to not disclose it either during her ... Am. Trust Co. v. Catawba Sales & Processing Co. , 242 N.C. 370, 380, 88 ... ...
-
CF Industries, Inc. v. Transcontinental Gas Pipe Line Corp., C-C-77-131.
... ... Commission did not cover direct retail sales of gas. Accordingly, Transco participated with ... Reed Supply Co., 277 N.C. 119, 177 S.E.2d 273 (1970). Vogel, ... American Trust Co. v. Catawba Sales & Processing Co., 242 ... ...
-
Vogel v. Reed Supply Co.
... ... 453, 177 S.E. 335.' American Trust Co. v. Catawba Sales & Processing Co., 242 ... ...