Boshell v. Phillips

• Decision Date: 01 June 1922
• Docket Number: 6 Div. 610.
• Citation: 93 So. 576,207 Ala. 628
• Parties: BOSHELL v. PHILLIPS.
• Court: Alabama Supreme Court

93 So. 576

207 Ala. 628

BOSHELL v. PHILLIPS.

6 Div. 610.

Supreme Court of Alabama

June 1, 1922

Appeal from Circuit Court, Walker County; J. J. Curtis, Judge.

Bill by W. R. Boshell against J. M. Phillips. From a decree sustaining demurrer to the bill, complainant appeals. Appeal dismissed.

John S Stone, of Birmingham, and Ray & Cooner, of Jasper, for appellant.

Bankhead & Bankhead and A. F. Fite, all of Jasper, for appellee.

MILLER J.

This bill of complaint was filed by W. R. Boshell against J. M Phillips. Demurrers were sustained to the original bill on May 24, 1921. The bill was afterwards amended twice. Demurrers were filed to the bill as last amended. These demurrers were by the court sustained on October 7, 1921. From this decree, rendered October 7, 1921, sustaining demurrers to the bill as amended, the complainant appeals and assigns it as error.

The clerk in his certificate states "the complainant on December 12, 1921, took an appeal to the Supreme Court of Alabama," and "that W. R. Boshell filed security for cost of appeal to the Supreme Court on the 12th day of December, 1921," and gives the names of the sureties on the appeal bond. The register must certify the fact that such appeal was taken, and the time when, as a part of the record which gives the Supreme Court jurisdiction of the case. Sections 2837 and 2848, Code 1907.

Appeals from the circuit court, in equity, may be taken by giving security for costs of the appeal to be approved by the clerk or register or court. This appeal was taken in that way. Act approved September 22, 1915; Gen. Acts 1915, p. 711, amended by Gen. Acts 1919, p. 84. Appeals from decrees rendered by the circuit court in equity sustaining or overruling demurrers to a bill in equity lies to the Supreme Court, if taken within 30 days from the rendition thereof. Section 2838, Code 1907, amended by Gen. Acts 1915, p. 137.

This decree was rendered and enrolled October 7, 1921; the register certifies the appeal was taken, and appeal bond for cost approved on December 12, 1921. This was more than 30 days after the decree sustaining the demurrers to the bill as amended was rendered, and this court has no jurisdiction of this cause. The appeal was taken too late; this court is without jurisdiction to consider it, and it must be dismissed. Blackburn v. Huber Mfg. Co., 135 Ala. 598, 33 So. 160; Lide v. Parker, 132 Ala. 222, 31 So. 360; Dennis v. Currie, 142 Ala. 637, 38 So. 802; Rowell v. State, 166 Ala. 44, 52 So. 310; Bickley v. Hays, 183 Ala. 506, 62 So. 767.

The parties by their attorneys agree in writing, which is on file in the cause, to make no motion to dismiss the appeal, because the appeal bond was not filed in time, but agree to request this court to consider the case as if appeal was taken in time, as the parties desire the cause settled on the merits.

Appeals must be taken to this court within the time fixed by statut...