Boykin v. Bissette, 247

• Decision Date: 09 October 1963
• Docket Number: No. 247,247
• Citation: 132 S.E.2d 616,260 N.C. 295
• Parties: Doretha BOYKIN, Administratrix of the Estate of Linda Louise Burnette, Deceased, v. Beulah Burnette BISSETTE and Johnnie P. Harris.
• Court: North Carolina Supreme Court

Page 616

132 S.E.2d 616

260 N.C. 295

Doretha BOYKIN, Administratrix of the Estate of Linda Louise Burnette, Deceased, v. Beulah Burnette BISSETTE and Johnnie P. Harris.

No. 247

Supreme Court of North Carolina.

Oct. 9, 1963

Robert A. Farris and Allen G. Thomas by Allen G. Thomas, Wilson, for plaintiff-appellant.

Narron, Holdford & Holdford by Talmadge Narron, Wilson, for defendant-appellee.

PARKER, Justice.

Plaintiff's evidence considered in the light most favorable to her (Bridges v. Graham, 246 N.C. 371, 98 S.E.2d 492) tends to show the following:

About 5:30 p. m. on 28 June 1960 defendant Beulah Burnette Bissette was driving a Ford automobile, owned by defendant Johnnie P. Harris, in a westerly direction on Highway 264 about one and one-half miles west of Middlesex. Mrs. Cleo Harris, wife of Johnnie P. Harris, was sitting in the middle on the front seat. Sitting on her right on the front seat was Mrs. Marie Burnette, who was holding in her lap her daughter Linda Louise Burnette, a healthy baby two months eleven days old. Three boys were sitting on the back seat. About one and one-half miles west of Middlesex the pavement on the highway is about 24 feet wide, with dirt shoulders on each side about 10 feet wide. At this point the highway is straight and hilly. The weather was clear and the pavement was dry.

After passing through Middlesex, Beulah Burnette Bissette, driving at a speed of about 35 to 40 miles an hour, tried two or three times to pass a red pickup truck traveling ahead. Mrs. Marie Burnette testified:

'After leaving Middlesex, I recall seeing a red pickup truck ahead of us. We followed him a mile or a mile and a half. She started to pass him three times, I think, and on the third time we started to pass him--every time we would start to pass him, he'd doodle out in front of us. And the third time we tried to pass him, he started over on our side, and Beulah, she went over to the left. She drove it over to the lefthand side, on the side of the dirt. The car started down the embankment on the side of the road, it went across the embankment. After it left the road, we started down that hill and hit a tree. * * * When Mrs. Bissette blew her horn for the very first time, they were side by side. The truck and car were side by side. She had not blown the horn at all before then. She had not ever blown the horn when she had attempted to pass on the two prior occasions.'

Mrs. Cleo Harris testified:

'We followed that truck a mile or a little over. She attempted to pass that truck two or three times. Then she started to pass this truck and as we got at him to pass him, the red truck was coming towards us across the center line into the left lane at that point. Beulah Burnette Bissette blowed her horn as we got beside the truck because I saw the wheels of the truck. After the truck came over to the left and she blew her horn; I don't remember nothing else; I was injured in the accident. After I saw the red truck coming over to the left I did not feel the car in which I was riding slow down or brake down any. I didn't feel nothing only when we hit the tree. When she tried to pass the truck two or three times before that, the red truck was making little doodles in the road, cross the center line. By making a motion with my hand, I am indicating that the truck was weaving across the road.'

When Beulah Burnette Bissette, immediately before her automobile left the road and hit the tree, drove to the left to pass the red pickup truck ahead, she was traveling down a steep hill, and there was no approaching traffic. Just as she approached the pickup truck to pass, it came across the white line into her lane of traffic. She cut her automobile to the left, and it left the highway, went down an embankment, and crashed into a tree. Tracks leading from the automobile at the tree to the pavement on the highway measured about 215 feet.

When the automobile hit the tree, its front was severely damaged. As a result of the automobile crashing into the tree, the baby Linda Louise Burnette sustained a fractured skull, which caused her death about two hours later. Mrs. Cleo Harris and Mrs. Marie Burnette sustained severe injuries in the wreck, requiring several months' hospitalization for each.

The driver of the red pickup truck did not stop. He has never been discovered or identified.

There is nothing in the record to indicate that Beulah Burnette Bissette was driving in a business or residential district as defined in G.S. §§ 20-38(a) and (w)1, at any place she attempted to overtake and pass the pickup truck ahead; in fact the record indicates it was open country. G.S. § 20-149(b) states: 'The driver of an overtaking motor vehicle not within a business or residence district, as herein defined, shall give audible warning with his horn or other warning device before passing or attempting to pass a...