Brooks v. South Broward Hospital Dist., 74-213
| Decision Date | 19 December 1975 |
| Docket Number | No. 74-213,74-213 |
| Citation | 325 So.2d 479 |
| Parties | Laura BROOKS, Appellant, v. SOUTH BROWARD HOSPITAL DISTRICT, a special tax district d/b/a Memorial Hospital, et al., Appellees. |
| Court | Florida District Court of Appeals |
Appeal from the Circuit Court for Broward County; John G. Ferris, Judge.
Jeanne Heyward, and Harold West, of Meltzer, West, Friesner & Goldman, Miami, for appellant.
Rex Conrad of Fleming, O'Bryan & Fleming, Fort Lauderdale, for appellees South Broward Hospital District and Continental Ins. Co.
The tragic facts of this case can be stated quite succinctly. Appellant, while a patient in the appellee-hospital delivered her baby, which, being premature, expired the following day. No negligence is charged to the hospital for the death of the child. However, the hospital through its negligence misplaced and never again located the child's body, as a result of which appellant suffered severe mental anguish and emotional disturbance. There was no evidence of any physical impact or physical injury to appellant, nor any evidence of wantonness, wilfullness or malice on the part of appellee-hospital. Although permitting the case to go to the jury, the court reserved ruling on the hospital's motion for directed verdict and subsequently, after the jury had returned a verdict for the plaintiff, the court granted the defendant-hospital's motion for judgment N.O.V. Appellant assigns that order as error and appellees cross-assign error to one of the jury instructions.
In a line of cases commencing with Dunahoo v. Bess, 146 Fla. 182, 200 So. 541 (1941) and culminating in Gilliam v. Stewart, 291 So.2d 593 (Fla.1974), the courts of this state have consistently held that there can be no recovery for mental anguish or emotional distress unaccompanied by any physical impact or physical injury to the plaintiff, in the absence of wantonness, wilfullness or malice. See, e.g., Herlong Aviation, Inc. v. Johnson, 291 So.2d 603 (Fla.1974); Crane v. Loftin, 70 So.2d 574 (Fla.1954); Kirksey v. Jernigan, 45 So.2d 188, 17 A.L.R.2d 766 (Fla.1950); Carter v. Lake Wales Hospital Association, Inc., 213 So.2d 898 (2nd DCA Fla.1968); Kimple v. Riedel, 133 So.2d 437 (2nd DCA Fla.1961).
We are unable to make any meaningful distinction between the facts of this case and those of the several cases cited above insofar as application of this principle of law is concerned. We therefore conclude that ...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Gonzalez v. Metropolitan Dade County Public Health Trust, 92-1462
...47 (Fla. 3d DCA 1979); Estate of Harper v. Orlando Funeral Home, Inc., 366 So.2d 126 (Fla. 1st DCA 1979); Brooks v. South Broward Hosp. Dist., 325 So.2d 479 (Fla. 4th DCA 1975), cert. denied, 341 So.2d 290 (Fla.1976); Jackson v. Rupp, 228 So.2d 916 (Fla. 4th DCA 1969), approved, 238 So.2d 8......
-
Langbehn v. Public Health Trust of Miami-Dade, Case No. 08-21813-CIV.
...distress by emergency room patient who was bitten by spider, where bite itself was not actionable), Brooks v. South Broward Hospital District, 325 So.2d 479-80 (Fla. 4th DCA 1975) (applying impact rule to bar negligence claim by parents of deceased newborn child against hospital for having ......
-
Catania v. Eastern Airlines, Inc.
...was properly dismissed. See Steiner and Munach, P. A. v. Williams, 334 So.2d 39 (Fla. 3d DCA 1976); and Brooks v. South Broward Hospital District, 325 So.2d 479 (Fla. 4th DCA 1975). A fourth count (found only in plaintiff Duerr's complaint) claims damages because the defendant "shadowed" Du......
-
Friedman v. Mutual Broadcasting System, 79-1217
...Jernigan, 45 So.2d 188 (Fla.1950); Slocum v. Food Fair Stores of Florida, Inc., 100 So.2d 396 (Fla.1958); Brooks v. South Broward Hospital District, 325 So.2d 479 (Fla.4th DCA 1975); Steiner and Munach v. Williams, 334 So.2d 39 (Fla.3d DCA 1976); Gellert v. Eastern Air Lines, Inc., 370 So.2......