Bryan v. Hubbard
Decision Date | 10 October 2008 |
Docket Number | 1071662.,1071590. |
Parties | Raymond C. BRYAN et al. v. Mike HUBBARD and Gene Howard. Gene Howard v. Raymond C. Bryan et al. |
Court | Alabama Supreme Court |
Algert S. Agricola, Jr., of Ryals, Plummer, Donaldson, Agricola & Smith, P.C., Montgomery, for appellants/cross-appellees Raymond C. Bryan, Rodney James, and Jonathan Thompkins.
Albert L. Jordan of Wallace, Jordan, Ratliff & Brandt, L.L.C., Birmingham; and Christopher M. Hopkins of Campbell & Hopkins, Anniston, for appellee/cross-appellant Gene Howard.
Edward S. Allen, Ed R. Haden, and Aaron L. Dettling of Balch & Bingham, LLP, Birmingham, for appellee Mike Hubbard.
This is an expedited appeal and cross-appeal. Raymond C. Bryan, Rodney James, and Jonathon Thompkins appeal from a summary judgment in favor of Mike Hubbard and Gene Howard, upholding the Alabama Republican Party's revocation of Bryan's certificate of nomination as a candidate for judicial office. Howard cross-appeals, arguing that the summary judgment is not a final judgment. We affirm in case no. 1071590 and dismiss the cross-appeal in case no. 1071662.
On April 4, 2008, Bryan, a licensed attorney in Alabama residing in the Seventh Judicial Circuit, filed a candidate-qualifying form with the Alabama Republican Party formally declaring his intention to seek election to the office of circuit judge of the Seventh Judicial Circuit, place 4. The Seventh Judicial Circuit comprises Calhoun and Cleburne Counties. James and Thompkins are registered voters who reside in the Seventh Judicial Circuit. Both James and Thompkins voted for Bryan in the Republican Party primary election. Hubbard is the chairman of the Alabama Republican Party executive committee. Howard is a registered voter who resides in the Seventh Judicial Circuit and who voted for Bryan's opponent and the incumbent judge, Mannon Bankson, Jr., in the Republican Party primary election.
Bryan and Bankson were certified to the secretary of state's office as candidates for the office of circuit judge of the Seventh Judicial Circuit by the Alabama Republican Party for placement on the ballot for the primary election set for June 3, 2008. Both names appeared on the Republican Party primary-election ballot. No candidate qualified to run for the judgeship in the Democratic Party primary election.
On May 29, 2008, five days before the primary election, Bryan mailed to the secretary of state's office by certified mail, return receipt requested, his pre-election report of campaign contributions and expenditures required by the Fair Campaign Practices Act, § 17-5-1 et seq., Ala.Code 1975 (hereinafter "the FCPA"). Bryan's report arrived at the United States post office in Montgomery at 5:14 a.m. on Monday, June 2, 2008. June 2, 2008, was a state holiday, and no one from the secretary of state's office retrieved the mail from the post office that day. Bryan's report was delivered to the secretary of state's office at 7:42 a.m. on June 3, 2008. Bryan's report was posted on the secretary of state's Web site later that same day.
On June 13, 2008, Hubbard, as chairman of the Alabama Republican Party executive committee, certified the vote totals from the June 3, 2008, Republican primary election: Bryan received 3,051 votes and Bankson received 2,838 votes. On that same day, Bankson wrote a letter to Hubbard, which stated:
Bryan received a telephone call from someone in Hubbard's office, informing him of the receipt by the Alabama Republican Party of Bankson's statement of election contest. Bryan responded to the telephone call by sending a letter to Hubbard on June 16, 2008. That letter stated:
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Rice v. Chapman
...(Ala.1997); Harvey v. City of Oneonta, 715 So.2d 779 (Ala.1998); Etheridge v. State of Alabama, 730 So.2d 1179 (Ala.1999); Bryan v. Hubbard, 6 So.3d 491 (Ala.2008); Roper v. Rhodes, 988 So.2d 471 (Ala.2008); and Wood v. Booth, 990 So.2d 314 (Ala.2008). 6 The Court also notes that it is undi......
-
Sears v. McCrory, No. 1080728 (Ala. 12/18/2009), 1080728
...He also alleges that none of the reports filed by McCrory met this requirement. Page 11 However, McCrory, quoting Bryan v. Hubbard, 6 So. 3d 491, 499 (Ala. 2008), argues that "[t]he legislature's primary purpose in enacting the FCPA was to require candidates for public office in Alabama to ......
-
SEARS v. McCRORY
...and complete. He also alleges that none of the reports filed by McCrory met this requirement. However, McCrory, quoting Bryan v. Hubbard, 6 So.3d 491, 499 (Ala.2008), argues that "[t]he legislature's primary purpose in enacting the FCPA was to require candidates for public office in Alabama......