Burns v. Gardner, 245
| Decision Date | 10 October 1956 |
| Docket Number | No. 245,245 |
| Citation | 94 S.E.2d 591,244 N.C. 602 |
| Parties | Mrs. Margaret T. BURNS, Administratrix of the Estate of Beverly J. Burns, Deceased, v. A. H. GARDNER and wife, Leila S. Gardner. |
| Court | North Carolina Supreme Court |
Guy T. Carswell and George J. Miller, Charlotte, for plaintiff, appellant.
Charles W. Bundy, Charlotte, for defendants, appellees.
When the cause was here on former appeal, three members of the Court were of opinion that plaintiff's allegations, liberally construed, sufficiently alleged negligence to justify the overruling of the demurrer. Upon consideration of plaintiff's evidence, we are unanimously of the opinion that such evidence, taken in the light most favorable to plaintiff, is insufficient to warrant submission to the jury of an issue as to actionable negligence of defendants.
Lovin v. Hamlet, 243 N.C. 399, 402, 90 S.E. 2d 760, 763, and cases cited.
Nothing appears in the evidence to show that children played in or about defendants' pond or lake with their permission, express or implied. The testimony of certain school children, witnesses for plaintiff, who had trespassed on defendants' premises on certain occasions to play in or about the pond or lake, shows plainly that whenever they were caught by defendants they were warned of the danger and ordered to keep away. Their testimony is to the effect that they knew they had no business in or about the pond or lake and made their visits when defendants were away from home or otherwise unaware of their presence.
The drowning of the child upon stepping into the pond or lake stirs the sympathetic concern of all; but, upon the evidence offered, it does not appear that this tragedy can be attributed to actionable negligence on the part of the defendants. Hence, the judgment of involuntary nonsuit must be affirmed.
Affirmed.
JOHNSON, J., not sitting.
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Bell v. Page, 35
...is not an act of negligence to do so.' Lovin v. Town of Hamlet, 243 N.C. 399, 402, 90 S.E.2d 760, 763, and cases cited; Burns v. Gardner, 244 N.C. 602, 94 S.E.2d 591. Upon the present record, whether the court erred in entering judgment of involuntary nonsuit depends upon whether the eviden......
-
McLean v. Ward, 68SC200
...they not be permitted to do so and had warned their parents to keep them away. This case is controlled by the decision in Burns v. Gardner, 244 N.C. 602, 94 S.E.2d 591, wherein it is 'The drowning of the child upon stepping into the pond or lake stirs the sympathetic concern of all; but, up......
- Schoenith v. Town & Country Realty Co., 236