SEA CABINS v. City of North Myrtle Beach
Decision Date | 04 October 1999 |
Docket Number | No. 3050.,3050. |
Citation | 337 S.C. 380,523 S.E.2d 193 |
Court | South Carolina Court of Appeals |
Parties | SEA CABINS ON THE OCEAN IV HOMEOWNERS ASSOCITION, INC., Grand Strand Realty, Gerald W. Arney, Mary P. Arney, Bobby McLean, Thelma McLean, Thomas P. Woodruff, Virginia C. Woodruff, Ronald L. Peck, Philip H. Morris, Linda M. Morris, Jack L. Tyson, Shirley S. Tyson, Timmy R. Helms, Thomas Minton, Frank R. Buoniconti, Jeanne L. Buoniconti, Robert A. DeSimone, Jim F. Moore, Jo Mingas Moore, William R. Kennedy, Jr., Hilda B. Kennedy, Steve A. Brock, Gary W. Alphin, W.F. Tugwell, Jr., Ronald D. Hall, Bath Investments Properties, c/o Thomas Myers; David L. Saunders, Ray A. Bolick, Nancy P. Bolick, Elizabeth Kandler Elliott f/k/a Elizabeth A. Kandler, Jimmy L. Love, Etta Love, Charles A. Ginardi, Carol W. Ginardi, Russell L. Pinkelton, R. Steve Metcalf, Ray E. Jennings, L. Derek Herring, William P. Brown, J.P. Batten, Jr., Tony Sherrill, Carolyn H. Sherrill, Joseph M. Baker, Martha. K. Baker, Don Ferrell, Nancy C. Williamson, Alan H. Branan, Francis G. Logue, Patricia J. Logue, Dominick Mauriello Trust f/k/a Dominick Mauriello and Marjorie Mauriello, John W. Blake, Sharon D. Blake, Bobby Young, Forrest D. Bricker, Robert E. Sease, Jane A. Sease, Howard E. Virkler, Macy L. Hoyle (died 9/13/90), Jane Brendel, Richard Brendel, Stacy Jean Snyder, Fred M. Snyder, Joyce Snyder, Daniel E. Wilson, Wanda M. Wilson, Bobby J. Garrison, Barbara S. Garrison, Hambry Brothers, Inc., Vera G.M. Hankin, Sarah S. McLean, A.F. McLean, Jr., (as trustee for William H. McLean), Estate of Sarah S. McLean f/k/a Sarah S. McLean, Mellon Bank, Phillips E. Powell, Diane F. Powell, Joseph A. Galiano, Denise Galiano, Vincient and Catherine Pastore; Vincient, Jennifer, and Deigo Monticciolo, Charles H. Hammond, J.E. Bobbit, Jr., Wallace Webster Quate, Jr., William Maegruder, Peggy Maegruder, George W. Joyce, Sara Murray Joyce, Reggie Keith Safrit, Martha Stirewalt Safrit, Beach Properties/Linwood Jackson/James R. Bullock, Jr.; Franwell, a partnership, Edward C. McGimsey, Partner, c/o Morganton Hardware Co.; James J. Linden, Alice C. Linden, Kirkland P. Broom, Ann S. Broom, John R. Henderson, Mary Ann Henderson, James T. Grier, Janet R. Grier, Emma H. Valentine, Francisco Valentine, Johnny C. Whitmore, Emma G. Whitmore, Guy A. Walters, Jr., Ann H. Walters, Felder W. West, Jack N. Morris, John E. Varol, Ralph Varol, Garland J. Candle, Tony R. Craven, Doloris Craven, Grady Oliver, Carol Oliver, Robert C. Barry, Jr., Jimmie R. Foxx, Eva Lewis, Richardo F. Cecchini, Nilda E. Cecchini, Anthony P. Sapienza. Anne M. Sapienza, Clyde R. Randal, Jean M. Randal, Bernard J. Milano, Mary N. Milano, c/o PMM Company, David Steele Jarrett, Kathy Saunders Jarrett, Charles Weir, James Vernon Gross, Dorothy D. Gross, David R. Eva, Judith E. Eva, (Estate of Sarah S. McLean f/k/a Sarah S. McLean), Richard Adams, Sherrell Dennis Hedrick, Galileo D. Casquejo, Thomas M. Clayton, Linda B. Clayton, Russell L. Pinkelton, Judy Pinkelton, Stan Halpern, William D. Powell, Patsy Powell, Jerry L. Calvert, Ruth C. Calvert, W.B. Seddinger, Edward Bell, Jr., Mary Lee M. Bell, Myles G. Keery, Sabra L. Keery, Fleming, Francis & Associates, Burl Kenneth Flemming, Alma Jean Flemming, David Frances, Betty L. Frances, c/o Mr. David L. Francis, Larry Peak, James R. McCracken, Max R. Schmidt, Alice Schmidt, Delores Randall, Hambry Brothers Concrete, Inc., Richard Link, Ray W. Welsh, Wendy C. Welsh, Bobby L. Tuttle, Thomas T. Archer, Martha C. Archer, Ted D. Fuller, Nancy K. Fuller, Danny Edwards, Sandra Edwards, Edwin T. Yarborough, Suzanne C. Yarborough, Epworth Children's Home, Dr. A .W. Macklin, James A. Pierce, III, c/o Marietta Pallet Company, E. Wayne Harper, Brabston B. Harper, John G. Hansen, Richard Adams, James H. Kirk, Agnes C. Kirk, W. James Dubose, Henry Voznick, Jean H. Voznick, Thomas F. Conn, Madeline Conn, Arlon O. Jones, Charles E. Ramsey, John M. McCoy, Gerald L. Fowler, William R. McAdams, Jerry E. Moats, Fowler Moats, Inc., Chester F. D'Agostina, Janis R. D'Agostina, Wall-Johnson, Leon W. Wall, Joyce B. Wall, A. Gray Johnson, Jo Ann R. Johnson, Jerry McKee, Donna McKee, James E. Messick, Jr., Jean M. Messick, Arnold M. Schwartz, Janice M. Schwartz, Jing Ming Liu, Ellie Y. Lao, Warren Heiser, Mary Ann Heiser, Earl R. Betts, Jr., Carol A. Betts, John R. Stass, Barbara J. Stass, Hardiena J. Smith as personal representative of William B. Smith, Jack M. Ladford, Ila L. Carver, Walter W. Little, Doris H. Russ, Kenneth F. Spainhour, Carolina A. Spainhour, John R. Spies, Alice L. Spies, Randall David Torcasi, Robert Q. Yeckley, Carl S. Sigmon, Louie O. Lavender, Jr., Noble Vaughn, Jr., Cornelia L. Vaughn, Larry D. Procter, Kara P. Proctor, Roy L. Lynam, Donna M. Lynam, Jeffrey Huber, Deborah J. Huber, Emmett Floyd, Kathy Floyd, James Russell Millner, Donald C. Winterich, Richard R. Steinke, Lewis B. Keener, LaFayette F. Decker, Cecelia M. Decker, Anthony L. Buoniconti, Margaret A. Buoniconti, Calvin L. Palmer, Jr., Rosie B. Palmer, Duane Knight, Sharon G. Knight, W. Glenn Jenkins, Charm House Design, Stephen L. Nader, William O. Reeside, Jane S. Reeside, Michael Ray, Cynthia N. Ray, Don A. Ray, Eleanor J. Ray, Cranston Blanks, Jr., Margaret L. Blanks, J.R. Gibbons, Gladys Gibbons, R.M. Glasscox, Cheryl Glasscox, Haracio P. and Martha A. Moreno-Compos, Gerald Hull, Emma J. Hull, James B. Davenport, Carolina Land Company, George E. Wells, Robert W. Braam, Maurice W. Brady, Ronald Bittles, Florence Bittles, David Whitley, Michael G. Carovillano, Judith A. Carovillano, John Petrozzi, Thomas F. Murtha, Dorothy A. Murtha, John F. Quinn, Jane H. Quinn, Presbyterian College, c/o Bailey Bank, George W. Wilson, Mark Wilson, Donald M. Bryant, Sandra B. Bryant, Jack Holsclaw, Mary H. Clarke, Valerie H. McRary, Gene S. Clarke, Thomas B. McRary, c/o Skyland Furniture Shoppe, Gerald W. Edmonds, Doris A. Edmonds, Jack S. Brown, Talma L. Brown, David T. McLaughlin, Carol H. McLaughlin, Harry Whitener, Eva S. Whitener, William J. Brennan, Gracia BJ. Brennan, Jerry R. Sutherland, Jo Ann Sutherland, L.D. Austin Company, Randolph Jones, Frances Jones, Seigfried Abrahams, Harold Langenderfer, Joan M. Langenderfer, Delbert L. and Marianne C. Wolcott, William B. Seddinger, William Harnett, W. Nelson Lewis, Barbara Craven; Helen, Gene, Laurie and Teresia Maye, R.A. Elmore, III, Judy A. Elmore, Rodney Thompson, Mark Cosgrove, Evelyn Cosgrove, Robert Brown, Danny G. Turner, Elaine M. Turner, Harry Anedisian, Louis I. Anedisian, Ferrel G. Camp, Joyce A. Camp, Ruth Fridinger, Stephen C. Cesar, Bonnie L. Cesar, John C. Sanders, Ann Marie Sanders, John R. McClure, Rebecca D. McClure, Jay Elliott Gordon, Faye H. Gordon, Gene S. Edmonds, Helen E. Edmonds, F. Bruce Pearch, Florence Pearch, Carl Spahn, Jr., Debra A. Spahn, Ralph J. DeFillips, Dorothy J. Phillips, Mary R. Trogdon, Linda S. Toleno, Sally Davis, Stanley L. Smith, Doris H. Smith, Gerald W. Krimminger, Joyce A. Krimminger, Anthony P. Sapienza, Anne M. Sapienza, Daniel P. Mageras, Janet A. Mageras, Earl Downing, Sharon B. Downing, Robert Steele, Lori Steele, B.L. Sizemore, D. Ann Sizemore, Roger W. Huffman, Patricia W. Huffman, John W. O'Connor, James W. McMaster, Lana McMaster, Thomas L. Herb, Joy Herb, James W. McArthur, Theodore M. Cooley, Ralph W. Pope, Wallace H. Burgess, Gordon McCoy, Mary J. McCoy, John F. Barna, John Capito, Jr., Margaret B. Capito, Harry W. Wayne, David A. Dunlap, Elizabeth Stover, Americo R. Caggiano, Viola Catherine Caggiano, W.B. Seddinger, Reggie K. Safrit, Lori Anne Boyle, Linda Boyle, Fredrick J. Saleeby, Reid S. Saleeby, John G. Underwood, Jr., M/M Edward Gregory, Johnny T. Gregory, Randy S. Hammett, DPS Investment, Francis Feltham, Thomas and Eunice Kirby, Joseph Jengehino, Maryann J. Jengehino, Allan Warrington, Greenville Progressive Womens Investment Club, Robert A. Jackson, Richard Arvonio, Cherry Grove Sales, Inc., Frederick S. Carter and Patsy S. Carter, Respondents, v. CITY OF NORTH MYRTLE BEACH, Appellant. |
W. Cliff Moore, III, of Ellis, Lawhorne & Sims; William H. Davidson, II, and Andrew F. Lindemann, both of Davidson, Morrison & Lindemann, all of Columbia, for appellant.
Newman Jackson Smith, of Nelson, Mullins, Riley & Scarborough, of Charleston, for respondents.
This is a takings and inverse condemnation case. Sea Cabins on the Ocean IV Homeowners' Association, Inc. and numerous owners of units in the homeowners' association (Sea Cabins) filed this action against the City of North Myrtle Beach alleging a taking and condemnation of their private pier. The Master-in-Equity found a taking had occurred and awarded Sea Cabins $900,000.00 in compensation. The City appeals. We reverse.
Sea Cabins was created by master deed in 1980 pursuant to the South Carolina Horizontal Property Regime Act, S.C.Code Ann. § 27-31-10, et seq. (1976). One of the common elements of Sea Cabins was a fishing pier that extended approximately 900 feet into the ocean. The pier was built with authorization under Act 499, 1955 S.C. Acts 1083-1084. On September 21, 1989, Hurricane Hugo damaged a significant amount of the pier.
In a letter dated February 20, 1990, the City informed Sea Cabins it was considering the adoption of an ordinance to declare the remaining portion of the pier a nuisance. The resolution, adopted on March 6, 1990, stated the pier would be removed if it was not repaired. Several extensions were requested and granted for the repair of the pier.
On April 9, 1990, the City passed the Beach Franchise Ordinance, which required a license agreement be entered into with the City as a condition for obtaining a building permit. The agreement being negotiated between Sea Cabins and the City required the pier be open to the public. On June 28, 1990, Sea Cabins instituted an action in the United States District...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Mellen v. Lane
...decided by a Master-in-Equity, "this Court will correct any error of law." Sea Cabins on the Ocean IV Homeowners Ass'n, Inc. v. City of North Myrtle Beach, 337 S.C. 380, 388, 523 S.E.2d 193, 197 (Ct.App.1999). "We must affirm the Master's factual findings unless there is no evidence reasona......
-
Sea Cabins v. City of North Myrtle Beach
...during the alleged temporary taking, the Court of Appeals unanimously reversed. Sea Cabins on the Ocean IV Homeowners Assoc., Inc., v. City of North Myrtle Beach, 337 S.C. 380, 523 S.E.2d 193 (Ct.App. 1999). The Court granted Sea Cabins' petition for a writ of certiorari to review the Court......
- State v. Sierra
-
Frampton v. S.C. Dep't of Transp.
...taking of the owner's property without just compensation is an action at law.” Sea Cabins on the Ocean IV Homeowners Ass'n, Inc. v. City of N. Myrtle Beach, 337 S.C. 380, 388, 523 S.E.2d 193, 197 (Ct.App.1999)aff'd sub nom. Sea Cabins on Ocean IV Homeowners Ass'n, Inc. v. City of N. Myrtle ......
-
Palazzolo, Lucas, and Penn Central: the Need for Pragmatism, Symbolism, and Ad Hoc Balancing
...coal estate). 148. See supra note 42 and accompanying text. 149. See Cabins on the Ocean IV Homeowners Ass'n v. City of N. Myrtle Beach, 523 S.E.2d 193, 200 (S.C. Ct. App. 1999) (holding that the right to build a pier is not a separate right), aff'd on other grounds, 548 S.E.2d 595 (S.C. 20......