Carlton's Estate, In re, 75-1874
Decision Date | 14 January 1977 |
Docket Number | No. 75-1874,75-1874 |
Citation | 348 So.2d 896 |
Parties | In re ESTATE of Perry CARLTON, Deceased. Lucy Jane Carlton ROGERS, Appellant, v. Alberta Carlton HAYES, Ruby C. Teague, Charles H. Carlton, et al., Appellees. |
Court | Florida District Court of Appeals |
Robert Jackson, Law Offices of Jackson & Clem, Vero Beach, for appellant.
Raymond E. Ford, Fort Pierce, and John T. Brennan, Brennan, McAliley, Albury & Hayskar, Fort Pierce, for appellees.
Lucy Carlton Rogers appeals from a circuit court adjudication in the Estate of Perry Carlton, who died intestate April 4, 1970, that Lucy, adopted daughter of the intestate's deceased brother Lindley, is not an heir at law of the intestate. At the instance of nieces, nephews and others claiming through deceased nieces and nephews, the circuit court held that Lucy's claim is foreclosed by the Supreme Court's decision in In re Hewett's Estate, 153 Fla. 137, 13 So.2d 904 (1943), and that legislation expanding the rights of adopted children since 1941, the critical date in Hewett, does not affect the result. 1
At the times relevant in Hewett and in the present case the order of devolution of an intestate's property was provided by § 731.23, F.S., in relevant part as follows:
In rejecting Lucy's claim as the adopted daughter of Perry Carlton's brother, the circuit court in this case resolved the controversy on the principal if not the only theory there submitted by Lucy, namely, that legislation intervening since 1941 reversed the result in Hewett, supra, n. 1, 13 So.2d 904. We sustain Lucy's claim as a matter of law, but by another route.
The Court in Hewett held that the claimant, though by statute the heir at law and lineal descendant of her adoptive father, §§ 72.06, 731.30, F.S.1941, could not claim to be a descendant of her father's mother Thankful Collwell, the deceased aunt of the intestate. The Hewett court rejected claimant's argument
"that an adopted child could not 'for the purpose of inheritance be regarded as a lineal descendant of its adopting parents' without also being regarded as the lineal descendant of its adopting parents' ancestors . . .." 13 So.2d at 906.
Therefore, the Hewett claimant was not among the "descendants of such . . . deceased (uncles and aunts)," to whom the estate passed by operation of § 731.23(6)(b), F.S.1941, supra.
In the present case the question is not whether statutes have made an adopted child the descendant of her father's ancestors but rather whether statutes have made an adopted child a descendant of her father, that is to say, a descendant of the deceased brother of Perry Carlton, the intestate. Sec. 731.23(5), F.S.1969, supra. Sec. 731.30, F.S.1941 and 1969, providing that the...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Lewis v. Green
... ... 389 So.2d 235 ... 11 A.L.R.4th 927 ... William G. LEWIS, as Executor of the Estate of Beulah Robinson Lewis, Appellant, ... Raleigh Travers GREEN, III; Jan Singleton Carter, William ... ...
-
Estate of Carlton, In re
...We issued the Writ and have heard argument of the parties. After hearing argument and upon further consideration of the matter (See 348 So.2d 896 (Fla.App.)) we have determined that the Court is without jurisdiction. Therefore, the Writ must be and is hereby discharged and the Petition for ......
-
McIlvaine v. AmSouth Bank, N.A.
... ... trustee, therefore, sought instructions as to whether, under the terms of the trust, Tommy's estate or the successor beneficiaries were entitled to the dividend ... AmSouth also ... ...
-
Dodds v. Deposit Guaranty Nat. Bank, 51257
... ... Armstrong, Jr., their guardian ad litem ... DEPOSIT GUARANTY NATIONAL BANK, Executor of Estate of Mrs ... Bettye P. Brown Dodds ... No. 51257 ... Supreme Court of Mississippi ... June 6, ... ...