Carroll v. Silk

Citation11 S.W. 116
PartiesCARROLL <I>v.</I> SILK.<SMALL><SUP>1</SUP></SMALL>
Decision Date10 February 1888
CourtSupreme Court of Texas

Howard Finley, for plaintiff in error.

GAINES, J.

The defendant in error brought this suit in the court below to recover of plaintiff in error's intestate the precise sum of $500, exclusive of interest. It is held that the district court has no jurisdiction of a suit for this amount. Railway Co. v. Rainbolt, 67 Tex. 654, 4 S. W. Rep. 356. The judgment for the defendant in error must therefore be reversed, and the suit dismissed. Reversed and dismissed.

1. Publication delayed by failure to obtain copy of opinion at time of its delivery.

To continue reading

Request your trial
11 cases
  • Dillion v. Dillion
    • United States
    • Court of Appeals of Texas
    • May 20, 1925
    ...district court has no jurisdiction where the matter in controversy is of the exact value of $500, exclusive of interest. Carroll v. Silk, 70 Tex. 23, 11 S. W. 116; Garrison v. Pac. Exp. Co., 69 Tex. 345, 6 S. W. 842, Const. art. 5, §§ 8 and It follows that unless the plaintiff had the right......
  • Humphrey v. Works
    • United States
    • Supreme Court of Oklahoma
    • June 20, 1913
    ...in an action to recover money of the exact amount of $ 500. Railway Company v. Rambolt, 67 Tex. 654, 4 S.W. 356; Carroll v. Silk, 70 Tex. 23, 11 S.W. 116; Betterton v. Echols, 85 Tex. 212, 20 S.W. 63; Erwin v. Blanks, 60 Tex. 583; Carney v. Marsalis, 77 Tex. 62, 13 S.W. 636; Garrison v. Exp......
  • Escue v. Hartley
    • United States
    • Court of Appeals of Texas
    • March 30, 1918
    ...jurisdiction: Railway Co. v. Rambolt, 67 Tex. 654, 4 S. W. 356; Garrison v. Pacific Express Co., 69 Tex. 345, 6 S. W. 842; Carroll v. Silk, 70 Tex. 23, 11 S. W. 116; Lazarus v. Swafford, 15 Tex. Civ. App. 367, 39 S. W. 389. The exception stated is established by the following cases: Erwin v......
  • Humphrey v. Coquillard Wagon Works
    • United States
    • Supreme Court of Oklahoma
    • June 20, 1913
    ...... recover money of the exact amount of $500. Railway. Company v. Rambolt, 67 Tex. 654, 4 S.W. 356; Carroll. v. Silk, 70 Tex. 23, 11 S.W. 116; Betterton v. Echols, 85 Tex. 212, 20 S.W. 63; Erwin v. Blanks, 60 Tex. 583; Carney v. Marsalis, 77. Tex. 62, ......
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT