Cartee v. Brewer
Decision Date | 17 May 1978 |
Docket Number | 61701,Nos. 61656,s. 61656 |
Citation | 265 N.W.2d 730 |
Parties | Elmer CARTEE, Jr., Appellant, v. Lou V. BREWER et al., Appellee. James HUGHES, Jr., Appellant, v. Roland McCAULEY et al., Appellee. |
Court | Iowa Supreme Court |
John P. Roehrick and John C. Wellman, Des Moines, for appellants.
Richard C. Turner, Atty. Gen., Ray Sullins, Asst. Atty. Gen., and Dan Johnston, County Atty., for appellee.
En banc.
In separate postconviction suits each petitioner contended § 801.5(3), The Code, supplement 1977, provides they are entitled to be sentenced anew upon their prior criminal convictions. In separate rulings filed in each action the trial courts rejected this contention. Upon petitioners' consolidated appeals we affirm.
On December 12, 1968 petitioner Cartee was convicted of second-degree murder in violation of § 690.3, The Code, 1966. He was thereupon sentenced to an indeterminate term of not to exceed 40 years. His conviction was affirmed in a prior appeal to us. State v. Cartee, 202 N.W.2d 93 (Iowa 1972).
On March 18, 1977 petitioner Hughes was sentenced to an indeterminate term of not to exceed five years for shoplifting in excess of $20 in violation of § 709.1 and § 709.2, The Code, 1977.
Under the new criminal code, which became effective January 1, 1978, second-degree murder carries a maximum sentence of 25 years. § 707.3 and § 902.9, The Code, supplement 1977. Under the new criminal code shoplifting is theft. § 714.1, The Code, supplement 1977. Where the value is between $50 and $100 theft is a serious misdemeanor. § 714.2(4), The Code, supplement 1977. Punishment for a serious misdemeanor is imprisonment not to exceed one year, or a fine not to exceed $1000, or both. § 903.1(2), The Code, supplement 1977.
Hence both petitioners would face substantially shorter sentences if they were to be punished under the new criminal code rather than under the provisions under which they were sentenced. The sole question in this appeal is their contention they are entitled to be sentenced anew under the lesser sentences now provided for their offenses.
I. A general revision of our criminal code became effective January 1, 1978. The Code, supplement 1977. In § 801.5, The Code, supplement 1977, the legislature addressed the question of applicability of the revision to offenses committed before its effective date. Section 801.5 provides in material part:
The question narrows to whether the language "provisions of this Act governing the release or discharge of prisoners", includes postconviction petitioners serving sentences imposed prior to the effective date of the Act. In urging they are so included petitioners argue § 246.38, The Code, provides a prisoner's discharge date is to be determined by the maximum time he is sentenced to serve. It is suggested the length of sentence helps determine discharge date and hence is "a provision governing discharge" under § 801.5(3).
Upon consideration we adopt the views expressed by the trial court in Webster District Court in its ruling:
To continue reading
Request your trial- Bornn v. Madagan
-
State v. Clark
...and not solicitation under section 705.1, since the specific substantive statute controls over the general statute. Cartee v. Brewer, 265 N.W.2d 730, 733 (Iowa 1978). II. Defendant argues the State failed to prove defendant persuaded or arranged for Officer Richardson to become a prostitute......
-
State v. Hubbs
...be resentenced under the new criminal code, which became effective January 1, 1978. This same issue was considered in Cartee v. Brewer, 265 N.W.2d 730 (Iowa 1978), and decided adversely to defendant's contention. We held there that § 801.5(3), The Code, Supplement 1977, does not apply to se......
-
State v. Bousman
...Therefore, because this case presents a question of statutory construction, Wiese does not control.3 The holding in Cartee v. Brewer, 265 N.W.2d 730, 733 (Iowa 1978), is not to the contrary. That case dealt with a substantially different question and considered a different subsection of the......