City of Bradenton v. Johnson
| Decision Date | 20 June 2008 |
| Docket Number | No. 2D07-1312.,2D07-1312. |
| Citation | 989 So.2d 25 |
| Parties | CITY OF BRADENTON, Florida, Appellant, v. Delane JOHNSON, Appellee. |
| Court | Florida District Court of Appeals |
Michael J. Roper and Dale A. Scott of Bell & Roper, Orlando, for Appellant.
Christopher E. Cosden of The Wilbur Smith Law Firm, Fort Myers, for Appellee.
The City of Bradenton appeals from the trial court's order granting Delane Johnson's petition for writ of mandamus. Because mandamus is not the appropriate vehicle to obtain relief in this case, we reverse. However, we do so without prejudice to Johnson to seek further relief in the circuit court.
City of Bradenton police officers approached Johnson during a robbery investigation and noticed that he had a large roll of cash, discovered to be $10,020, in his possession. Johnson stated that the money came from his mother's business. The officers arrested Johnson for a violation of section 896.102, Florida Statutes (2006), for failing to report receipt of more than $10,000 in currency received in trade or business.
While Johnson was being held in the county jail, police officers presented him with a document titled "Bradenton City Police Department, Bradenton, Florida, Contraband Forfeiture Agreement." The agreement stated that "[i]n consideration of the department forgoing its right to file an action under the Florida Contraband Forfeiture Act1 and to avoid the costs, delay and uncertainty of litigation to all parties," Johnson would surrender the money to the department and release the department from any damages, suits or claims related to the seizure of the property. It further required Johnson to acknowledge that he voluntarily agreed to enter into the agreement without benefit of counsel, waived the right to review of the agreement by a court, mediator or arbitrator, and waived the right to a jury trial. Johnson signed the agreement surrendering the money to the City. He was never charged with any crime.
Johnson later filed a petition for a writ of mandamus seeking to stop the Bradenton Police Department from entering into forfeiture contracts with arrestees and to require the City to file a civil action for forfeiture of the $10,020. The City moved to dismiss Johnson's petition. Following a hearing, the court denied the City's motion and granted Johnson's petition, finding, among other things, that the contract was invalid for lack of consideration. The trial court ordered the City to either properly pursue a forfeiture proceeding to obtain the money or to return the money to Johnson.
As the City argues, mandamus is a common law remedy to enforce an established legal right by compelling a...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Davis v. Sheridan Healthcare, Inc., Case Nos. 2D17-829
... ... Williams of Cozen O'Connor, Miami, for Appellee Sheridan Healthcare, Inc. David S. Johnson and Scott W. Anderson of Johnson Daboll Anderson, PLLC, Tampa, for Appellee Sheridan Radiology ... statutes rather than construe one statute as being meaningless or repealed by implication." City of Treasure Island v. Tahitian Treasure Island, LLC , 253 So. 3d 649, 659 (Fla. 2d DCA 2017) ... ...
-
City of Tarpon Springs v. PLANES
...II (the Family). Because mandamus is not the appropriate vehicle to obtain the relief sought, we reverse. See City of Bradenton v. Johnson, 989 So.2d 25 (Fla. 2d DCA 2008) (reversing a grant of a petition for mandamus on the basis of inappropriate relief sought but without prejudice to the ......
-
Manatee School Bd. v. Nationsrent, Inc.
... ... As the appellant, the School Board has the duty to make error clearly appear. See Lynn v. City of Fort Lauderdale, 81 So.2d 511, 513 (Fla.1955) ... Because the School Board has ... ...