City of Carthage v. Garner
Decision Date | 26 February 1908 |
Citation | 209 Mo. 688,108 S.W. 521 |
Parties | CITY OF CARTHAGE v. GARNER et al. |
Court | Missouri Supreme Court |
Appeal from the Circuit Court, Jasper County; Hugh Dabbs, Judge.
R. W. Garner and Joe Lawson were convicted of violating an ordinance prohibiting excavations in the city streets without a permit, and they appeal. Affirmed.
McReynolds & Halliburton, for appellants. J. D. Harris, for respondent.
This is a prosecution for the violation of an ordinance of the city of Carthage, instituted by proper information of the city attorney before the police judge of said city. Defendants were convicted in the police court, and appealed to the circuit court, wherein was had a trial upon an agreed statement of facts, at which trial defendants were again convicted by that court, and this appeal is the result. The case reaches this court by reason of a constitutional question.
The city of Carthage is a city of the third class. In 1895 said city passed an ordinance granting to the American Electric Telephone Company of Kokomo, Ind., the right to construct, operate, and maintain telephone lines and operate a telephone exchange in said city, which said franchise and right were duly accepted by said company. This ordinance is quite lengthy, and will not be set out, but such portions as may become necessary will be noted later. The remaining portion of such agreed statement of facts, which in addition to outside facts contains sections of different ordinances brought into question, is as follows:
Defendants prayed for a peremptory instruction, which was refused, and they were adjudged guilty of a violation of sections 553 and 554 of the Ordinances as above set out and as charged in the...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Breinig v. County of Allegheny
... ... Philadelphia v. Anderson, 142 Pa. 357, 21 A. 976, 12 L.R.A. 751; New Castle City v. Withers, 291 Pa. 216, 219, 139 A. 860. It may be estopped to deny the authority of its agents ... 1142, 287 S.W. 585 (mayor and city clerk to issue permits to haul swill); Carthage v. Garner, 209 Mo. 688, 108 S.W. 521 (city clerk to issue permits for street and sidewalk ... ...
-
Kalbfell v. City of St. Louis
... ... The governmental ... function involved may not be alienated, surrendered or ... abridged by municipal administrative officers. Carthage ... v. Garner, 209 Mo. 688, 108 S.W. 521; State ex rel ... v. Public Serv. Comm., 271 Mo. 270, 197 S.W. 56; ... Thompson v. City of St. Louis ... ...
-
Kalbfell v. City of St. Louis
...The governmental function involved may not be alienated, surrendered or abridged by municipal administrative officers. Carthage v. Garner, 209 Mo. 688, 108 S.W. 521; State ex rel. v. Public Serv. Comm., 271 Mo. 270, 197 S.W. 56; Thompson v. City of St. Louis (Mo.), 253 S.W. 969, 972[2]; Pot......
-
McGrath v. Meyers
... ... as valid Ordinance 2895 of the city of Sedalia. (a) An ... Ordinance 2895 of the city of Sedalia is void and ... unconstitutional as ... Co. v ... Manufacturers' Ry. Co., 230 Mo. 80; City of ... Carthage v. Garner, 209 Mo. 688; State v ... Thompson, 160 Mo. 333; St. Louis v. Lamp Co., ... 139 Mo ... ...