City of Somerville v. Dickerman

• Decision Date: 29 July 1879
• Citation: 127 Mass. 272
• Parties: City of Somerville v. George H. Dickerman
• Court: United States State Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts Supreme Court

127 Mass. 272

City of Somerville v. George H. Dickerman

Supreme Court of Massachusetts

July 29, 1879

Middlesex. Contract upon an award of arbitrators appointed under an agreement of submission to arbitration, under seal entered into by the plaintiff, as the party of the first part, and the defendant and others, as the parties of the second part, on June 3, 1872, and containing the following "Whereas, a certain street or town-way, known as Highland Avenue, has been duly laid out and established in said Somerville, extending from Central Street to Elm Street now, therefore, the parties whose land has been taken for the laying out of said street do hereby mutually covenant and agree to refer and submit to three arbitrators, to be appointed as hereinafter stated, the following matter, namely: To ascertain, determine and estimate the amount of damage sustained by the said parties of the second part severally in their property, by the laying out and construction of said street and taking of their land therefor (the said parties of the second part hereby severally releasing to said city the land so taken for the construction or laying out of said street), from Central to Elm Streets, as aforesaid, and likewise to ascertain, adjudge and determine the value of the benefit and advantage received by any real estate of the said parties of the second part therefrom, beyond the general advantage to all real estate in the said city of Somerville, and to assess or award to be paid a proportional share accordingly of the expense of laying out and constructing said street as aforesaid, upon said parties of the second part; provided, however, that such assessment upon said parties shall not exceed one half the amount of such adjudged benefit and advantage, and the award of said arbitrators, or a majority of them, shall be final." Then followed a provision in regard to the appointment of the arbitrators, and their mode of procedure.

At the trial in this court, before Ames, J., without a jury, it appeared that on November 2, 1869, Somerville, which was then a town, accepted the betterment laws then in force, namely, the Sts. of 1866, c. 174; 1868, c. 276; 1869, c. 169.

In 1871, the selectmen of the town altered and widened the existing portion of Highland Avenue, lying between Medford Street and its termination at Central Street, by the addition of ten feet on each side, making the same sixty feet wide; and, at the same time, and by the same act, laid out and extended the avenue sixty feet wide from Central Street to Elm Street.

At a town meeting held on April 27, 1871, in pursuance of an article in the warrant, "to see if the town will accept and approve the laying out, the alteration, widening and extension of Highland Avenue, on the report of the selectmen," the town accepted and approved such alteration, widening, extension, and laying out of Highland Avenue. In the report of the selectmen, no reference was made to the betterment law, and they awarded damages to only two persons whose lands were taken. After the acceptance by the town of the report of the selectmen, and at the same meeting, the town passed the following vote: "Voted, that the selectmen be instructed to assess the expense of the extension and alteration of Highland Avenue upon the abutters, under the provisions of the betterment law of the Commonwealth." But no assessment has been made, and no proceedings have been had by, in behalf of, or against, any of the abutters, on account of the widening or extension of Highland Avenue, except as herein stated.

At the time of the execution of the submission to arbitration, the new portion of the avenue, from Central Street to Elm...